News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by freyr on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:09PM (#8038363)
The Internet of Things hype hasn't hit HN hard yet, but it seems to be ramping up. Is anybody else skeptical?

The strongest push for IoT seems to be from the wireless hardware manufacturers (Cisco, Qualcomm, etc.) and of course, they have the most to benefit from putting a wireless chip in everything. It's a wonderful solution to their problem of "How do we sell more chips?"

Now Google and Apple are hopping on board. They also have something to gain; Apple sells more hardware, Google collects more information.

But from a consumer's perspective, it seems like a solution in search of problem, and I haven't yet seen a single truly compelling use case that will impact a large segment of the population (turning heating/AC or lights on and off automatically is cool, but not that cool for most people when initial cost is factored in). Can somebody illuminate this for me?

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by toby on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @04:42PM (#8038861)
I have a few "home automation" items in my house -- lights, thermostats, outlets, switches, etc.

By far the most useful is the Z-Wave deadbolt on my front door. It means I never carry keys, I can give codes to friends or the contractor and get texted when they enter, I can set temporary codes for deliveries, etc. I never have to worry if I locked the door.

I was surprised at the hype around Lockitron, since these have existed for a while. The main different seems to be that people prefer WiFi (since they already have it) even though it's a poor protocol for low-power and low-bandwidth.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by bandushrew on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @06:09PM (#8039396)
I believe that the main reason it is hard to see the benefits is that we dont yet have the interesting infrastructure inside that house that an IoT will allow.

ie, I think it is actually too early in the IoT life cycle to really visualise the impact it will have.

Let me explain - currently our lighting and applicances are designed entirely around the idea that they will be manually operated and standalone pieces of equipment.

Once that assumption is taken away, and houses are built with a different assumption, suddenly magic begins to happen - imagine that instead of a few lights in the lounge, there was a ceiling and walls covered in thousands of LED lights that could be independently controlled via the internet. The average home could literally have lighting shows. An entire wall could be utilised as alternately a television or a photo viewer, even a wall in every room.

etc, etc. Use your imagination here. The point is that the impact of an IoT on the average middle class house as they are built today is currently pretty small because neither the house nor the contents of the house were designed with an IoT in mind. Once we actually have an IoT houses will be build from the ground up with different assumptions .

At least, that is my opinion.

tl;dr: The IoT has a chicken and egg problem.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by x1798DE on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @06:58PM (#8039634)
I still don't see a compelling argument here. Who cares about having a "light show" in their house? What does that even have to do with the internet? We already have huge televisions that aren't very expensive. If we want the whole wall to be a TV, we can get a projector. A wall covered in individually-addressable LEDs is probably not going to be cheaper than a wall covered in televisions or just a big projector.

The question the parent was asking was "Why hasn't anyone shown me a concept that makes me think, 'Now I want an internet of things in MY house!'?" Not, "Why haven't I seen quick adoption of these IoT concepts out there?"

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by bandushrew on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @08:13PM (#8039913)
"Who cares about having a "light show" in their house?"

People do - "mood lighting" is already a thing, that is why we have dimmers on some light switches now. Going further than that we can change lighting color, create patterns etc.

Many people, including myself and my kids, would LOVE to have that in their houses.

But only if it was easy, it needs to come essentially for nothing, ie, to be builtin from the start.

"What does that even have to do with the internet?"

Internet Of Things I have always understood to mean "Things that we can talk to and control using our devices, possibly over the internet" but in terms of the internet as it is widely understood, not much really. I am not sure I understand the question?

"We already have huge televisions that aren't very expensive. If we want the whole wall to be a TV, we can get a projector. A wall covered in individually-addressable LEDs is probably not going to be cheaper than a wall covered in televisions or just a big projector."

Right, and who knows whether that specific leap of imagination is realistic, I certainly do not - but I was not trying to make you want a TV in your wall, or even arguing that it specifically was a good idea, it was merely one possible example to make a point.

"The question the parent was asking was "Why hasn't anyone shown me a concept that makes me think, 'Now I want an internet of things in MY house!'?"

Yes. and I was attempting to suggest that one possible reason is that our imagination is balking because we keep looking at what we have in our houses now - all of which is extremely functional and works fine according to our expectations and desires, which have been moulded by what is available and by what has always been available.

ie, we are looking at our existing house infrastructure, the idea of an IoT and saying "but the Internet Of Things is not going to give me a faster horse, so why would I want it?".

I think I am doing a bad job of explaining myself, so I will bow out :)

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by x1798DE on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @10:14AM (#8042082)
> ie, we are looking at our existing house infrastructure, the idea of an IoT and saying "but the Internet Of Things is not going to give me a faster horse, so why would I want it?".

I think again you're missing the point with this. An LED light show is a trifle, it's not something that will really affect you in any way and it's already possible with current technology. A cell-phone controlled LED light show is the faster horse. What the parent (and now, by extension, I) was saying was that I'm looking at the way an inter-connected house would look and I'm not seeing anything fundamentally new, just marginal and possibly dubious improvements on our existing technologies.

With Nest it's obvious that the appeal is that you'd have the ability to remotely change your thermostat settings, which is neat, but how often does that really come up? If I were to program my thermostat with my work schedule generally, how often would I really need the internet-connectivity? Once a month maybe? Is that really worth it? It's an improvement, but it doesn't seem like it's a whole new platform like you and other people are suggesting. Not yet, anyway.

>Internet Of Things I have always understood to mean "Things that we can talk to and control using our devices, possibly over the internet" but in terms of the internet as it is widely understood, not much really. I am not sure I understand the question?

I was mostly referring to the LEDs-wall, thing, which isn't inherently a networking problem any more than addressing each pixel in a television is a networking problem. If you're building a wall of LEDs for "light shows", chances are you'll just connect them all to a single controller anyway which can individually address each LED "pixel", and then that controller will be either plugged into your "internet of things" or it will be controlled by some physical panel.

The two big advantages of device connectivity are going to be that you don't have to be in the same room as your device to mess with it (not having to get up basically doesn't count, because we already have remote controls for almost everything), and that your interface with a device can be much, much more robust (you can essentially use your tablet or phone to give a full touch-screen UX to a small, cheap device like a coffee maker or a lightbulb). The first advantage seems to be getting a lot of hype because people can mess with things at home from when they are out, but that's a benefit that I find marginal at best (how often do I really need to interact with physical things in my home when I'm not even there). The second benefit is much more valuable, but again it is likely to be marginal, because chances are your major devices are ones where you don't actually need to change the settings (or replace parts, etc) very often, so it's a convenience maybe 2 or 3 times a year, not a revolution in the way we interact with our homes and devices.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by jkestner on Thursday July 17, 2014 @12:56AM (#8046111)
In your last point you touch on something important - do we need a rich digital UI for everything? Is the dryer that has essentially an Android tablet embedded in it superior to the two knobs and a button my current one has? (And of that, I use 10% of my options.) Do I need yet finer control? I only have so much attention to give; no interface is more appealing to me. An appliance can be "smart" without having the trappings of computers, I hope.

And likewise, do we need an Internet connection in order for the object to be smart? If context awareness is the name of the game, there's quite a bit you can glean by being a physical object with a memory of how it's used, and beyond that, a local network.

The Drift lightbulb is interesting because it adds some smarts to a dumb object but doesn't add more I/O - it still uses a light switch and an LED bulb, and it isn't trying to get on the network. There are computers that are taking on the form factor of a light bulb, and there are light bulbs that are taking on the force multiplier of a computing device. The latter philosophy needs to be explored more.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by _pmf_ on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @02:02AM (#8040764)
> suddenly magic begins to happen

The magic of a tenfold increase in maintenance costs.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by paletoy on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @04:31PM (#8038795)
> But from a consumer's perspective, it seems like a solution in search of problem

I think the company to look at is Philips. They really understand how to create appealing connected things. For example this article[1] that talks about their controllable color lights, cooking assistant and coffee maker, all controlled through an app to great benefit.

And once something is connected, bluetooth becomes a limitation - say you want to choose coffee type at the living room with your guests ? or you want to watch the cooking assistant while being at the kids room ? Considering that the cost of full connection should be similar to bluetooth in the best case scenario , why settle ?

[1]http://gigaom.com/2014/04/04/lights-cookers-and-coffee-a-dee...

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by MrQuincle on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @06:08PM (#8039390)
What's the problem with Bluetooth here?

No mesh networking? That has been in the pipeline for quite some time now, and will hit the market big time:

http://www.csr.com/news/pr/2014/csr-mesh

Disclaimer: I've been part of a Dutch consortium with companies that developed their own mesh standards and did not understand that you need to "board the smartphone train". This is why I'm skeptical w.r.t. anything that does not just interface with smartphone technology.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by jamesbritt on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @05:52PM (#8039294)
The strongest push for IoT seems to be from the wireless hardware manufacturers

Another area seems to be from those offering yet another (non-standardized) protocol or format such that they can then sell you tools and consulting tailored to their software.

[I]t seems like a solution in search of problem ...

Indeed. Most of the demos I've seen (e.g. turn on a light using Twitter) are easily doable in a number of ways, so the requirement for some IoT "solution" is dubious.

But suppose we grant that such demos are mainly done because they are easy to comprehend, easy to show in a bite-size video clip. Still, there still needs to be something that extrapolates to a more significant use case. I'm not so sure these currently exist for most homes.

Part of me thinks people are tagging "IoT" onto anything they can because it sounds sexy. Controlling my living room lights from my phone is not an example of the Internet of Things.

Controlling fertilization for a farm based on smart sensors out in the fields? That I can see.

Actual use-cases in the average home are less obvious, as is why people will want it.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by FroshKiller on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:27PM (#8038463)
Personally, I'm stoked. The first connected home device I got was an Internet-connected thermostat when I got my home HVAC replaced two months ago. I had no idea I was getting that in the package, and I love it. Looking forward to the day when I no longer have to curse myself for forgetting to start the dishwasher when I'm away from home.

Keep in mind that in terms of factoring in costs, yeah, that will be true at first. But it wasn't that long ago that you had to buy an aftermarket modem as part of the barrier to entry to getting online on your personal computer. In a few years, connectivity will be the new normal, and prices will adjust.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by freyr on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:48PM (#8038580)
Perhaps an Internet-connected thermostat is something I need to try to fully appreciate.

No doubt the costs will come down, and capabilities will increase. And as costs and capabilities increase, potential for innovation will increase.

But it would feel much more compelling if they had a strong application out of the gate (perhaps its networked thermostats). It would benefit from some initial momentum. Industry seems to be taking a "if we build it, they will come" approach, but this often doesn't work out in reality.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by FroshKiller on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @04:40PM (#8038848)
A big part of it is just geeking out over how cool it is that my thermostat is online. However, I'm the kind of guy who never remembers to change the thermostat's schedule before I leave home for a trip, and this thing has already made it possible for me to correct that mistake without having to go back to the house or ask a friend to go over and do it for me. Over the lifetime of the thermostat, that will more than cover its cost in savings off my electric bill.
Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by rsync on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:46PM (#8038570)
"Looking forward to the day when I no longer have to curse myself for forgetting to start the dishwasher when I'm away from home."

Is that a tech prediction, or an optimistic view of your future mental health ?

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by FroshKiller on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @04:38PM (#8038826)
Ha, aren't they often the same thing? In this case, I'll be happy to continue forgetting, because I'll be able to correct the mistake without going home.

Kind of chilling, actually: The notion that this technology might make us more complacent with our weaknesses rather than empower us to be better.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by wlesieutre on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @05:39PM (#8039199)
On the one hand, it'd be great if I could remotely double check that I turned off the stove and locked my front door.

On the other, if you can remotely control these devices then I have to wonder about the security implications. Track records for most wireless device companies have not been good, and I don't want someone burning down my house.

Maybe the plan here is to get everyone on a single standard that shoves good security practices down their throats? But you still have to rely on them implementing it correctly.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by FroshKiller on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @04:26PM (#8044337)
At least in the case of my thermostat, all remote functions are mediated by a server on the thermostat company's side that dials into the thermostat over the Web. In order to compromise the thermostat, you'd have to know how to identify my thermostat and how to spoof the server it communicates with. It's not like you can just stand outside my window with a fob that has an antenna and a big red button and turn my heat up.

From another perspective, front doors with deadbolts and residential don't have a good security track record, either, since most of them can be kicked open easily. But they're good enough.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by dmritard96 on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @11:32PM (#8045943)
Energy efficiency. IoT can bring more awareness to things for finer grain control which can take systems developed over 60 years ago and make them more aware and targeted.

Shameless plug: http://www.flair.zone We are aiming at lowering HVAC energy consumption by between 20 and 30%. Financial incentives are rather attractive ones.

I will agree that there are going to be IoT whizbangs that are solutions in search of a problem, but there are bound to be a handful of actual problems that get addressed.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by bduerst on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:24PM (#8038446)
The Internet of Things won't be that useful until it starts tying in several external services. I imagine then there will be enough value added that it will go over the tipping point for consumer recognition.

I'm personally waiting for my refrigerator to detect my food inventory, and auto-order grocery delivery once a week to restock itself. But seeing how Safeway, Shopping Express, Amazon Fresh, etc. don't even have an API yet, it's going to be a long wait.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by freyr on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:36PM (#8038514)
> I'm personally waiting for my refrigerator to detect my food inventory, and auto-order grocery delivery once a week

I imagined this as well, and it would be pretty cool (although I actually enjoy grocery shopping).

As you say, it's still a long way off. In addition to Internet connectivity and an API, fruit/vegetables/meat and all other refrigerated items would need some kind of tracking label (RFID perhaps) so that the refrigerator could automatically track levels. Scheduling delivery of refrigerated food might also be an issue (I'm not sure how existing online grocery delivery services handle this), as I don't want my dairy items sitting on my hot doorstep all day waiting for me to get home from work.

This could be extended to pantry food items as well.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by bduerst on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:49PM (#8038584)
I've thought about that too - you can create biodegradable passive-RFID tags to put on to packaging, and then have the trash bins read them as they are thrown out.

Problem is the biodegradable RFID tags don't exist. A dutch company was researching them a few years ago but that ship sailed when the iPhone 5 came out without NFC.

Google's project tango could be used with a standard library of objects, but that's still too early to tell if it's possible. Not to mention you'd be tied to Google's services and their whims.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by azdle on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @10:18PM (#8040257)
A friend of mine actually made something kind of like that: https://github.com/danslimmon/oscar

Instead of using RFID, it's using barcodes. It's a little more manual, but same basic concept.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by Sanddancer on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @11:41PM (#8040446)
The online services I use let you schedule a window for delivery, and also require someone to be there to sign for the order, and will also let you change an order to some extent. So I imagine that you'd get an email when your fridge has decided to order more food, and you'd be able to see if the normal window works, or if you need to move it a few hours, days, etc.
Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by alttab on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:21PM (#8038431)
Right now its all buzzwords and vaporware. We are in 2004 talking about the "cloud."

However, its coming, much like the cloud has.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by Someone1234 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @06:11PM (#8039408)
A lot of people here are sceptical but I keep looking for products on Amazon I just assume would already exist but don't.

Three examples:

I was recently looking for a door chime ("door bell") and since I have WiFi already all over the house I wanted something that could piggy-back off of that to increase range but also maybe send the notification to my phone or similar. Doesn't exist. Only ye-olde style RF doorbells no different than what they sold 50 years ago.

I wanted a motion sensor that wasn't part of a security system, just a single stand alone motion detector which could send a text message ONLY during set hours (e.g. 11 pm to 6 am) when motion was detected. But nope, also doesn't exist (in fact there is a serious lack of variety in motion detectors, the closest I found was a Honeywell one which set off a doorbell when motion was detected, but cannot be shut off based on time of day).

I want to know when the clothing dryer is done. I often don't hear it. I have WiFi, but yet I cannot receive an update digitally yet. Why?

I cannot speak to everyone but for me personally I WANT this stuff. I'd happily buy this stuff. It doesn't exist. Where is it? Make it and I'll buy it.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by alttab on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @09:52PM (#8040186)
Don't get me wrong I totally get it. When you plug your device into a message bus like you would a power cord into the wall, things begin to make sense.

Here is how I see it coming together:

- STANDARDS: The "message bus" needs to have essentially an HTTP protocol standard, that both producers and receivers on both ends can understand.

- Hardware, appliances and objects generate their own implementation of an end-node adhering to the protocol.

- Wifi Routers allow the firmware to run "master" nodes, that would have a mobile app and a web front end to configure and customize.

But because having to VPN into your house to manage anything, or even have to have a VPN at all would be silly. So now we host it in the cloud and the devices simply pull.

To design the APIs, platform, SDK, and hosting solution would look a lot like what Apple and Google are doing with their all-encompassing themed keynotes this year. I'm actually worried about interoperability more than anything.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by x1798DE on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @10:18AM (#8042099)
>STANDARDS: The "message bus" needs to have essentially an HTTP protocol standard, that both producers and receivers on both ends can understand.

I think a better analogy to what we need should be an HTTPS protocol standard. HTTP was designed in an era of slow computers when security and privacy were not particularly high on the list of developer priorities, and now we're seeing an agonizingly slow move towards universal HTTPS adoption. It'd be nice to actually start out with security-aware protocols for once.

Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by jkestner on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @11:45PM (#8045969)
It's hard to meet every need when connectivity is still to expensive to try throwing in everything, but that's why we made a general connected object - your examples can be mostly met by http://supermechanical.com/twine, some with the breakout board to wire into existing circuits.
Re:Thread is a mesh network to connect products around the home by freyr on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:43PM (#8038555)
There's a critical difference. Although the cloud and the IoT both began with buzzwords and vaporware, the cloud had clear and compelling potential benefits for customers from the start.

For every "cloud," there are many overhyped technologies that went nowhere, despite industry's best efforts to thrust them upon us.