News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacking goes squishy by biohacker42 on Friday September 04, 2009 @01:30PM (#805270)
But the FBI may genuinely be wary of biohackers

Obviously, the government has never seen any invention it's not scared of. This goes all the way back to the steam engine.

Before anyone here dredges out the old tired super virus or gray goo.

There's no such thing as gray goo and never will be because you'd have to violate the fundamental laws of thermodynamics to get it.

There are plenty of super viruses and bacteria in nature. Neither HIV nor MRSA came from biohacking. As I have said before, anything we create would be like just one more bullet in a machine gun shootout. Sure it could be the one that gets you, but then again, there's an infinity of stuff out there that can also get you.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by tigerthink on Friday September 04, 2009 @07:57PM (#805979)
>There are plenty of super viruses and bacteria in nature. Neither HIV nor MRSA came from biohacking. As I have said before, anything we create would be like just one more bullet in a machine gun shootout. Sure it could be the one that gets you, but then again, there's an infinity of stuff out there that can also get you.

It sounds like you're saying that each supervirus mankind creates marginally increases the chance that a Bad Thing will happen. Isn't marginally increasing the chance that a Bad Thing will happen also Bad?

Also, how close do you think that HIV and MRSA are to the upper bound on supervirus potency?

Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Friday September 04, 2009 @10:24PM (#806081)
MRSA is pretty close to sending us back in time, a time before penicillin, it wasn't a good time, but obviously we survived.

We got super lucky with HIV because you have to exchange bodily fluids to catch it. If it ever becomes as easy to catch as the common cold, we're screwed.

And while the marginal danger may increase with research, the marginal utility will also increase, in fact it will increase faster. We'll discover more cures then diseases. And yes, regulation is a blunt weapon which stops not only the bad, but also the good.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by tigerthink on Saturday September 05, 2009 @01:01AM (#806229)
>We got super lucky with HIV because you have to exchange bodily fluids to catch it. If it ever becomes as easy to catch as the common cold, we're screwed.

If some asshole creates a contagious HIV, then discovering cures faster than diseases will hardly save us.

You get diminishing utility from curing diseases anyway. Say you discover cures for half the world's currently incurable diseases at random. My guess is that our life expectancy would increase by less than a decade. People are still going to age.

And I'm not sure the threat of a contagious HIV would ever go away. It'd be hard finding a cure for a disease that wasn't even created yet.

My guess is that there's already too much momentum behind this sort of research for us to halt it. Do you think requiring background checks for purchasers of biotech supplies would make the field more or less attractive to a hypothetical evil mastermind?

Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Saturday September 05, 2009 @04:05PM (#806958)
Requiring background checks is like requiring any bureaucratic red tape, it annoys the good and does not stop the bad.

But I completely and totally disagree with your implication that more research will only marginal increase life spans, and that we can't find cures for yet undiscovered diseases.

That's like saying in 1989 that in 2009 all the progress in the computer industry both hardware and software would only give us marginally better VisiCalc.

To me at least it is OBVIOUS more biotech research will radicaly change the world not just slightly improve things.

And the asshole most likely to create a more easily transmissible HIV is mother nature.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by tigerthink on Sunday September 06, 2009 @02:40PM (#808018)
>But I completely and totally disagree with your implication that more research will only marginal increase life spans

Unless the research is directed at curing aging, aging will always cause people to get more and more susceptible to disease as they get older.

>and that we can't find cures for yet undiscovered diseases.

What I was saying there was that you can't find a cure for a disease you haven't discovered yet. Do you disagree?

>And the asshole most likely to create a more easily transmissible HIV is mother nature.

There are six billion humans on Earth and the population is growing. All we need for disaster is one person who's intelligent, driven, and wants to destroy the human race. I agree that person would be very atypical. I disagree that we can be confident no one will ever fit that profile.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Sunday September 06, 2009 @04:23PM (#808119)
What I was saying there was that you can't find a cure for a disease you haven't discovered yet. Do you disagree?

Absolutely. Many drugs targeting one disease have been found to cure others. The list includes cancer drugs, antibiotics, antiviral compounds, etc. And that's just drugs, what about the research itself, isn't it obvious it has implications well beyond any one single thing. And isn't that the case for every kind of research, not just medical? To me this seems obvious.

All we need for disaster is one person who's intelligent, driven, and wants to destroy the human race.

Again, we already have that, it's called mother nature. HIV, Ebola, 1918 flu, current flu, etc, all natural.

Here's where I see the problem with your argument, it assumes great asymmetry.

Here's what I mean by asymmetry, I think you imply that if we have the technology to create super viruses on demand that does not mean we'll have anywhere near equivalent knowledge and technology to fight them.

I happen to consider that an extraordinary claim. To me the symmetry of knowledge is self evident. Almost as soon as we invent the nuclear bomb, we also invest nuclear power. Almost as soon as we can gene splice, we have gene therapy for humans which has already been successful applied.

If we have the ability to create super viruses on demand, then we also have the ability to create drugs for them, to detect them, to stop transmission, and most obviously to create vaccines for them. If you can manufacture the virus, it would be one hell of a cosmic improbability that you are also NOT able to manufacture a vaccine for it.

Alternatively if we don't have the knowledge to make viruses and vaccines on demand, that won't stop mother nature from her never ending quest to kills us all.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by tigerthink on Monday September 07, 2009 @06:38PM (#809894)
>And that's just drugs, what about the research itself, isn't it obvious it has implications well beyond any one single thing. And isn't that the case for every kind of research, not just medical? To me this seems obvious.

I agree there will be unexpected good benefits associated with biotech research.

>Again, we already have that, it's called mother nature. HIV, Ebola, 1918 flu, current flu, etc, all natural.

None of those were designed to be harmful.

>Almost as soon as we invent the nuclear bomb, we also invest nuclear power.

This is not an example of symmetry. The nuclear bomb gave humanity the power to destroy itself forever. Nuclear power has not given humanity the power to preserve itself forever.

>If we have the ability to create super viruses on demand, then we also have the ability to create drugs for them, to detect them, to stop transmission, and most obviously to create vaccines for them. If you can manufacture the virus, it would be one hell of a cosmic improbability that you are also NOT able to manufacture a vaccine for it.

Are you sure you aren't exaggerating? You call that cosmically improbable? Remember, we are talking about things that haven't even been discovered yet.

Let me put it this way. If you had such extraordinary predictive power about which technologies will be invented in what order, you could make a lot of money in the stock market. And extraordinary predictive power is what you need to rule scenarios that are compatible with all formulations of the laws of physics as being "cosmically improbable". I agree that such predictive power may exist in astronomy. I disagree that such predictive power exists in technology forecasting, or pretty much anything involving humans for that matter.

If you continue to stand by this position, I will decide that you're not worth convincing and unlikely to be convinced and leave the discussion.

>Alternatively if we don't have the knowledge to make viruses and vaccines on demand, that won't stop mother nature from her never ending quest to kills us all.

"Mother nature" has no quest to kill us. All the damage that's been done by naturally-occuring viruses has been by accident. So someone who was consciously optimizing to create a maximally harmful virus might be able to do a lot more.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by tigerthink on Friday September 04, 2009 @10:03PM (#806063)
Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Friday September 04, 2009 @10:26PM (#806083)
Ebola kills far too quickly to ever become a pandemic. For a pandemic a virus needs to kill you slowly so you can spread it a lot. Like the 1918 flu.
Re:Hacking goes squishy by darien on Friday September 04, 2009 @01:44PM (#805301)
I think it was stephen hawking who said that the only way for humans to ensure their salvation from man-made super viruses in the next 100 years would be to colonize space. Outrageous? Sure, but so is cancer, atomic energy and quatum entanglement.
Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Friday September 04, 2009 @05:17PM (#805743)
I think that was more of hard sell for space exploration then a warning against super viruses.
Re:Hacking goes squishy by steveklabnik on Friday September 04, 2009 @02:59PM (#805452)
> There's no such thing as gray goo and never will be because you'd have to violate the fundamental laws of thermodynamics to get it.

As someone who only heard of "grey goo" very recently, care to explain why this is the case?

Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Friday September 04, 2009 @05:16PM (#805741)
In one way gray goo already exists. The world is literally covered in tiny nano machines eating and multiplying as fast as they can. And many of them are deadly to us. We call them bacteria and fungi.

"grey goo" beyond the natural goo, as often seen in fiction, multiplies and moves so fast as to violate basic laws of physics. For example there's only so much energy stored in stuff that could be eaten.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by endtime on Friday September 04, 2009 @07:30PM (#805952)
Does speed really matter? Bacteria only eat certain things, right? If some mutated type of bacteria could consume more kinds of matter, wouldn't it be a threat?
Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Friday September 04, 2009 @10:20PM (#806078)
Given how long bacteria have been on earth, and how they live from ice to desert to even nucler waste, and how fast they evolve and freely swap DNA, how has not a single one of them already evolved the ability to consume more kinds of matter?

Answer: No free lunch, every advantage carries a cost. Any "super" bug we come up with will enter a world with vicious competitors who've been with us since long before the dinosaurs.

Re:Hacking goes squishy by endtime on Saturday September 05, 2009 @03:01AM (#806303)
I don't really find the argument "It hasn't happened naturally so it could never happen artificially" compelling...
Re:Hacking goes squishy by asdlfj2sd33 on Saturday September 05, 2009 @04:08PM (#806962)
Perhaps you may change your mind if you read up on how easily bacteria swap DNA and just how many of them there are and all the places they live and all the things they eat.

Or to put it another way, what happened since bacteria have been around? Humans. Humans started out as single celled creatures like bacteria. And if we can get from that to humans, is it not reasonable to assume that bacteria have had the time to figure out how to multiply as fast as possible?

Re:Hacking goes squishy by steveklabnik on Friday September 04, 2009 @06:29PM (#805876)
Hm, okay. I guess I never took the speed into account.