News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by dsr_ on Monday July 14, 2014 @12:29PM (#8031677)
How to drive away customers: prioritize your unproven loss of income over making an attractive product. Accuse all your users of copyright infringement.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by scrollaway on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:22PM (#8032354)
It is unbelievable that the entire comment thread is filled with people saying it's a bad article, it can be worked around, etc, when:

1. The article is an experiment on techniques and what can be achieved.

2. At the VERY BEGINNING of the article, the author links to his own comment in a previous HN post which said "I do not advocate using any of the techniques, please don't use it, it's terrible and will give your users headaches! I'm against ressource "protection" on the web, what's on the internet should be fully consumed by users of it! The article describes just a few experiments I set up to see how far someone could go if it WAS important."

3. The article acknowledges these techniques are ultimately stupid.

What is this attitude? Would you have the same attitude with someone experimenting with XSS flaws, hacks and so on to figure out what is possible? Did you all forget than, in order to do good, you have to know what is bad first?

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by cookiecaper on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:39PM (#8032462)
Totally agree. Articles like this are awesome and ideally HN would be filled with them. It's about a set of interesting hacks, that are ultimately still just hacks, but stimulate the hacker mind and add to an archive that can be drawn upon when/if the reader ever encounters the need to solve a similar problem (hopefully with better practical applicability). Articles like this are amusing, interesting, and inspiring, and embody the spirit of Hacker News.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by WorldWideWayne on Monday July 14, 2014 @06:30PM (#8033638)
The person you're responding to didn't say "it's a bad article" or that "it can be worked around". I'm guessing that the root comment was simply a reaction to the title. I bet they didn't even read the article. However, you must be aware that the majority of the technical user community hates DRM.

Regarding your points 1, 2 and 3... where does it stop? Should we always be enthusiastic about experimentation for the sake of experimentation? At what point would you say "that's stupid"?

For instance, what if the title was: How To Dump Toxins In Your Local Water Supply

Would you read the article and then come here and congratulate the author on their efforts? I bet most people would glance at the article and then come here and complain about too many toxins in the water and what a jerk the author is.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by scrollaway on Monday July 14, 2014 @07:01PM (#8033746)
Congratulations on hitting as many fallacies as you possibly could in a single comment. You managed to compare, literally, "poisoning the water supply" with... web development.

You know where it stops? It stops when you start putting people in danger. I cannot believe you're seriously asking that question (and yet, I have to believe you are seriously asking that question, because the alternative is that you're an awful troll).

I would like to encourage you to read my comment, and then read it again, and keep doing that until you understand the difference between killing people and blogging on the internet. I would then like to encourage you to read up on things such as "white hat hacking", pentesting and so on to give you an insight as to why, in the IT world, if the good guys don't push the limits first, the bad guys will.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by WorldWideWayne on Monday July 14, 2014 @07:14PM (#8033789)
Fallacy schmallacy. I was talking about blogging about experiments in poisoning people (just a bit, not killing them :) Anyway, you don't think people are harmed by DRM? Of course they are. Time and water are among the most valuable things we have and DRM steals away everybody's time so a few can profit.

Let's try another hypothetical title: How To Force Your Neighbors Take Out Your Trash or, How To Write A Virus That Steals Banking Information...How To Really Embarrass Your Coworkers...9 Ways To Enrage Internet Commenters...(this is fun!)

Would you applaud those experiments? I'm guessing YES since "It stops when you start putting people in danger." and nobody is being put in danger.

(BTW, I'm just doing my own experiment here - I guess I should have said that. You're not being a very good sport though ;) Seriously - I'm sitting here trying to understand your point of view and I made some POLITE arguments. You mis-represented one of my arguments and then patronized me to the extreme, so is that the kind of behavior that you're promoting?

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by jobu on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:28PM (#8032039)
Obscurity is a far more common problem than plagiarism. The best solution for this is to put a signature in the image. Most people aren't trying to steal an image without attribution, they just want to share something they liked.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by stevekemp on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:06PM (#8032278)
> Most people aren't trying to steal an image without attribution, they just want to share something they liked.

As an amateur photographer you'd be amazed how many people think nothing of taking an image and slapping it on their website, or in their print media.

People routinely use services like imgur.com to rehost images they have no permission to use, and can and will strip watermarks and be silent when asked for attribution.

I'm used to it now, but damn it's frustrating when you take that _one_ great shot and find it everywhere on the internet the next day with no credit.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by metacorrector on Monday July 14, 2014 @03:56PM (#8032838)
I just can't sympathize, at all. I would prefer (I realize this is not the law) an internet that was considered public domain. If you don't want you picture copied, don't put it in the public domain.

I do understand hard work, and skill, and putting in the time that made you the great photographer that you are, and I understand the need to earn a living, and I understand capitalism, economic profits, and accounting profits and economic profits.

But a large number of highly trained and skilled people put a lot of hard work and effort into writing the open source software that is running the internet and the webservers that your images are on.

I understand your perspective: you'd rather buy a proprietary microsoft operating system and a proprietary microsoft webserver so you could run a proprietary Oracle database to keep track of your DRMed photos.

But understand that I wouldn't, I'd rather have a public domain web where photographers share their work like artists do and computer programmers and graphic designers and bloggers and everybody else.

I'm just not that excited by your great photo, there are a lot of great photos.

full disclosure: I took a significant news photo once and made money selling it. I enjoyed spending the money. I don't chase around the internet stopping people from duplicating it.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by stevekemp on Monday July 14, 2014 @04:50PM (#8033145)
> If you don't want you picture copied, don't put it in the public domain.

Most of my pictures are prints, hanging on walls. But you need a portfolio to attract (paying) clients, so images have to exist!

> I understand your perspective: you'd rather buy a proprietary microsoft operating system and a proprietary microsoft webserver so you could run a proprietary Oracle database to keep track of your DRMed photos.

So if I said I'm an ex-Debian developer who's released a pile of open-source software, for free? And does so regularly?

Seriously you're getting too personal there, and just wrong. Photography started as a hobby because I love people - in the same way that woodworking is a hobby because I like doing things with my hands that are "real".

But there are costs involved, I've probably spent close to 10,000 in camera-equipment, to have people steal your work, means that stuff doesn't pay for itself any more.

You mention proprietary software? How would you feel if you wrote open-source software and people abused the licenses? That's copyright infringement, and the same thing is a huge deal in the photography world.

Sure everybody has a camera, and fly-by-night people will take money for pictures. But that's like hiring a self-taught PHP-programmer instead of a kernel developer. There are skills, styles, niches, and similar involved that clearly differentiate photographers.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by WorldWideWayne on Monday July 14, 2014 @06:59PM (#8033735)
> and the same thing is a huge deal in the photography world.

Is it big enough to start deploying the lawyers? That's what software companies have to do. If you're not doing that, then it must not be a big enough deal to you. If you CAN'T do that, then I think you should get out of the biz.

But, I bet you won't because you are probably getting something more than money out of your career. Maybe you enjoy the work. If it were all about money, you would have become a banker, right?

No sympathy here either. You have no natural right to get paid every single time one of "your" images is used. (Oh and who owned the stuff you took a picture of? Should you pay them to photograph it? Should they get paid every time the image is used?) With no natural rights, you have to use the legal system. Nobody cares if you sue some big corporation, but please...complaining about people posting stuff to imgur.com? What money was lost because your image showed up there? Did you try sending them a cease and desist? I bet they'd take it right down. If you don't do that, then you're not trying hard enough.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by stevekemp on Monday July 14, 2014 @07:19PM (#8033804)
OK so you don't believe that people should be rewarded for their creativity, that people should have their licenses honoured in any field of endeavour.

I have sent cease and desists in the past, in the same way that I've sent DCMA takedown notices against people who post documentation I've written with no attribution, and against people who've forked my code and pretended to have authored it.

But I'm done with you now.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by WorldWideWayne on Monday July 14, 2014 @07:41PM (#8033896)
Specifically on the topic of photography though - Do you feel that the owner of the object of your photograph should get paid every time the image is shown though? Where does that end? For instance, if you shot a famous building - do you think the architect should get paid? What about the construction workers? The current owner?

That was really my main gist. Sorry for not being sympathetic. I thought I made a pretty good argument. I was not trying to be impolite, but I can see how it could be taken as such. Could you just answer that one question? I'm really interested in the fine line that is being discussed here.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by drzaiusapelord on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:29PM (#8032400)
> strip watermarks and be silent when asked for attribution.

If the watermark can be removed without making the image largely useless then you're not watermarking properly. Sure, its not pretty, but this isn't a pretty world. I never understood the lazy bottom-right watermark. Its trivial to remove and sites like reddit reward fraud because people like to pretend its their content as narratives like "Oh i bought a camera and took my first photo" are eaten up by low-information voters (who i imagine are the plurality of votes on reddit).

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by cookiecaper on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:43PM (#8032486)
Get a good C&D template. In this day and age, it's the only protection IP holders have. If someone isn't worth pursuing legally, it's not worth worrying about whether they're providing proper attribution or cutting out your watermarks, just let those people go. If you get ripped off by a commercial publisher, send some letters and get the remuneration you deserve.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by stevekemp on Monday July 14, 2014 @04:51PM (#8033151)
It used to be the former, now it is the latter.

Newspapers, big online sites that should know better. They take pictures and half the time you never even know unless you use tineye, or a friend/colleague will share a link with you "Hey nice work getting included in the New York Times", etc.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by SilasX on Monday July 14, 2014 @12:58PM (#8031860)
Do you agree that it's sometimes desirable to communicate in a way that doesn't produce a written record? (e.g. insisting that you talk privately in person rather than over email)

If yes, then I think you agree in principle with the goal here, even if you disagree with the specific use case.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by paulhauggis on Monday July 14, 2014 @12:51PM (#8031822)
I really dislike this attitude on HN. You can have great products that make no money because cracks get popular (I have done testing with my own software and know for sure this is the case) and get higher results than the original product listing on google, Adblock, and many other methods thought to be "rights".

Even look at music piracy. Pirates did the big labels a favor: small, independent artists can't make a living anymore because everyone just expects it to now be free. They now are almost forced to go with a big label if they actually want to make any kind of living.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by probably_wrong on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:22PM (#8032004)
> Pirates did the big labels a favor: small, independent artists can't make a living anymore because everyone just expects it to now be free.

This is a point I hear often, but there seems to be no consensus. If I understand you correctly, are you saying that small, independent artists used to make a living just from CD sales?

I've only met in person poor musicians, those that make money either from street concerts or the occasional gig, which were consistent with Courtney Love's position[1] that CD sales are not really important when it comes to revenue. But I'd love to hear an argument from the other side.

[1] http://www.salon.com/2000/06/14/love_7/

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by shmerl on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:01PM (#8031875)
> independent artists can't make a living anymore because everyone just expects it to now be free.

DRM can't help artists make money. It only helps them lose more.

Examples which talk about it:

* http://www.lexi-alexander.com/blog/2014/6/1/will-the-real-pi...

> And this is my favorite part: I am 100% certain that the hacking of entertainment industry's security features provides better entertainment for these kids than the entertainment we're trying to prevent them from stealing. Let that sink in for a second, then try not to bust up laughing.

* http://brutalgamer.com/2012/03/09/cd-project-red-drm-no-long...

> Every subsequent game we will never use any DRM anymore, it’s just over-complicating things…We release the game. It’s cracked in two hours, it was no time for Witcher 2. What really surprised me is that the pirates didn’t use the GOG version, which was not protected. They took the SecuROM retail version, cracked it and said ‘we cracked it’ — meanwhile there’s a non-secure version with a simultaneous release. You’d think the GOG version would be the one floating around.”

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by the_ancient on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:32PM (#8032062)
That is the thing the Content owners do not get...

The people releasing the content do not care about the actual content, they are not fans, hell most of them probably never watched/played/listened to the movie/show/game/song they are releasing.

The Act of cracking, releasing, encoding, etc is the entertainment for them... The content is irrelevant

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by shmerl on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:09PM (#8032290)
Luckily some start getting it, but the majority still doesn't.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by kstrauser on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:00PM (#8031873)
That attitude is realism. It's not unreasonable to take minor steps to make casual copying easier - the clear GIF overlay is a good example of that - but there ain't no such thing as perfect digital restrictions management. Anything beyond those minor steps becomes an inconvenient nuisance for your real customers and the risk/reward paying just isn't worth it.

Imagine you have a stock photo website. Basically honest potential customers might try right-clicking a photo once to download it, and failing that will whip out their credit card. Basically dishonest non-potential customers aren't going to pay you and see your protections as something fun to be worked around.

There just isn't a business case for heroic measures that can ultimately be trivially defeated.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by smtddr on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:56PM (#8032218)
>>Basically dishonest non-potential customers aren't going to pay you and see your protections as something fun to be worked around.

You have no idea how much time I've spent on sites doing weird things to try and stop the user from downloading their content. Like online schools that don't want anyone to save the class-lesson videos. I don't even want the media, I just find it irresistible to understand and ultimately defeat their protection.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by clarry on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:08PM (#8031927)
There's nothing dishonest about not being a customer and not wanting to pay. But breaking protections for the heck of it is fun indeed.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by meshko on Monday July 14, 2014 @12:55PM (#8031847)
Like it or not, you can't do it, so don't waste your time.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by stcredzero on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:05PM (#8031911)
To be able to do this on browsers is foolish. Devices might be workable, though they would only be on the same level of deterrent as a cheap lock. A user could always take a photograph of the screen.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by skizm on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:02PM (#8031890)
I don't think anyone is saying piracy is not hurting anyone. To what extent, I would say there is a great deal of disagreement. If a perfect DRM existed (completely prevents privacy while leaving paying customers unaffected) everyone would implement it. However, the message is that you shouldn't stoop to making your own product worse or punish paying customers just to combat piracy. For example, if you're selling software and someone wants to buy it, they shouldn't have to jump through hoops to get it and/or use it. On the other hand if someone wants your product and doesn't want to pay for it, there is a significant probability that is a lost sale regardless of DRM efficiency. Just because a ton of people use a pirated version of your software doesn't mean that a ton of people would have bought it if you had better DRM.
Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by the_ancient on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:25PM (#8032020)
You may feel it was a "great product" but apparently people were not willing to pay for your great product. Several companies and people get paid giving away their software.

I suspect that your DRM was so overly burdensome that it turned away any potential customers, you in effect screwed yourself.

If the DRM does not get in may way, or require me to do anything(i.e it is invisible to me) then I might buy that software, for example Steam Games, Spotify, etc have DRM that is invisible to the End User. I will grin and bear this level of DRM, begrudgingly. However if you go much beyond this no thank you.

If your software has Activation Keys, Installation Limits, Locks itself to my Motherboard that I change ever 6mos, or other crap like that then you would never get a single dollar from me.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by base698 on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:11PM (#8031943)
This is not my experience. I work in a space that is seeing impressive numbers from up and coming acts. To me it seems like the variety and quality of music offered to the consumer has increased leading to more people seeing Joe Blow's act instead of going to Cher or Britney Spears.

All the money is in touring and merchandising.

Re:How to prevent screenshots in a web browser by colechristensen on Monday July 14, 2014 @12:55PM (#8031843)
Regardless of what you believe I am not going to patronize you if you treat me like a thief, likewise I'm going to fight tooth and nail to ensure that I am the one that controls the device I physically own, not a content business.