News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by Alupis on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:23PM (#8049628)
Verizon is charging me for access to the internet -- then charging the internet for access to me. That is double-billing, and it's egregious.

Verizon is selling me a 50Mbps connection, but if I use it, for even a little, they get upset and say they are over capacity. This is the same company that over-subscribes their network on purpose, as most ISP's do. They will come into a neighborhood with a 1Gbps link, then sell 50Mbps to 100 homes, in hopes that not everyone uses the connection at the same time, nor for long duration.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by judk on Thursday July 17, 2014 @11:42PM (#8051560)
This is a weak argument. Internet connectivity simply is not measured as a 1-dimensional value. It is effectively infinite dimensionsal.

The marketing papers over this in misleading ways, and that is bad, but if you wanted to pay for your own dedicated bundle of wires, like a businesses office building does, you could get it.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by unclebucknasty on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:05AM (#8051750)
>This is a weak argument.

>The marketing papers over this in misleading ways, and that is bad

It's not a weak argument at all and the misleading marketing is exactly the reason it is not. In fact, Verizon has oversold bandwidth (or at least offered it for less than they are willing to accept).

But, what you seem to be effectively saying is that customers are at fault for buying an advertised product which touted the benefits they desired at a price that was acceptable.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by res0nat0r on Thursday July 17, 2014 @08:52PM (#8051133)
> Verizon is selling me a 50Mbps connection, but if I use it, for even a little, they get upset and say they are over capacity.

If your last mile network was built to allow you to saturate your 50Mbps connection 24/7 your bill would be much larger than it is now. So much that you probably wouldn't pay for internet service, so oversubscribing is a totally normal and rational process when building out a network.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by msandford on Friday July 18, 2014 @09:20AM (#8052837)
If I accept your premise as true, then please explain:

1. Kansas City, KS

2. Chattanooga, TN

3. Provo, UT

4. Austin, TX

These places all have fiber to the house, and supposedly gigabit speeds. Two of them were built out with zero help from Google, so Google can't be making huge losses on the internet to prop up other parts of their business.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by res0nat0r on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:33AM (#8053199)
If everyone on those networks were saturating their connections 24/7, then yes, there would also be network performance issues.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by msandford on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:25AM (#8053522)
>>> If your last mile network was built to allow you to saturate your 50Mbps connection 24/7 your bill would be much larger than it is now.

> If everyone on those networks were saturating their connections 24/7, then yes, there would also be network performance issues.

Okay, first it was the last mile that was expensive. Now it's the back-haul that's expensive.

You do realize that you're contradicting YOURSELF here, right?

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by res0nat0r on Friday July 18, 2014 @11:59AM (#8053729)
I'm not sure how you are misunderstanding or purposefully ignoring what I'm writing in every post.

Your network no matter the bandwidth to your house is oversubscribed. If everyone was using their network connection at max capacity 24/7 there would be network congestion issues.

Thus the arguments that "I've been sold 50Mbps/down I should be able to use it at max capacity 24/7" without issue are incorrect.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by msandford on Friday July 18, 2014 @12:47PM (#8054039)
> Your network no matter the bandwidth to your house is oversubscribed. If everyone was using their network connection at max capacity 24/7 there would be network congestion issues.

No, not necessarily. That's how Verizon Residential chose to build out their network but that's not the only way to do so. The commercial side of Verizon manages to provide their customers with 100% of SLA throughput 24/7 no problems. Technically this is feasible.

I would agree that I might not be able to get 100% utilization at the price I am currently paying. That is a point I will concede. BUT, SOMEHOW Google Fiber in three cities and Chattanooga is also supplying gigabit fiber. And they're not charging $10k/mo per person to do so. Could everyone use the full gigabit connection 24/7? I seriously doubt it. But if they're oversubscribed by 10x on gigabit and other places are oversubscribed by 10x on 100 Mbps then they are successfully delivering 10x the internet for the same price, or perhaps 50%-100% more. It's not linear that's for sure.

For your argument to hold water if Google Fiber was 10x faster than Verizon, then Google Fiber would also have to be 10x as oversubscribed as Verizon. I very, very seriously doubt that this is the case.

> Thus the arguments that "I've been sold 50Mbps/down I should be able to use it at max capacity 24/7" without issue are incorrect.

This is a straw man argument. You are not engaging in an honest dialog. You seem to be purposefully obtuse. People watching Netflix in NO WAY constitutes 100%, 24/7 utilization!

How about "I've been sold 50 Mbps service and I want to use 3 Mbps of it for an average of 3 hours per day, which is a measly 6% of the advertised speed and is only 12.5% of the 24/7"

There are two ways to do the math here. One is based on peak utilization, where we assume that everyone watches Netflix at the same time, 100% identically, say from 6pm-9pm. In that case Verizon can be over-subscribed by a factor of roughly 16x (50Mbps/3Mbps) and still keep their customers happy.

The other is to assume that everyone watches Netflix perfectly randomly. In that case let's assume 3 hours per day. Here Verizon can be over-subscribed first by the 16x (since people don't use all 50 Mbps) and further by another 8x (since people are using the service for 3/24 hours per day). That gives you an over-subscribed factor of 128x.

The truth of course would lie somewhere in between 16x and 128x. But what we're seeing is that Verizon is over-subscribed by a factor of more than 16x otherwise people wouldn't have any problems watching Netflix. Put as percentages instead of ratios, customers are asking Verizon to provide between 0.75% and 6% of what they promised to deliver, and Verizon is refusing to do even that.

Further we have evidence via a blog post from Verizon that their entire network is NOT oversubscribed by a factor of 16x as it's only at 40-60% utilization. What is happening is that Verizon is throttling their users at the peering point. It's a great gig if you don't get caught. http://publicpolicy.verizon.com/blog/entry/why-is-netflix-bu...

If we assume that 100% of all traffic on Verizon's network is from Netflix that means Verizon could double the peering bandwidth to L3 before their network got congested. Is that a valid assumption? I don't know, but I sincerely doubt it's 100%. During peak hours it might make up 50%. In that case doubling the peering bandwidth would increase utilization from roughly 50% to roughly 75% which is perfectly acceptable.

It must take some pretty fantastic mental gymnastics to convince yourself that a provider who is not able to make good on 6% end-user utilization is totally in the right and their upset customers are irrational and wrong.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by danielweber on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:25PM (#8049640)
Verizon is charging me for access to the internet -- then charging the internet for access to me. That is double-billing, and it's egregious.

Both me and my brother get billed when we call each other on our cellular phones! Help me!

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by staunch on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:31PM (#8049679)
Which is not how it works in the rest of the world. Only U.S. consumers are so used to getting screwed that they would defend it as normal. Verizon loves double-billing so much for cell service that they want to do the same with the internet.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by viraptor on Thursday July 17, 2014 @07:08PM (#8050766)
There are other countries that bill for incoming calls. I know of at least Singapore that does it.

Also, your phone provider does get charged for each incoming call. They just eat/redistribute that cost, since for normal phone user it's likely to be less than a penny per month. But try running a conference service and you're definitely going to get billed for incoming calls (apart from some weird force-subsidised areas where you can get paid to receive calls)

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by cflee on Thursday July 17, 2014 @09:34PM (#8051237)
The difference is that in Singapore, you can get charged for incoming calls depending on your contract, but you _don't_ get charged for incoming SMS.

From a Singaporean perspective, that's the most bizarre part of mobile service in the US. I need to get an unlimited texting plan so that I don't get billed for people sending me texts? Whoa!

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by arjie on Thursday July 17, 2014 @07:29PM (#8050842)
In India, when we were younger, we'd sometimes all call someone on their birthday. Before you know it, there'd be eight people at a time (with people dropping in and out to wish) on a conference call held at the birthday person's number. That person would pay nothing for this.

I'm pretty sure you can still do this.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by danielweber on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:39PM (#8049724)
U.S. consumers think it's extremely unfair that a poor guy with a landline should subsidize the rich guy with the cell phone or the satellite phone. It might cost me $1 a minute to call my neighbor? No thanks!
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by yxhuvud on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:37PM (#8049715)
Well, that is a damned strange US custom that isn't the case in many other places. It is certainly not the case here in Europe, for example. The receiver pays.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by fudgie on Thursday July 17, 2014 @05:57PM (#8050447)
Don't you mean caller pays? Otherwise I could make someone else spend money just by calling them.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by mercurial on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:43AM (#8051845)
Caller pays, indeed.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by snambi on Friday July 18, 2014 @01:08AM (#8051762)
No one pays for incoming calls in India. This is one of the reasons why even very poor have cell phones. Unfortunately american cell phone users aren't that lucky. Both the caller and callee have to pay. Verizon being cell phone company probably want to charge both sides. Most likely they will win.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by neura on Thursday July 17, 2014 @04:01PM (#8049846)
This is a very bad analogy. When you sign up for mobile phone service, you're also agreeing to usage fees or paying extra to get "unlimited", which case, you pay nothing for those calls.

When I sign up with an internet provider, I am agreeing to pay a fee for open access to the internet at large. I'm not signing up to pay for each piece of content I access or each site I connect to.

I've never agreed, to the best of my knowledge to pay for access only to content served at a rate limited by the reverse utilization of the peering connection that content provider's content can be accessed across.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by DanBC on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:44PM (#8049750)
In UK when Ann calls Bob it is Ann who pays for the call. Bob doesn't pay anything. When Bob calls Ann it'll be Bob paying for the call.

Are you saying that in the US when Ann calls Bob that both Ann and Bob will be charged?

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by danielweber on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:51PM (#8049793)
For POTS, only the caller gets charged.

If you are using a cell phone or a satellite phone, you pay for your connection to that network, whether or not you started the call.

You certainly don't make it so that grandma using her POTS has to pay for the guy with the more expensive connection. That is viewed as extremely unfair.

OTOH, using the cell network generally has free calling to anywhere in the lower 48. It's not the old physical wires that are the expensive part, it's maintaining and upgrading all the cell towers, and so people pay for that usage. Once you've paid to connect your call to the wired network, you can do whatever within very wide geographic borders.

Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by arg01 on Thursday July 17, 2014 @07:52PM (#8050915)
It's actually a historical issue. In the US cellphones orginaly used standard POTS numbers while in other countries cellphones often had an easily distinguishable format. This means that in the US granny wouldn't know she was calling a cellphone so charging her extra would be an unpleasant suprise, while in other countries she knew and was thus implicitly accepting to pay the charge.
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by Alupis on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:32PM (#8049688)
To use your own analogy -- it would be as-if your phone provider charged you to call me (they do), my phone provider charged me to receive the call (they do), then my phone provider charged you for making the call (they don't).
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by derekp7 on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:56PM (#8049816)
Actually, they do (on that last point). Which is why Google Voice won't route calls to certain numbers. It's called a termination fee, which works like this: I pay my local phone company, and also pay a long distance carrier. When I call you, your local phone company charges the long distance carrier a fee, which that carrier then passes on to me. (Well, it used to work this way, but almost everything is flat rate now).
Re:Verizon's accidental mea culpa by Tobani on Thursday July 17, 2014 @09:39PM (#8051246)
But if you answer on your land line you don't get billed by his mobile provider.