I've gone this route replacing a niche software product running on MS Access with a newer, better, faster one. It met all the requirements. It fixed all their pain points. It followed the latest usability guidelines. If this office had adopted it and referred it over to other offices, I would have been as well-off as the dentist described by GP.
It fell flat. They paid me for the product, said it was really great, but ... none of their reps wanted to make the changeover. It was not that the learning curve was too high - it was that any learning curve was too high.
To clarify: anything different from what they were doing every day for the past 10 years meant that they had to think about the software they were using and not the job that they were doing. And that slowed them down - the fact that it would have been a temporary slowdown was irrelevant.
I've seen the same thing played out in my eye dr's office. THey had an old 3270-based system that they used via emulator - and they could fly with that. They knew all the shotcuts, didn't even have to look at the csreen.
Over the period of a year and a half I watched them get a new system in. It had all the same features and a ton more. And it slowed them down to a crawl.
They reverted back to their 3270 based system by the time a year had passed.
So you make an assumption that newer is better - but remember that's your assumption, and it's not one that the targe audience (ultimately the end-users, not just the people you're selling to higher up the chain) will necessarily share.
My wife is just out of residency running her own medical practice. She went with the latest-and-greatest electronic medical record system that's all either web of iPad based, with all her records stored in the cloud and fully integrated with similarly advanced billing software. It's pretty good, and does most of what we need well. It's definitely head-and-shoulders above any other software out there that's specific to her specialty.
Right now she's considering buying another practice, and during the pre-purchase process the ~65 year old doc was talking about how fantastic their medical record/billing software suite is. Does everything they could ever want it to do, everyone in the office loves it, etc..
So, I ask for a demo, and he loads up a Filemaker database running off the server in the back room. Looks like it was designed in 1996, offers zero web-connectivity, and they're 100% happy with it.
That practice would never consider "upgrading" to the software we use. We'd never consider the software they use. There's a generational gap in medicine and dentistry, just like everything else. The more young docs come out of medical school, the higher their expectations will be for things like GUI, UX/UI and mobile connectivity.
For your wife, in ten or twenty years that all-touch cloud-based system will be as the Filemaker system is for the 65 year old doc, when the next generation of latest and greatest comes around.
It's not about the abilities of the technology, IMO, but about people's resistance to change for the sake of change. If what they have works well for them, there is very little impetus to accept change, particularly when technology is not their actual business.
Just like all the changes in gmail are not welcome by everyone, but you can't just choose to stick with the 2004 version.
Or, maybe, she'll get an email saying "we're sorry but we'll shut down the service, the company is closing". Or "we're glad to announce we're acquired by our competitor, see how you account will be migrated."
There is a finite number of times that a small business owner can say the words, "I'm sorry, I can't schedule your appointment right now because our system is down" before never saying that again becomes their number one software-related concern.
Quite possibly other dentists/programmers figured that they could sleep their way through all this but in that case they more than likely found themselves upstaged by a newcomer that did get with the times.
Perhaps that is the real lesson of DentalSoft and Dent.io and dental.com - disrupt yourself before someone else does.
I can tell you after working with hundreds of different businesses and individuals that the things that HN programmers think is important about software is very different from what the end users think is important, especially in retail and service industries.
I doubt they'll ever change it.
It's just that life cannot be that simple otherwise I want to start a VC that just finds clever coders with middle aged domain experts and fires out dozens of winners and dozens more also-rans
Guy had 7 dentists in his family. Built a website for his dad's practice, started successfully selling it to other dentists.
Instead of dogfooding it themselves, these dentists should hire professional software developers to build custom software and tell them what features to build based on their knowledge and experience. Then again, everyone is a critic.
Isn't that against the HN mantra that everyone should do the development themselves? Perhaps that is why you deleted that part?
I'm not familiar with any HN mantra that you're referring to.
Many business models these days are 'x' on the web, where 'x' really does not improve by being on the web and practice management is a prime example of that. If you don't believe that try to explain to a dentist why they need redundant internet access to keep their practice running in case they have internet problems when right now they can do so just fine without any access at all.
Web apps have lots of upside but they also come with a set of requirements that is not always practical or even desired.
On top of that you discount domain knowledge which I think is a very important part of any successful business in an area like the one you describe.
If customers expect to be able to book online (and as a user of services like ZocDoc, FreshDirect, Instacart, and Homejoy I do expect these things now), then providers who do (theoretically) provide these things will have an advantage of those who don't.
Not going to argue for or against the 'upside' part, as I do think that is debatable, at least in the short-term. A big part of this is avoiding 'downside' by not adapting, IMO.
You do have a market: new dentists. But old ones are just happily going to roll along with their gear until either they or the gear dies of old age. And then they or their heirs will sell the practice to a new dentist, who will have to wonder about re-keying all the old data into your shiny new software or to focus on what he's best at: dentistry.
Because our dentist/programmer was a smart fellow (he'd have to be, given that he's active in two different complex fields) he foresaw that selling the software once was a nice proposition, but selling it repeatedly would be even better.
Hence the annual 'maintenance fee', of about 1,000 euros per dentist using his software. Do you know how many dentists there are in nl?
So, instead of going for venture capital this dentist-wannabe-programmer built himself a money printing press that printed more money than he and his extended family will ever be able to spend. At the end of every year the maintenance payments roll in and he's laughing all the way to the bank. This money machine has been printing since the early 90's and does not look like it will stop printing any day soon. And no VC made a single cent on any of that. He's so solidly entrenched that trying to attack his position is a losing proposition.
I like the avc blog, but it would be nice if stories like this were grounded in reality rather than fiction.