When a primal tribe beats on a drum they've just invented music. When a computer beats on a drum it has been told by some human to beat a drum.
Well yeah, it seems likely that if a computer ever becomes really intelligent, it has been built by a human. So?
For that to happen though we have a bunch of formidable hurdles to cross, and in spite of all our processing power and data storage capability we have not yet been able to simulate the intelligence of even an insect or a small mammal.
Whether an AI is built by humans or aliens or comes in to being through some freak coincidence is irrelevant.
As long as it takes a human with their intelligence to tell a computer what to do it has not achieved intelligence, merely the capability to follow instructions very precisely.
This is possible, but not a certainty.
Physics as you know it ('classical physics') stops making sense at that level, things no longer have an apparent causal relationship.
What Roger Penrose argues in his book 'the emperors new mind' is that 'mind' springs from these effects.
He suspects that if we simply follow the classical physics rules that we will end up on a dead end and that it will take a full blown quantum simulation of a whole brain in order to simulate one with the emergent behaviour that is being sought.
I don't think it's me who is misunderstanding the discussion here. You're using double standards.
When a primal tribe is beating on drums: music. When a computer builds a primitive melody? That's not music! Those are just bits and bytes!
If I follow your logic to the extreme a computer can never compose music because there will always be a human who built the computer, or built the computer that built the computer that composed the music. I don't buy that.