Re:Kindle Unlimited
by jaysonelliot on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:26AM
(#8053532)
"Get off my lawn" is an intellectually lazy argument.
George Lucas has already famously done repeated "updates" to Star Wars. If it existed only in subscription form, you'd never be able to see the original.
Re:Kindle Unlimited
by dogecoinbase on Friday July 18, 2014 @02:09PM
(#8054633)
There's also a subtle point here about accessibility of creative works that I think is often missed -- copyright, as a social contract, exists because society has a reason to provide creators with a period of economic exclusivity in exchange for the release of the work. There's no natural or defensible "right" to prevent people from copying. If a creator chooses to release their work in a format that they can retract (e.g. they can negate the societal benefit of the release), society is under no moral obligation to respect their copyright.
> George Lucas has already famously done repeated "updates" to Star Wars. If it existed only in subscription form, you'd never be able to see the original.
Or, you might sign up for a service where access to more than one version is a differentiating feature, and get both for the same subscription price rather than having to buy multiple re-releases.
Re:Kindle Unlimited
by icebraining on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:15PM
(#8054247)
What makes you think Lucas would grant any service the license to distribute multiple versions?
How do you know Jeff Bezos didn't tweak a couple of sentences in your Kindle copy of Catch 22? I don't know, but I do know that detecting such a change will be far, far easier with digital publications than it ever was with paper.