News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by jacquesm on Thursday July 31, 2014 @06:00AM (#8113258)
It's an efficiency matter. The cylinder gives good electrode surface relative to the amount of matter contained. For a cube that ratio would be much worse, for a sphere it would be optimal, but spheres are harder to manufacture and connect to, as well as harder to stack in arrays. So we take a medium between the sphere and the cube and end up with a sweet spot in the cylindrical shape.
Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by SeanLuke on Thursday July 31, 2014 @07:55AM (#8113541)
This doesn't explain why LiPoly batteries are cuboids.
Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by jacquesm on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:36AM (#8113680)
Indeed it does not, this is about Tesla's and Panasonics 'gigafactory' which will make Lithium-Ion batteries in a cylindrical form factor.

Lithium Polymer batteries (or LiPo for short) are a special case of Lithium-Ion batteries. They are sold in a 'pouch' format (and they are not the first to use a format like that, for instance, in the polaroid cartridges there used to be a battery in a similar form factor (polapulse)).

The reason why LiPo batteries are not so constrained in shape as their siblings is that the electrolyte is a liquid. Solid electrolyte batteries are typically much more constrained in terms of shapes.

This is also why regular car batteries (lead-acid) can be block shaped, the acid is also a liquid.

The polapulse was an interesting battery, it only had to fire the camera 10 times but was quite high current. The packaging constraints of the cartridge dictated the battery geometry and so a flat pouch like battery was born.

LiPo batteries exist in all kinds of interesting shapes and sizes too.

Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by tobz on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:45AM (#8113990)
Also, and this is entirely speculation and I'd love to hear a battery engineer confirm this, but: if you're packaging together cylindrical batteries, it inherently gives you more air channels between the batteries to promote cooling. When you're talking tens of kilowatts, both in discharge and charge rates, the percentage that ends up as waste heat suddenly becomes a whole lot of heat. You probably wouldn't want a maximally stuffed cavity with these packs turning into a single, massive chunk of thermal mass.

EDIT: looks like I was firsted somewhere below, doh!

Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by jacquesm on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:08AM (#8114155)
But you're 100% on point there. That's a side benefit from having those cylindrical cells.
Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by TD-Linux on Thursday July 31, 2014 @08:27PM (#8117793)
This is exactly backwards. Traditional Li-Ion batteries have a liquid electrolyte, and Li-Poly have a solid polymer electrolyte. Both batteries consist of anode/electrolyte/cathode rolled up. In the case of a "pouch" cell, they are rolled up flat, and a cylinderical cell has them rolled up in a cylinder. There is actually no limitation for the shape - you can totally make a Li-ion battery with liquid electrolyte in a prism - many cell phone batteries do this.

Li-ion, due to the liquid, needs a hard metal case, whereas li-poly can often get away with a foil pouch. The surface area per volume of a cylinder is less, as well as easier to make structurally sturdy, which means less weight is spent in the casing. Tesla cares more about weight than volume, so this is an acceptable tradeoff.

Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by jacquesm on Friday August 01, 2014 @10:18AM (#8119916)
Interesting! I just spent the better part of today reading up on all this because I found it hard to accept that I'd remember something so terribly wrong. Turns out that the names have changed over time to denote various packages and gel/liquid/solid combinations. Wikipedia has a whole page on the subject and it almost seems as if they made the naming of these battery classes confusing on purpose:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_polymer_battery

Enjoy the read, I certainly did and it turns out the situation is a lot more complex (also historically) than I remembered it, but my memory wasn't quite as faulty as you made me feel initially (fortunately!).

Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by Retric on Thursday July 31, 2014 @09:31AM (#8113905)
Why not stack flat plates like a car battery?
Re:Panasonic and Tesla Sign Agreement for the Gigafactory by jacquesm on Thursday July 31, 2014 @10:07AM (#8114151)
Because it would be more expensive and the space gain would be very small.

Battery geometry is mostly dictated by physics and economics, even though a flat plate battery would be denser the gains in density would be off-set by the increase in cost and in the end the wasted space doubles as a cooling channel so you might end up having to separate your flat plates by periodic air channels anyway.

The reason why flat plates are better in some applications (for instance, for starter batteries in cars) is because those batteries are optimized for very high current during very short bursts of time. 300 Amps @ 12V is 3.6KW out of a very compact little box. The power generated from that little package is extremely impressive (if you pull the distributor cap on your car (if you have an old car) you can actually move the car for a bit on the starter engine in first gear or reverse!) but because of the short duration the power absorbed by the battery is relatively small (current is absorbed by the internal resistance of the battery during charge and discharge leading to a warming up of the battery).

But it does not last for very long so heat removal is not usually a problem, and the charge currents are reasonably low, so again no big problem in removing the heat (low current, longer time).

With electric vehicles the situation is reversed, the discharge time is relatively long (hours) but the charge times are getting ever shorter which means packs have to be actively cooled to avoid overheating, and the easiest way to do that is to flow air through gaps in the cells.