News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by mikeyouse on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:14PM (#8049565)
It's easy to ridicule the FBI for statements like this, but I'm glad they're considering the downside to some of these technologies. The pie-in-the-sky version of a driverless car society is tremendous, and I hope we get as close as possible to that, but it does open up some other problems.

1. How would you go about stopping an autonomous semi truck that was programmed to drive through crowds?

2. Will terrorists use autonomous cars as delivery mechanisms for what were formerly suicide bombs?

3. If locations with pedestrians are sandboxed in some way, could a sufficiently skilled 'hacker' intentionally break that sandbox without a trace only to blame it on bad technology?

4. How much privacy / 'liberty' would we be willing to give up to enable such a society?

Someone should be considering the worst-case scenarios..

Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by Throwaway823 on Thursday July 17, 2014 @04:04PM (#8049861)
You can remote control a vehicle or truck at the moment with a few electronics and supplies. I don't see anyone using them for weapons, so why would autonomous vehicles be used that way?

As for suicide bombers, a lot of them appear to have other options for achieving the same goal, yet they choose the method that takes their life. They can buy a grenade for $10, and toss it into a crowd, yet they choose to strap a bomb to their chest. I don't think they're doing so because it's the only option, and because autonomous vehicles are not available, I think they're doing it because they want to give their life to their cause.

What about quadcopters? Couldn't anyone just strap a bomb to a quadcopter, fly it over a stadium, and down into the crowd? I think that's even more scary than autonomous vehicles, because they can fly over barriers.

People have countless ways they can cause damage or mass casualties available to them. However, I can walk around a city surrounded by millions of people, and feel completely safe. Most people are quite nice, they're not sitting at home unable to achieve their terrorist goals because Google autonomous vehicles are not available to them.

Nothing will change. Sure, someone will toss explosives in an autonomous vehicle, instead of putting them in a parked car. It's unfortunate, but not a reason to hold back technology that would positively benefit the other 99.99999% of the population.

Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by sailfast on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:29PM (#8049669)
Agreed. A law enforcement kill switch requirement is probably something that will be discussed as agencies talk through compromises that enable this to happen. (Can't think through all of the pros/cons to this)

That said, if someone is skillful enough to program an autonomous vehicle, they'll probably figure out a way to get around a kill switch as well - like any technology, it can be used for both good and bad. Risk can't be completely removed, but can be sufficiently mitigated. I'm glad the report addressed both sides of the argument, and I'm a bit disappointed that the BBC chose to sensationalize one small conclusion to such an extent.

Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by dm2 on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:29PM (#8049671)
An autonomous semi-truck that drives through crowds?

I understand that there are maniacs out there, but the technical skill required to do this combined with the cost and the level of insanity would make this scenario pretty unreasonable to consider a valid threat. Not saying it couldn't happen, but there are easier ways to cause a similar amount of damage.

How would I stop it?

- Box it in with dump-trucks, other semis, or armored vehicles.

- Use a tank or other armored vehicle from one of the many armories located everywhere.

- Use one of those MRAPs that the military has been giving law-enforcement recently.

- Shoot out tires.

- Armor piercing or 50 caliber rounds to the engine.

- Remote shutoff that is impossible to disengage without also disabling the GPS.

- I'm very close to a major air-force base, they have plenty of ways to stop a civilian semi-truck.

- Use one of the many armed drones, a military helicopter, or even an armed aircraft. I'd have no problem with the US military using an air-to-ground missile to take out a autonomous vehicle that was programmed to do harm, as long as they were sure that there would be zero civilian casualties.

Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by Someone1234 on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:25PM (#8049643)
> 1. How would you go about stopping an autonomous semi truck that was programmed to drive through crowds?

In my opinion that question is no longer important. Back in the 80s and 90s the prevalent thinking was that "bad guys" won't die for their cause. This mandated things like removing the baggage of passengers who aren't flying (which wasn't the case before).

I think we learned quite starkly in the 2000s that suicide attackers are a legitimate threat and therefore we cannot take for granted any longer than a "bad guy" won't put themselves in harms way in order to hurt others.

So if we apply that to your autonomous semi-truck example, how do you stop that NOW? Since presumably someone who wanted to accomplish that could go out right now, get in a truck and then do it. Automation doesn't really change too much.

As far as an answer: Concrete bollards supported by steel mesh (both internally and in the foundation) in pedestrian areas.

Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by sailfast on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:32PM (#8049687)
This is true, but humans scale a lot worse than automation. Now instead of convincing somebody to kill themselves, all I've gotta do is wire up 30 trucks to do what I need them to do. Didn't work? Do it again. Cars are cheap.

Discussing this keeps reminding me of Suarez's Daemon novels. Swarming changes many, many things.

Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by mikeyouse on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:31PM (#8049680)
Surely the universe of "bad guys willing to kill scores of people" is magnitudes larger than the universe of "bad guys willing to die to kill scores of people"?
Re:FBI: Google's driverless cars could be lethal weapons by IanDrake on Thursday July 17, 2014 @03:57PM (#8049822)
>How would you go about stopping an autonomous semi truck that was programmed to drive through crowds?

Same way you stop an non-autonomous one

>Will terrorists use autonomous cars as delivery mechanisms for what were formerly suicide bombs?

No. If they wanted to the could use a $200 remote control car to get a good sized bomb into a crowd from a distance.

For those people, suicide is part of the point.

>could a sufficiently skilled 'hacker' intentionally break that sandbox without a trace only to blame it on bad technology?

It doesn't take a genius to cut a few brake lines of your target, but we don't see that happening.