News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Net neutrality by njs12345 on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:15PM (#8031967)
> I would love to see a world where the companies that own last-mile infrastructure are required to lease the lines to any ISP the end consumer wants; this would create a competitive market and mostly eliminate the problem. [2]

This is pretty much how it works in the UK; see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openreach

It does seem to work pretty well.. there are a wide variety of operators and prices are very low. If I had to pick out common criticisms, Openreach can take their time if you have to deal with them directly (getting a line installed in a new office or apartment can take a few weeks), and there seems to be very limited innovation in the last mile - even in London it's hard to get more than 20mbps, and many people in rural areas are stuck with a crappy DSL line at 2mbps or so.

Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:27PM (#8032031)
> and there seems to be very limited innovation in the last mile - even in London it's hard to get more than 20mbps, and many people in rural areas are stuck with a crappy DSL line at 2mbps or so.

This is the entirety of the problem with the DSL-style line sharing. If the companies operating the infrastructure get paid on a per-customer basis, they have no incentive to make the service better by improving service for individual customers. The incentive is to provide service to as many customers as possible regardless of the quality / speed of that service.

If you want DSL-style line sharing to work in the US, the line owners will need to charge the ISPs on a per-gigabyte basis. This pretty much requires the ISPs to charge on a metered basis as well. This would be an overwhelmingly bad thing for companies doing business over the Internet.

I've been banging this drum for a while: companies will act in their own best interest, so you have to align the economic incentives with the desired behavior. If you try to regulate to enforce the behavior you want without the proper incentives, the investment dollars will just move somewhere else because it becomes too hard to make a profit.

Re:Net neutrality by wtallis on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:08PM (#8032286)
> If you want DSL-style line sharing to work in the US, the line owners will need to charge the ISPs on a per-gigabyte basis. This pretty much requires the ISPs to charge on a metered basis as well. This would be an overwhelmingly bad thing for companies doing business over the Internet.

Why? It seems to me that metered internet could work just fine, if the prices are at least somewhat connected with reality (meaning cents per gigabyte at most, with a base cost not more than about $20/month). The form of metering we currently have in the US is usually punitive overage charges for data in excess of some unrealistically low monthly quota, and is applied on top of $60+/month subscription fees. That's obviously bad for internet content providers (since their whole point is to deter further usage), but I think reasonable prices are possible.

Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:42PM (#8032479)
But the prices you list aren't connected with reality. They're your wishful thinking of what Internet access should cost. Reality says that most telecom companies make about 10-15% net margins, so there really isn't room to drop prices more than 10% or so from where they are currently, even if the ISPs are willing to abandon all hope of profits.

It's also a well-known psychological phenomenon that people will curtail usage if they know their usage will cost them more -- even if the amount is trivial. The last thing Internet-based companies like Netflix or Amazon want is for people to use the Internet less. Current metering systems really only "catch" the most egregious offenders (less than 1% of total customers). Most ISPs have a "business class" plan you can purchase for more that truly is unlimited, if you find yourself exceeding the caps on a residential account on a regular basis.

Re:Net neutrality by cma on Monday July 14, 2014 @03:08PM (#8032611)
Telecoms have huge marketing budgets. A large portion is just a zero-sum war with competitors (another portion is enticing people to upgrade existing service).

Those are effectively a source of hidden profit margins--NFL, Major League Baseball, et. al. get them instead of the telecom operators, but when looking at how much prices could drop, you have to consider that.

Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Monday July 14, 2014 @04:22PM (#8032994)
Telecom service is by its very nature a high-churn business: you lose approximately 20% of your customers every year. Churn happens for a lot of reasons: people move, competitors offer better deals, or people simply get rid of the service (but the "people move" one is actually probably the biggest). But because it's a high-churn business, you have to do brand marketing so that when people say "I need TV service. Who offers that?" your name is the first one they think of. Since so many of your customers leave you (and your competitors) every year, you have to be constantly acquiring new customers through a variety of means. If you don't, you'll be out of business in 5 years flat.

The huge marketing budgets don't go away if you suddenly split the market between a dozen or so providers. In fact, overall marketing spend across the industry would probably go up substantially because there would be more competition for limited consumer mindshare.

Re:Net neutrality by wtallis on Monday July 14, 2014 @04:55PM (#8033173)
Total bullshit. People don't replace the wires in their yard every 5 years. Sure, they move (and immediately get replaced by new customers), and they sometimes opt out of the TV service and increasingly opt out of landline phone service, but the only "churn" that's relevant to this discussion is people switching between DSL and Cable, which wouldn't matter if we could get one set of neutral cables installed to get the data to and from the nearest peering points. The rest of the churn you listed and its overhead costs are for the parts of the business that need to be divorced from the actual internet connectivity.
Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @08:02AM (#8035882)
If you have multiple ISPs selling connectivity over a carrier-neutral set of wires, they're going to be trying to poach each others' customers whenever they churn. Any business with high customer churn carries high marketing costs because the return on marketing is relatively good with 20% of the market up for grabs every year. With more players doing marketing in a zero-sum system, overall marketing spend is likely to rise, not decline.

All I'm saying is that the marketing costs wouldn't go away even if the big cable companies do: they would just be replaced by a dozen smaller companies doing the marketing, billing and connectivity. These smaller ISPs would just be taking each others' customers rather than customers jumping ship to DSL or some other last-mile tech.

Re:Net neutrality by fred_durst on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:09PM (#8032287)
Investment dollars are definitely not coupled with profit. They haven't been for almost 100 years in the US.
Re:Net neutrality by tzs on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:21PM (#8032349)
There was a show on PBS [1] that looked at internet access in several countries, and one of the segments covered the UK. There were two amusing facts they mentioned about line sharing in the UK.

1. BT was very much against it, claiming they would lose a lot of money. They now admit it was great for them.

2. AT&T and Verizon were strongly in favor of this. Ask them about doing it in the US, and they say it would be terrible for consumers.

The reporter for that PBS show did an updated print version of this story for Engadget [2].

[1] http://www.pbs.org/wnet/need-to-know/culture/video-high-fibe...

[2] http://www.engadget.com/2011/06/28/why-is-european-broadband...

Re:Net neutrality by SilasX on Monday July 14, 2014 @03:16PM (#8032651)
OT, but I've been looking for examples where a group opposed a policy that passed anyway and turned out to benefit them by their own admission, and your #1 is exactly what I was looking for: http://www.quora.com/What-are-some-cases-where-a-group-admit...
Re:Net neutrality by twoodfin on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:26PM (#8032023)
If I had to pick out common criticisms, Openreach can take their time if you have to deal with them directly (getting a line installed in a new office or apartment can take a few weeks), and there seems to be very limited innovation in the last mile - even in London it's hard to get more than 20mbps, and many people in rural areas are stuck with a crappy DSL line at 2mbps or so.

That's exactly what I'd expect. Make infrastructure a low margin utility and a true monopoly and you'll get utility-grade results.

If everyone here (as I do) hopes they'll have gigabit speeds to their homes in a few years, you have to plausibly explain how those upgrades happen in a utility infrastructure regulatory world.

Re:Net neutrality by Daishiman on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:35PM (#8032083)
The same way they happen with unregulated providers: some government actor has to step in and provide incentives.

We've already seen that expecting multiple last-mile physical providers everywhere is impossible due to cost reasons and the fact that land lines are a natural monopoly, therefore you'll have to manage it as such in the face of absence of normal market pressures.

It's still a better scenario than the current situation in the US

Re:Net neutrality by kuschku on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:33PM (#8032422)
German here – we have one company owning most of the lines, it gets subsidies from the government, but is in turn forced to make their lines available for everyone.

Also the government just forces ISPs to provide specific speeds in specific areas.

And we have many small ISPs which provide their own network, most of the time they are the same company that also provides water and electricity, and these ISPs compete heavily with the government-owned ISP.

Also right now ISPs have to upgrade rural areas first, so in many rural areas you can already get 200mbps to 500mbps for 50€/month, while I'm in the city and can only get it from next year on.

Overall: It is possible to create competition and still have governmental regulated fast internet.

Re:Net neutrality by chimeracoder on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:41PM (#8032128)
> If everyone here (as I do) hopes they'll have gigabit speeds to their homes in a few years,

Unless you already live in a very densely populated area[0], I don't think there's any reasonable chance of that happening for most people, whether we go the Title II route or not.

Title II is better than the alternative, but having gigabit speeds for most households is quite a ways off no matter how we do it.

[0] And even then - I live in Manhattan and several buildings on my block have FiOS, but mine does not (thanks to TWC's exclusive agreement with the building owner).

Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:11PM (#8032299)
> [0] And even then - I live in Manhattan and several buildings on my block have FiOS, but mine does not (thanks to TWC's exclusive agreement with the building owner).

This is a problem with MDUs and why the big telecoms have dedicated sales teams assigned to make these kinds of deals. The more likely scenario is that Verizon was working on getting these kinds of deals set up, then they halted FiOS expansion and stopped adding new buildings before they got to yours.

I don't think contractual exclusivity is legal, but a building owner does have to set up agreements with a company like Verizon or TWC to allow them access to the building, provide a contractual basis as to who owns what wiring, etc. So if Verizon doesn't reach out to the building and set that up, FiOS isn't going to be offered.

Re:Net neutrality by chimeracoder on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:45PM (#8032498)
> The more likely scenario is that Verizon was working on getting these kinds of deals set up, then they halted FiOS expansion and stopped adding new buildings before they got to yours.

Actually, no, they are still adding new buildings in NYC, but only on the condition that they provide both television and Internet service to the building. (For a short period of time they did Internet-only out on Long Island, but they've stopped that).

I got very far up the Verizon chain and found out a lot of information about this, which is why I know the specifics here.

In my case, I requested that Verizon figure out whether they wanted to provide service to my building (they did) and that they then contact my building (they did), at which point it turned out that TV (not Internet) for the building could only be provided by TWC.

For what it's worth, I'm pretty sure Verizon uses this as an easy excuse to avoid expanding their service (since 2010 or 2011, Verizon has been very half-hearted about FiOS and doesn't really seem to care about expanding FiOS as much as they care about appearing to care)[0].

> I don't think contractual exclusivity is legal,

No, but they've found creative ways to get around it, and it's certainly not something that's widely enforced.

[0] My evidence in favor of that comes more from my experience dealing with them in New England.

Re:Net neutrality by warfangle on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:37PM (#8032105)
>utility-grade results

Hopefully not gas-delivery grade results. 5-10% of methane delivered via mains in the UK is lost to atmosphere. Similar leakage rates are found in the US, sometimes much worse. The main (heh, no pun intended) source of these leaks are cast iron pipes that are over 100 years old.

And unlike the Internet, when those things fail, things literally explode.

Re:Net neutrality by danielweber on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:45PM (#8032154)
Methane is a much worse GHG than CO2. This seems like a very significant problem.
Re:Net neutrality by warfangle on Monday July 14, 2014 @05:46PM (#8033461)
It is. Methane leakage in the US is comparable to the GHG output of half the coal plants in the US.
Re:Net neutrality by xorcist on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:33PM (#8032417)
One idea could be to look at those who actually have gigabit residental connections at see how they did it...

I've seen several different models and most have their uses. I pay roughly $80/month for mine in a somewhat dense suburban area.

Re:Net neutrality by walterbell on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:29PM (#8032051)
Didn't 1996 telecom deregulation mandate sharing of last mile copper, creating short-lived (~5 years) DSL CLECs funded by about $20B of public IPOs? Various tactics were employed by incumbent telcos to slow down the CLECs, while nominally complying with the requirement to share the last mile.
Re:Net neutrality by r00fus on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:28PM (#8032393)
Yes, that was rolled back in 2001 as one of the first Bush Administration moves against the internet - I have no doubt this protectionist move was done in exchange for these big telcos to support the "terrorist surveillance" that's now turned into constant surveillance on Americans.
Re:Net neutrality by danielweber on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:24PM (#8032008)
I've been led to believe (by conversations here on HN as well as elsewhere) that DSL in the US is operating under that regime -- the phone companies are required to lease them out, so you can have 5 different providers all selling you DSL over the same wires. But DSL bandwidths strongly lag behind cable modem bandwidths because the people laying the wire have no desire to upgrade for the benefit of their competitors.

How much truth is there to this?

Re:Net neutrality by toast0 on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:47PM (#8032168)
It's a little bit complex now. The incumbent carrier (ILEC) is still required to lease lines at the Central Office, but they used to be required to lease access to DSL delivered from remote terminals as well. AT&T still provides leased access to DSL delivered from remote terminals, but does not provide leased access to U-Verse, so companies leasing access can put their own DSLAMs in the central office and compete on speeds for users near the central office, but not in areas that are primarily served by remote terminals after AT&T rolls out U-Verse's ADSL2 and VDSL based DSLAMs; the leased access for users behind remote terminals is limited to 6mbps ADSL1.

In cities which have been dense for a long time, like San Francisco, there are lots of central offices, and competition using leased access is feasible, but in cities where density is more recent, such as San Jose, there may only be one central office, and there's only a small area with feasible competition with leased access.

Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:29PM (#8032044)
DSL in the US used to operate that way until it failed spectacularly due to the reasons you mention and the FCC reclassified DSL as an information service.
Re:Net neutrality by bitJericho on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:33PM (#8032074)
I don't know when that happened, but when I had DSL about, oh 6 years ago, they practically begged me to sign up with MSN. I think they got a commission for it. I chose just to go straight with the company who owned the equipment, my phone company.
Re:Net neutrality by exelius on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:05PM (#8032272)
I think some resellers were grandfathered in when it was reclassified, but not many of them were left at that point anyway. And you're right, they probably did get some sort of commission: providing the service itself was so unprofitable (even with line sharing) the DSL ISPs had to find additional revenue channels.
Re:Net neutrality by rhino369 on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:43PM (#8032140)
You can use the local loop, if it exists. It's just not cheap than ADSL, which is already cheap as fuck.

Though AT&T and Verizon are ripping out the connections if they bring fiber to your house, and you can't share that line.

Re:Net neutrality by lloeki on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @04:12AM (#8035326)
Same here in France, both for copper lines — a.k.a "dégroupage" — and FTTH — a.k.a "mutualisation".

The first one was imposed to lift the monopoly of France Télécom (then the universal telecom public service, now Orange), while the second one was imposed not to repeat mistakes made when cable operators created local monopolies by negotiating cable installation at discounted prices with syndicated building owners or neighborhoods (Of course prices went through the roof once the monopoly was in place, and up again when one ended up buying them all).

Pragmatic result: I'm paying 35€/mo for 100Mb/50Mb (incl. TV/IP and landline/IP), due for an upgrade to 300Mb/100Mb.

Re:Net neutrality by matthewmacleod on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:47PM (#8032507)
"there seems to be very limited innovation in the last mile - even in London it's hard to get more than 20mbps"

That's just not true - vast swathes of London now have access to the VDSL-based Infinity service which is up to 76Mb down; there are quite a few FTTP exchanges too.

Re:Net neutrality by njs12345 on Monday July 14, 2014 @03:03PM (#8032578)
Well, when I looked (in E1, close to Central London) it wasn't available yet, and only about half the people in my office can get it. Hopefully things have changed in the meantime :)
Re:Net neutrality by oesmith on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:36PM (#8032093)
+1, I live in a semi-rural town of ~10k residents and I get 75Mbps / 15Mbps fibre-to-the-cabinet broadband.

The infrastructure is owned by the incumbent monopoly provider, but the service over the top can be supplied by any one of a number of large and small suppliers.

Re:Net neutrality by alex_duf on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:22PM (#8032006)
That's also how it works in France.