This is a point I hear often, but there seems to be no consensus. If I understand you correctly, are you saying that small, independent artists used to make a living just from CD sales?
I've only met in person poor musicians, those that make money either from street concerts or the occasional gig, which were consistent with Courtney Love's position[1] that CD sales are not really important when it comes to revenue. But I'd love to hear an argument from the other side.
DRM can't help artists make money. It only helps them lose more.
Examples which talk about it:
* http://www.lexi-alexander.com/blog/2014/6/1/will-the-real-pi...
> And this is my favorite part: I am 100% certain that the hacking of entertainment industry's security features provides better entertainment for these kids than the entertainment we're trying to prevent them from stealing. Let that sink in for a second, then try not to bust up laughing.
* http://brutalgamer.com/2012/03/09/cd-project-red-drm-no-long...
> Every subsequent game we will never use any DRM anymore, it’s just over-complicating things…We release the game. It’s cracked in two hours, it was no time for Witcher 2. What really surprised me is that the pirates didn’t use the GOG version, which was not protected. They took the SecuROM retail version, cracked it and said ‘we cracked it’ — meanwhile there’s a non-secure version with a simultaneous release. You’d think the GOG version would be the one floating around.”
The people releasing the content do not care about the actual content, they are not fans, hell most of them probably never watched/played/listened to the movie/show/game/song they are releasing.
The Act of cracking, releasing, encoding, etc is the entertainment for them... The content is irrelevant
Imagine you have a stock photo website. Basically honest potential customers might try right-clicking a photo once to download it, and failing that will whip out their credit card. Basically dishonest non-potential customers aren't going to pay you and see your protections as something fun to be worked around.
There just isn't a business case for heroic measures that can ultimately be trivially defeated.
You have no idea how much time I've spent on sites doing weird things to try and stop the user from downloading their content. Like online schools that don't want anyone to save the class-lesson videos. I don't even want the media, I just find it irresistible to understand and ultimately defeat their protection.
I suspect that your DRM was so overly burdensome that it turned away any potential customers, you in effect screwed yourself.
If the DRM does not get in may way, or require me to do anything(i.e it is invisible to me) then I might buy that software, for example Steam Games, Spotify, etc have DRM that is invisible to the End User. I will grin and bear this level of DRM, begrudgingly. However if you go much beyond this no thank you.
If your software has Activation Keys, Installation Limits, Locks itself to my Motherboard that I change ever 6mos, or other crap like that then you would never get a single dollar from me.
All the money is in touring and merchandising.
Even look at music piracy. Pirates did the big labels a favor: small, independent artists can't make a living anymore because everyone just expects it to now be free. They now are almost forced to go with a big label if they actually want to make any kind of living.