I probably should've worded that better, but that text will be changed/moved/removed in the near future anyway. The Imgur comparison really only refers to the upload/sharing process, not the non-commercial bit.
As for running off donations, I've addressed that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8034529
imo the worst part is that imgur doesn't even permit direct linking in many cases: they will 3xx-force redirect direct links to their ad filled pages
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host
by BorisMelnik on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:47AM
(#8034833)
yikes I did not know that. I generally link directly to the imgur image itself and bypass the image page. will be on the lookout for this.
Linking to the direct imgur image itself will trigger 3xx to the image page if a few conditions are met - referrer (is popular site), enough hits to the image (popular images trigger 3xxs), some weird cookies.
It's incredibly misleading and awful. Also, try uploading an image - you might notice that the "direct link to image" textbox on the right bar no longer exists, and hasn't existed in a very long time.
Check this out in term:
$ curl -I -H 'Referer: http://twitter.com/' 'http://i.imgur.com/ZKfUroW.png'
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host
by Already__Taken on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @08:33AM
(#8036014)
Imgur does a lot of weird things like that from growing up to be just for reddit onto being a huge entity on its own. Maybe they're using ads to help pay for the site from sources that can afford their own image hosting anyway like twitter.
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host
by vertex-four on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @07:25AM
(#8035789)
I just uploaded a random pic, and I definitely see the "direct link to image" box.
Are you logged in? http://i.imgur.com/7k3si8M.png
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host
by vertex-four on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @07:07AM
(#8041459)
Yes, I am logged in.
It's been running since May and is hosted on rather cheap servers (Ramnode) which limits the amount of funds that actually need to be expended to run such a service like this. At the moment, the project is rather small and doesn't require expensive dedicated servers.
They must be using a different imgur than I use, because it's definitely commercial and has ads. I can't see pdfy surviving on donations indefinitely.