How can the nation so famous for its entrepreneurial spirit not understand that you have to accept some risks in order to thrive. You can never be totally safe - there is always going to be some attack vector left. You have two options - accept that some bad things will happen, limit the control you try to have over society, and thrive. Or try to act on everything, prevent every risk... and you will fail... and damage your society more than any terrorist ever could in the process.
I am not naive - there needs to be some surveillance. Of course that safety is an important value. But it should not be the most important everything-else-trumping value.
If your security services react to a real intelligence about a real threat - that is great. But if they react to stuff like some old guy taking a picture of art (and this is not the only case, nowadays it seems more like a rule than exception) - well, you might be building a cowardly society that is so risk-averse that it will degrade its progress in the future.
This also basically means losing war on terror and giving them what they want.
This is absolutely right. Censorship is internalised into self-censorship.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chilling_effectThe FBI followed up to get the story straight. The FBI didn't know what the guy was doing or why he wasn't doing it, therefore they went to go find out. They sought out the truth. So please enlighten me as to how this can "spin out of control".
Sure, you could argue the guards were concerned he (some 86 year old guy with a camera) was part of a terrorist plot to blow up the natural gas tank. If you draw the line for suspicious activity there, though, then that time I searched Google Maps for local dairies should be equally concerning, since I could be planning to poison the food supply (I'm not. I am, however, looking for a good source of fresh milk for cheesemaking).
Once everything we do, on or off net, is observed and recorded, the only thing that Johnny Law can do is try to check out the things that are unusual: looking for fresh milk. Or wait, maybe you're one of the animal rights folks, and you're trying to figure out a way around the "ag-gag" laws. How does Johnny Law know? He or she doesn't. If you're lucky, like the photographer, they come ask. If not, you're on The List. Maybe you don't get to fly any more. Maybe you just can't get a new job.
I have to wonder, though, the way things are, if they were protecting the copyright on the building or because it's filled with liquified natural gas? Then again, it could be both...
Bruce Schneier disagrees: https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2005/09/terrorists_...
If the security guard suspicion was justified. The FBI found out that is wasn't. Case closed. They did everything by the book. And are you telling me that they shouldn't?
They should exercise some judgment, realize some bored-ass security guards (think about how dull it must be to guard a site like that) made a report just to feel important, and then toss it right in the trash can.
It was a guy taking pictures of a structure in public. No, the FBI should not be tracking him down.
Let's get rid of that 'instead' you used, too. Sneaky! There's no reason for 'establish cognitive bias' and 'find the truth' to be exclusive from one another, is there?
So here's the new cleaned up version I think I can get behind :
"I would like the FBI to establish cognitive biases as a tool towards the goal of finding the truth."
Much better!
The agents may have acted fine. Whoever told them to act, or decided to act on such flimsy circumstances, are the ones who are wrong.
If the agents decided to investigate this at their own discretion perhaps it was a way to instantiate a cross-country vacation within the workplace. That'd be the best we could hope for, because if the agents thought that this guy was a threat (especially given his names' public image and photography portfolio), that's a problem.
You're not at all scared that FBI agents interpret the suspicions of a security guard with greater priority than some random person on the side of the road? I've met plenty of security guards, and a number of them were so grossly under qualified that the thought of them as some sort of authority figure is horrifying, doubly so with FBI backing.
McCarthyists accused and found so many 'red spies' not because they existed (although they did in very limited amounts), but because McCarthyism generated them through false accusation, followed by an unwavering inability to admit wrongdoing or fault.
What can you do about it? A) join the ACLU and donate a little every month, B) actively support open government ordinances and proposals at every level of government, C) support investigative journalism and avoid agenda-driven media outlets and D) vote against surveillance-state supporting politicians (esp Feinstein and Boxer in CA) at every opportunity.
Law enforcement shouldn't keep information about people unless they've been convicted of a crime?
Pray tell how do you propose a system of law enforcement can work without both these things. Or do you think that law enforcement is an unnecessary evil?
>I've read about this happening //
This being 'someone asked about their whereabouts'? Really. This is too much of an invasion of your liberty to simply confirm that you were indeed the person in a particular place?
Perhaps he bought something on ebay from a person financially linked to terrorist operations abroad the week before he went visiting a natural gas storage facility .. we don't know. The outcome for him was to answer a couple of phone questions; I find it really hard to see anything in this story that shows the SAR program has failed.
I imagine they get a few folks taking pictures. Photogs tend to take lots-and-lots of pictures, and want to get in places where other people don't, get close-ups and such. TBH that this might look suspicious doesn't seem especially unreasonable. The security guards don't know he's a professional photog.
"Law enforcement" has no job until a crime has been committed. There is no point in attempting to foil a terrorist plot that doesn't even exist. We could do without all of this pre-crime BS.
The FBI can't prevent terrorism. That's not how terrorism works. Any idiot can kill a bunch of random people on the street and there is literally nothing you can do about it. And notwithstanding that, it still doesn't happen often enough to be worth spending half the resources on it that we do.
But the real issue in this context is that the people in charge of the pre-crime BS are the same people in charge of putting you in prison for violating the law. Such people are extremely dangerous to normal people because they can so easily ruin your life with a pencil, which is why good upstanding citizens legitimately take such exception to encountering them in these types of situations.
It's the chilling effects problem. If something like taking pictures of things causes a visit from LEOs then you're liable to stop taking pictures of things, or advancing your political views in public, or associating with certain people. Which is a totally unacceptable reaction for LEOs to be causing in upstanding citizens who are doing nothing wrong.
Does this mean you don't think there should be beat cops or patrol cars?
Looking at extremes: keeping a record of which people have killed someone in the past seems like a very reasonable thing to do. On the other hand, keeping a record of how long each person brushes their teeth on average, seems like an invasion of privacy (and pointless when it comes to anti-terrorism).
Taking photos of an already well-photographed public landmark seems to fall in the latter category.
"I lived through the McCarthy era, so I know how false accusations, surveillance, and keeping files on innocent people can destroy their careers and lives."
I'm actually rather amazed at the number of "so what?" comments I'm seeing here. I thought we were all much more conscious of how these types of programs start to spin out of control.
I've read about this happening to a guy that photographs underground missile silo's/bunkers already. That was admittedly pretty soon after 9/11, however.