News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by JohnTHaller on Sunday July 27, 2014 @11:38PM (#8095040)
A user being able to give a negative review for a game not supporting language X when the game, like every single app in the app store, lists exactly what languages it supports on the download page devalues legitimate reviews and is the sign of a broken app review process.
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by qzervaas on Sunday July 27, 2014 @11:44PM (#8095056)
Totally agree. Even the ability to respond as on we can on Google Play would be a massive improvement (or even up/down vote like on HN)
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by interpol_p on Sunday July 27, 2014 @11:59PM (#8095101)
I think there is a down/up vote mechanism in iTunes ("Was this review helpful? Yes/No"). But I'm not sure if that's visible on actual devices.
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by qzervaas on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:03AM (#8095114)
Oh right. Very rarely do I view the App Store in iTunes. The only legitimately useful reason I have for doing so is to quickly see rankings in a specific country's store (but doing so removes all Genius & iTunes Match data, so is pretty annoying also).

Before Google switched over to Wallet and allowed responses to reviews, you could get a fair bit of info about each sale (for a paid app), including often their email address.

I would often email people seeking clarification when they would review "XYZ doesn't work for me" in a bid to fix it.

On one hand it might seem a bit creepy, but on the other hand, they were my customer and I was provided with information about them. I never asked for a better review, just for information to improve the product.

They rarely replied.

Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by interpol_p on Monday July 28, 2014 @02:36AM (#8095484)
I think giving customer emails to app developers is plain wrong. I'd be creeped out if a developer emailed me after I reviewed his or her app.

Developers shouldn't be so concerned with reviews. Reviews are for other customers, not for developers to read. I say this as a developer who has received reviews that contain misinformation about my product (lying that it's going to be pulled from the App Store, for example). I made a decision to stop reading reviews and just focus on building something I'm proud of. This has paid off for me.

I also make it easy for customers to email me directly in my apps. I get a lot of good feedback this way — and I can send a response that is actually solicited.

Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by qzervaas on Monday July 28, 2014 @02:42AM (#8095493)
Agreed on the first point. I'm glad they removed it. But we had so few tools at our disposal, and the reviews can mean so much.

I'm the same though, completely averse when it comes to looking at reviews, good and bad. I hate it.

Your last point is really good, I've always thought there should be super easy mechanisms like this (although I'm often guilty of not providing, aside from email address or Twitter handles).

The Google Maps feedback mechanism works really well - includes a screenshot and a bunch of diagnostics info. The only thing I don't like about it is you need to shake to trigger it, meaning most people don't know about it.

Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by CmonDev on Monday July 28, 2014 @07:14AM (#8096070)
You think that is bad? How would you like this type of Android/Windows Phone reviews: "It's a good game, would give it 5 star if it was free :)))))"?
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by baddox on Monday July 28, 2014 @01:09AM (#8095275)
How would you fix this? Would you want Apple to have to approve every review? Even if they did, people could just lie about their reasons.
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by prawn on Monday July 28, 2014 @01:45AM (#8095386)
Having the ability to respond to a review would be helpful. (TripAdvisor allows this.)

We currently have reviews implying that our dictionary is missing basic words when in fact I think many people would think there are simply too many words that are valid in English and will surprise people.

Review replies would at least improve context even if it didn't change the ratings themselves.

[deleted]
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by qzervaas on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:14AM (#8095150)
There is a specific field on the App Store listing that says:

"Language: English"

I don't think it's a valid complaint, but it's a complaint nonetheless, and their complaint holds as much weight as someone complaining for something such as an app crashing. So we can only do what we can do, which is either add more languages, or tell them multiple times.

[deleted]
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by gress on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:33AM (#8095199)
It makes no sense at all to make feature requests in a review. Reviews are for other users to read. Feature requests should be sent to the developer.
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by frankacter on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:34AM (#8095201)
A negative review should not be a mechanism for a feature and/or translation request.

There are specific links provided in iTunes to "Triplezero Web Site" and "Hexiled Support" where these kind of requests should be made.

Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by FroshKiller on Monday July 28, 2014 @10:13AM (#8096779)
But users aren't QA testers. There's no way they "should" do anything. They're going to report feedback by the path of least resistance. Communicating through a review gives a user a lot of bang for their buck, because it's highly visible. Plus, lots of apps prompt users to leave reviews. I've never seen one that solicits feedback like that along any other channel.
Re:Apple Featured My Game, Here's Why I Changed It by qzervaas on Monday July 28, 2014 @12:25AM (#8095178)
I can't find it either. I think I could reword this general topic to: "A lot more people from non-English first language countries are using our game, holy crap, we need more languages" ;)