News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by lifeisstillgood on Sunday July 20, 2014 @03:33PM (#8061247)
In app purchases exist because there is no free market for apps - everything is purchased through two portals, who set the expected prices and act as unsupervised quality controllers. Because the prices are so low in app purchases and super-star hits are the only ways to profit.

If there was a free market here, there would not be any need for this, products would be priced at sustainable levels, and I as a parent would never ever ever purchase a game that had in app purchases.

I would rather that I could download apps from anywhere and there was still a rating and quality mechanism. Many options exist for that. But I will take this as an alternative

I think the European Union has this weird attitude that a free market works the best and where there is no free market then there should be regulation to guide the path towards the ideal, or there should be protection against the excesses of the unfree market. I, in the main, agree. It all kind of depends on your definition of free and regulation.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by watwut on Sunday July 20, 2014 @03:50PM (#8061298)
Free market drives prices down. That is what it is supposed to do. How exactly is it supposed to fix what they consider false "free" labels on apps? Products are not priced on sustainable levels, because sustainably priced app will loose against the one priced as "free".
Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by lifeisstillgood on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:16PM (#8061539)
No, free markets find the market clearing level. That's what they are supposed to do. Driving prices under water just means some providers drown and the others raise their prices once the cut throat competition dies off.

But if there was not just one or two portals, then the normal mechanisms of product discovery would take place in which advertising, quality, reputation and luck would differentiate products and allow prices to reflect costs.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by fidotron on Sunday July 20, 2014 @04:08PM (#8061337)
It's even worse than that.

The way startup funding for the cowboy end of the games business works allows the well funded companies to give much more away. What has occurred is the stakes are now out of control. Admittedly a hit game can bring in hundreds of millions, but to make or market it you'll need to spend a very significant fraction of that. This has the side effect of encouraging wild conservatism of design and price gouging as risk minimisation strategies.

The mobile part of the industry at this point needs someone to do what Nintendo did in the 80s, but it's totally unclear who or how that could possibly happen.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by watwut on Sunday July 20, 2014 @04:50PM (#8061458)
It is even worst then that. Even big AAA hit games are often loose money projects due to insane development costs. Game studios that produced great games close every month. Big publishers (EA) have track record of destroying brought successful studios within two years. Small developers struggle and close even more often.

Games seems to be extremely hard business these days.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by raverbashing on Sunday July 20, 2014 @04:43PM (#8061429)
"needs someone to do what Nintendo did in the 80s"

What exactly? Genuinely curious.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by k-mcgrady on Sunday July 20, 2014 @03:41PM (#8061273)
How would an open market fix this? Consumers have shown they no longer want to pay for anything. Movies, music, or apps. There are some people though who are happy to pay large amounts of money. In-app purchases allow those people to spend and the people who don't want to pay don't have to. In a more open market consumers still wouldn't want to pay for apps so in-app purchases would still be necessary.
Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by lifeisstillgood on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:25PM (#8061560)
Everyone has always not wanted to pay for anything. It's only recently been possible. And I disagree - a free market contains information about the cost of a product - but this information is not readily available at purchase time. It's like buying a car and not knowing the mpg - and the manufacturer gets 70% of your petrol purchases. In that case there is every incentive to sell cars doing 5 miles a gallon and less.

An open market fixes an awful lot of things - as long as it is an open market. I will add that this mobile app market is massively dominated by two players and that if mobile comms is as important to the next decade as we think it is, that is bad for everyone.

Apple should not have a lock on the software that runs the lives of half the western world. No one should.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by perlpimp on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:16PM (#8061541)
At least giving way for paid upgrades should sort of fix that, giving developers genuine motive not to produce this crap.

I have been annoyed by upgrades to apps that litter screen with triggers to buy new stuff. For example flightradar24 I bought a full version of the app. In an update they positioned tiggers on every city to get me to buy upgrade for every city to view departure and arrival time. Suddenly my app is visually broken and I have to pay for the upgrade to fix it. And I can't even downgrade. I really don't care about departure/arrival schedules for airports... this does not seem right to me.

I guess that breaks one of the core rules of the interface design - of least surprise. (or recurring one that turns into a severe irritation).

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by josephlord on Sunday July 20, 2014 @03:45PM (#8061285)
I fail to understand why the prices would rise to sustainable levels if there was the free market you envisage. Where would this "rating and qualiy mechanism" come from?
Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by lifeisstillgood on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:12PM (#8061528)
Ok - it would hit a market clearing level. That would either be sustainable or people would stop making games tha cost more than they made in profit.

I however despair - film studios and game studios regularly go bankrupt yet there is no shortage of subsidy for the next

Quality mechanisms are a viable function of markets - whatever checks apple does could be done by any other body that can be paid for it. A label of "safe to download" is valuable. A simple central registry and hashes would be one way to do it.

Overall I think In app purchases are shit, in the way paying people in company money to spend in company store was shit. In some cases an in app purchase is convenient but in the vast majority of cases (read games) half the game time is geared towards "buy more". It poisons the game, the trust between gamer and game writer and adds no value to the world.

This is not the manufacturing base we can build a prosperous new society on.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by josephlord on Sunday July 20, 2014 @06:11PM (#8061719)
But with a virtual good the marginal cost of production is zero so most traditional economic theory breaks down. I think the current market shows that plenty of people make games despite the fact that most are unlikely to make a profit. The fact that there are some mega-hits especially superficially simple games like Flappy Bird tempts people in with hope that in most cases isn't fulfilled.

Who do you picture paying for the quality checking body? Consumers won't normally pay and if the developers pay then the incentives are all wrong.

I agree consumable in-app purchases in games are usually shit. I can live with charging for more levels although it might be good if there could be reviews of the particular purchases. Also the only way to currently offer a trial is to use in-app purchases.

To declare an interest I do have a non-game app with in-app purchases. In-app purchases are currently the only way to offer a try before you buy experience. I offer an "Everything" purchase and some separate features intended to justify the everything price and to steer people to that purchase.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by lifeisstillgood on Sunday July 20, 2014 @07:12PM (#8061854)
I don't think marginal cost of production is a factor here.

Apps today feel like wheat production in mid west in the late nineteenth century - soooo much of it that Chicago became rich while farmers simply sold for less than the cost of transport. Eventually prices became more same but it hurt - a lot.

Quality checking bodies are an interesting problem. Consumer magazines (Which? in UK) are always struggling, but do their best. But in the end we regulate what we care about - making heart pacemakers. Guess what it's not a free market. Making cars or houses or kettles. Standards bodies and regulations and so on.

Maybe apps aren't important enough to regulate. For consumer games, I would probably agree, but that's not what I think the future of mobile is. I remember Sinclairs and Commodores and they were all about games. Maybe Microsoft is right and frankly Apple is going to die in the consumer space again while all the money is in business mobiles.

I'm not convinced but I am convinced that mobile computing matters more than just games.

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by josephlord on Sunday July 20, 2014 @08:03PM (#8061973)
You talked about market clearing and I'm not sure the concept makes any sense in the absence of a marginal cost of production.

Wouldn't wheat be the perfect example of a free market? There might be reasons to dislike the lack of choice of app stores but I think it is completely orthogonal to the oversupply and the pricing issues you talk about.

In the UK all sales to consumers are regulated to some extent (trading standards, Unfair Commercial Practices Directive).

In terms of something like Which? It takes a lot of time and staff to do well, if you think that you can make a serious go of app reviews on that scale good luck to you but I don't think the market will support it (it may not even support the level of checking that Apple does).

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by lifeisstillgood on Monday July 21, 2014 @03:11PM (#8065453)
> You talked about market clearing and I'm not sure the concept makes any sense in the absence of a marginal cost of production.

I would respectfully disagree. Market clearing is I think technically the price for the next unit of production, but even in a world of zero marginal cost (not quite true) then the capital cost still needs to be paid back (laptop, time spent coding flappy up and flappy down). So perhaps the clearing price is the expected number if sales divided by capex?

As for setting up which?, no thank you :-) But Apples main justification for App Store is to provide a safe user experience. And I think that has value even if I fail against it. I think I is much more viable to label or test all apps than all websites and people at least pay attention to googles "this web site is not safe"

I have sadly kind of forgotten where this thread started as my HN times are about 12 hours apart, and yet I have been surprised that wondering around saying "free market good" has been taken quite badly.

I am in favour of regulation btw (far more than I think we are over regulated at least)

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by josephlord on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @09:23AM (#8074211)
>> You talked about market clearing and I'm not sure the concept makes any sense in the absence of a marginal cost of production.

> I would respectfully disagree. Market clearing is I think technically the price for the next unit of production, but even in a world of zero marginal cost (not quite true) then the capital cost still needs to be paid back (laptop, time spent coding flappy up and flappy down). So perhaps the clearing price is the expected number if sales divided by capex?

This is closer to reality (and further from economic theory but that is a different rant[0]).

The trouble is to decide whether to make the investment of that capital cost you need to rely on that other economics assumption: perfect information. The real world doesn't provide perfect information of future customer behaviour so you don't know at the start if you are making Flappy Bird or Floppy Bird. Once you have made it your aim is to maximise your income from it (given the zero marginal cost in the App store). That maximisation needs to occur at a time when the capital cost has already been spent so the capex doesn't actually affect the price you charge. Even if you are making a loss increasing the price doesn't help as less people will buy it (you were already at the profit maximisation point) and if you were making a profit cutting the price reduces the profit.

Note that even the information at the time to set the price isn't available so you are guessing again there without the economists perfect information assumption.

Free markets are good but especially in the real world they are not always optimal and market failure isn't unusual. I think app review (at least the keeping malware out, not necessarily the Apple payment lock in part) is a public good but one that would be hard to get people to voluntarily pay for separately and some of the benefit is communal (you benefit from me not having a malware infested phone). We might end up in agreement here.

Yeah, regulation is a balancing act.

[0] http://www.amazon.co.uk/Debunking-Economics-Revised-Expanded...

Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by Oletros on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:09PM (#8061519)
You can buy apps for Android in more than one store and, even, you don't need an store at all to buy apps
Re:Europe Wants Apple and Google to Fix In-App Payments Problem by chrismcb on Sunday July 20, 2014 @08:53PM (#8062089)
If there were true free markets for games there would still be freemium apps.