News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by DanielStraight on Friday July 18, 2014 @09:21AM (#8052841)
Let's see if I can cover this entire comment thread in one comment.

Taking a break is good for most people. It can help prevent burnout.

People vary greatly in their ability to take vacation due to income, work and family requirements.

People vary even more in what they consider to be a good vacation. Some people like a lot of activity. Some people like lying around. Some people honestly don't like taking time off work. All of these are OK as long you do what works for you.

People in the United States get, on average, significantly less vacation time than their European counterparts.

Some companies have unlimited vacation policies, but unless the culture is unusually positive, these policies are generally harmful in that they require all vacation to be justified in some way.

In other words, there is no way to make a meaningful universal statement about vacation.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by hipsterrific on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:59AM (#8053356)
My previous job had unlimited PTO and that team sucked mega-donkey balls. It worked despite the culture, here's how:

- large vacation time was scheduled around projects. The SPM gave large priority to devs over the business. Thus priorities were reduced to meet resources for that sprint (SCRUM).

- We had a flexible work schedule so if you needed to be home because the guy fixing your water heater is coming at 3, we made that possible. The philosophy was that as long as you were meeting your targets, everything was peachy.

- We had one guy who would occassionally go on two/three day breaks and not tell anyone - including the SPM. As a team, we just left him alone and if he can't finish his task, oh well, we didn't bail him out.

- Ironically, most of us took fewer vacation days with unlimited PTO. You have the outliers who will gladly abuse it, but prior to my departure, I took a total of four weeks (20 days) of total vacation time. Most companies give that anyways.

Simply put, as long as we gave a long enough notice and put things into the engineering calendar, no one gave a crap. A lot of our unlimited PTO success boils down to prioritizing resources and expectations with the business. This company is around 300 people, so not a small company by all means. We just ensured that we all gave appropriate notice. For me, my formula was 1 month advanced notice for every week I wanted to take, so three weeks off meant three months ahead.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by ritchiea on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:44PM (#8054021)
I don't think most companies in the US give 4 weeks PTO. Currently I am contracting but at my last full time gig standard was 1 week, I pushed at hire time and got 2. What are other people's experience with this?
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by logfromblammo on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:41PM (#8054431)
When I started at this place, I had 10 days of vacation and about 8 sick days per year. Within the first 3 months, I had no more vacation, no more sick days, and just 15 days of PTO. Note the mathematical inequality. We were, of course, then required to use PTO days when the office was shuttered due to dangerous weather, and everyone got the flu because no one wanted to scuttle their own summer vacation plans by staying home sick in February.

My experience is that American companies hate the idea that their employees might prefer to do anything at all other than to make more money for the company than it costs to pay out their benefits and wages. This is not a theoretical hate, but an actual, almost tangible hate. They are completely furious that their inefficient meat-robots continually whine about needing to eat, sleep, and eliminate wastes. Never mind wanting to actually leave the workplace.

US companies emphatically do not offer 4 weeks PTO to new hires. You would be lucky to get that after 5 years of continuous employment with the same company. Your mileage, of course, may vary, especially if you are in a particularly labor-friendly job market. My personal experience, however, is that I have never been able to take a vacation longer than 9 continuous days, and those were often constrained by weekends and paid holidays, resulting in 4 days spent from PTO, and 5 days from weekends and holidays.

I would be willing to put up with some of the negative aspects of having a union, if it could manage even as much as stopping my non-paycheck benefits from eroding a tiny bit every year. I have had enough.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by fataliss on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:32PM (#8054362)
I think the US standard is more around 15 days of PTO. That's what I get here. Plus the week between Christmas and New year that is for everybody.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by lemming on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:31AM (#8053189)
In other words, there is no way to make a meaningful universal statement about vacation.

Except this bit:

Taking a break is good for most people.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by shurcooL on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:22AM (#8053497)
But... but it kills your github contribution streak.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by andrewd18 on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:45AM (#8053662)
Quick, before you go, write two scripts and corresponding cron jobs that convert tabs to N spaces, or N spaces to tabs. Then, set them up to commit to your favorite repo on alternating days.

Now you can enjoy your vacation while pissing off your fellow contributors at the same time!

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by dm2 on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:18PM (#8053837)
Spaces to tabs please.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by jackweirdy on Sunday July 20, 2014 @10:04AM (#8060313)
So you can convert them back again, right?
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by malyk on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:30PM (#8053915)
2 spaces 4eva!
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by pgeorgi on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:56AM (#8053718)
Luckily github only looks at the commit date :-)
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by JoshTriplett on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:27PM (#8053897)
Which is quite easy to manipulate, with amusing results: https://github.com/jbranchaud/commitart
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by JoshTriplett on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:32PM (#8053922)
One key item not noted here: there's a certain minimum amount of vacation you need to take in a row before you stop thinking about work and start actually taking a break. A week normally isn't enough; you need several in a row.

Personally, I like my company's policy of giving periodic sabbaticals, in addition to vacation.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by Diederich on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:24AM (#8053507)
I'll add one bit of colour. At the three places I have worked since 1997, specifically, the teams in those places, vacation/PTO time wasn't rigorously tracked. All three companies officially had vacation and tracked it, but the teams and managers I worked with didn't.

We did put in for vacation, but if we came back early, or extended it a few days (with reasonable notice), it probably would not ever go into the system.

If we were out of the office a day unexpectedly due to illness or family thing, that was almost never put into the system.

If we wanted to take a vacation longer than the number of days we had available, that was just allowed.

From 1997 until 2009 I worked for an enormous (at one time, 'Fortune 1') company. From 2009 until now, I've worked for a pair of mature tech companies in the SF Bay Area.

In my personal experience, it all came down to the nature of the teams you were on, and the managers.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by edpichler on Friday July 18, 2014 @09:58AM (#8053030)
Agreed, every people is different. There isn't the "formula for all".

I'm from Brazil and got curious about the "unlimited vacation", how it works?

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by michaelochurch on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:26AM (#8053170)
I'm from Brazil and got curious about the "unlimited vacation", how it works?

The U.S. is the only advanced economy without a vacation floor. (To join the EU, 20 days is the lower limit.) Three weeks is typical for an average job (but some companies are sleazy and pool sick time and vacation under "PTO") and two for a crap job.

It's surprising how reliably you can predict the quality of a company and job based on vacation allotment. Four weeks: solid, professional, you'll be treated as an adult. Three: average, mediocre. Two: dysfunctional, run the fuck away. Subtract one week if they use that pooled bullshit ("PTO") where sick leave is deducted from vacation. It's a horrible policy, because it means people come into work sick and everyone gets sick more often, but not only is it (shockingly) legal in the US to deduct sick days from vacation, it's not all that rare.

Generally, the assumption is that you should get one week off per decade (e.g. 2-3 weeks in your 20s, 3-4 in your 30s, 4-5 in your 40s) and that, if you have less than that, you're probably too old for the job you're in (you should be further along). That's not a legal requirement. It's just the cultural expectation. If you're 50 and you're still on two weeks, you haven't succeeded at life.

(It's different for consultants, who get no "paid" vacation but charge a higher daily rate. They can generally take off when they want, and can make more than most salaried people working 100 days/year. If you can pull it off, that seems to be the way to go after 40.)

Some startups have undefined vacation policies. This can be really good (if there's a positive culture) or really terrible (if it devolves into a race-to-the-bottom dynamic). It depends. (The one company, with more than 50 people, that I worked at with "unlimited" vacation was terrible. That's not casual, of course, and it's just one data point.) Better is to set a guideline (4 weeks minimum) but allow exceptions.

In software, the more talented people (until they can become independent) solve this by working "from home" and doing a bit of working travel. Free of office distractions and interruptions, you can actually accomplish more in a 3-hour "day" than most people get done in their 8-10. The downside of WFH is that you're still expected to be available during the full 8 hours, and if people get the sense that you're getting your work done in three, then they ask why you didn't ask for more work.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by nicolethenerd on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:43AM (#8053648)
Honestly curious, what is the alternative to PTO? I don't see why this is such a bad thing - you get X days off, you can use them for whatever reason you want - sick or vacation - as long as X is a reasonable number, what's the issue here?
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by joedrew on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:13PM (#8053812)
Having people's sick days deduct from their vacation is an incentive to go to work when you're sick, jeopardizing the health (and productivity) of the team.

A much better solution is vacation days and unlimited sick days, as well as generous work-from-home opportunities for days when you're under the weather but not too sick to work.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by a8da6b0c91d on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:58PM (#8054547)
The supposition here is that it's very unfair to impose a professional cost on getting sick. I don't see it that way. I see people getting sick because they take lousy care of themselves. They're fat and eat lousy food. Also, they make various idiotic stressful choices like having a 1hr commute, or putting a kid in some germ infested day care.

People who do not make such choices rarely get sick for more than the odd few of days a year. Why should they subsidize poor choices? Not being sick a lot is a reasonable and sensible professional expectation.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by alasdair_ on Friday July 18, 2014 @02:25PM (#8054730)
You are encouraging those sick people you seem to have a lot of disdain for to come in to the office when they have diseases and spread them to you.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by dllthomas on Saturday July 19, 2014 @10:30AM (#8057560)
I'm not sure it's "very unfair to impose a professional cost on getting sick" but we don't have a way to measure whether people are sick other than self reporting until they are way past infectious, so you're not punishing getting sick but rather reporting that you are sick, and thus encouraging under reporting, which leads to everyone getting sick more.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by chrismcb on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:51PM (#8056623)
Not only do you still have the few odd suck days but you might also have Kids that get sick. If you use up all your vacation time then you can't take any sick days
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by Spooky23 on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:18PM (#8053843)
"PTO" is an accounting ploy to avoid having to pay off leave balances.

The alternative to to accrue leave.

Where I work, we have vacation/sick/personal leave. There are different rules for each, and vacation time accrues and you get paid upon separation.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by T-hawk on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:16PM (#8053829)
It's fine if that combined PTO is a healthy number like 25 days. It's sleazy if a company promises three weeks vacation trying to look generous when that three weeks is really combined vacation+sick+personal.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by andsmi2 on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:42PM (#8054006)
If you have days "Specific" for being sick--that you can't take to "hang out" then you are likely to take them when you get a mild cold-- benefit to the company is you recover faster and you don't spread your germ. However if it's just "PTO" you are likely to not "Waste" your PTO on a mild cold... thus infecting everyone and making you sick and less productive for longer...
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by michaelochurch on Friday July 18, 2014 @03:53PM (#8055238)
1. Companies implement those policies to inflate their vacation policies. In the negotiation phase, candidates don't ask, "do you mean 15 days of vacation, or is it that shitty thing where sick days are pooled with vacation?"

2. It gives people an incentive to come into the office sick. The result is that half the office is ill (but showing up!) all winter. It's pretty disgusting.

If you're trying to build a polar vortex of disease, then implement a pooled PTO system. If you're trying to build a company, then don't. It's that simple. What are you trying to build?

Here's how I would set it up:

* Three weeks minimum vacation. (Investment banks have mandatory vacation and it's not a bad policy.) In tech, that wouldn't be a hard-and-set rule, but taking little vacation should be the choice that needs to be justified. Five weeks paid, anything beyond that is unpaid leave which can be taken without stigma.

* Don't come in if you're sick. It happens to all of us. If you're going to lose more than 10 days per year to health issues, talk to HR about accommodation and we'll try to make something work. If it's less than 10 days (e.g. colds and flus and stomach bugs) then just stay home.

* Don't worry about emergent personal issues. Let people know where you're going, then go. Come to work when you're ready to concentrate on work, not when you have nonsense hanging over your head.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by bicx on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:35AM (#8053210)
I have "unlimited vacation." Basically, there is no allotted number of days for vacation. At first, it sounds great, and for a day off now and then, it is. However, you can't just leave and spend all month at the beach. You have to justify your reason for taking off a week or two, asking yourself questions like "Have I done enough to justify a vacation? Can I take time off and not let down my team?" In contrast, getting a guaranteed number of weeks off doesn't require you to justify any time taken off. Instead, it's viewed as part of your compensation.

With all that said, unlimited vacation is not that bad in a good workplace with an understanding employer and team. I work hard, and I don't feel guilty about taking time off. What's annoying is when employers hire you with the lure of "unlimited vacation" and actually plan on turning you down if you try to go above a normal amount of PTO. In that case, it's all to their advantage.

When it comes down to it, be skeptical anytime an employer says things like "unlimited vacation" or "flexible hours." Unlimited vacation can mean that they just don't have official vacation days (and can deny you time off), and flexible hours can mean hours only flex one way: up. What people often don't see is that while the 40/hr work week and standard 2 - 4 weeks of vacation seem archaic and even oppressive, having time limits can also protect you as an employee. Remove those limits, and you just have to hope your employer continues to promote healthy work habits.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by NathanKP on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:14AM (#8053114)
The startup I'm at has "unlimited vacation". Basically there is no set limit on vacation days and we can pretty much take vacation whenever we want if we just give the other people some advance notice say a week or so ahead of time.

That said I have only taken a few weeks of vacation in the last few years for some reason. I should take advantage of it more.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by stygiansonic on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:11AM (#8053093)
Good points. This is sort of a corollary that "everyone is different". You wouldn't buy your shoes based on the average male/female shoe size so why would you structure something as personal as vacation based on someone else's experiences?

Best way to discover what's optimal for you in such personal matters is trial-and-error. It's your life - experiment and find what makes you feel good. :)

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by my_username_is_ on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:33AM (#8053580)
I'm curious if any companies have required (minimum) amounts of vacation. Taking a break seems to be a general positive for productivity, but people with unlimited vacation seem to not take it. What if you were obligated to?
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by erikw on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:56AM (#8053717)
Required vacation time is a security best practice, especially for anyone handling money. This makes it more difficult to perpetrate fraud. It also prevents institutional knowledge from being trapped with individuals, as at least one other person must know how to perform the role of the vacationee.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by delecti on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:22PM (#8054298)
Can you explain how it makes it more difficult to perpetuate fraud? I've never worked handling money, so I can't picture how that would be the case.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by zrail on Friday July 18, 2014 @02:09PM (#8054634)
Say you're a bank employee who handles money. It'd be pretty easy to just slip some off the top of each stack every day and take it home. Or arrange the software to skim some into a separate account and pull that money out often enough that the balance never gets high enough to be suspicious.

Both of those things, plus many more, require daily or weekly effort. If you're out of the office, something will go amiss and you'll get caught.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by oostevo on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:57AM (#8053721)
It's fairly commonplace in the federal government to have 'use it or lose it' leave. Only a certain amount of vacation hours can roll over from one year to the next, so those which you don't use and don't roll over are lost.

While it's not mandatory to take that leave, it's a very good excuse for why you want to take several days off.

See more here: http://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/pay-leave/leave-adm...

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by jeffasinger on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:14PM (#8053814)
Banks have this. In fact, the FDIC requires it.

It's harder to cover up fraudulent trading if you're not there.

Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by deciplex on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:56AM (#8053714)
Most jurisdictions require a certain number of days out of the office for people who work in finance. In Japan, it's ten consecutive business days each year. In the US I believe it's five.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by Spooky23 on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:13PM (#8053807)
Usually internal controls require that financial people in payables/receivables take a least a week off.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by goronbjorn on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:12PM (#8053801)
If there was an HN equivalent of Reddit Gold, you'd get it for this.
Re:Tell HN: Take vacation by hmexx on Friday July 18, 2014 @09:27AM (#8052868)
Amusing :)