News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by bedhead on Thursday July 10, 2014 @12:59PM (#8015739)
No, Uber didn't fail anyone. To the extent there's a failure somewhere, it's the monopoly the municipality holds on taxi medallions, which artificially limits supply of taxis overall.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tptacek on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:02PM (#8015762)
Municipalities and states hold "monopolies" on licenses of all sorts; the argument that says medallions are bad public policy because they're monopolistic applies equally to many other forms of licensure, for instance zoning.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by bedhead on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:20PM (#8015871)
While this is true, what makes taxi medallions so unique is the price discovery. This is one of those rare things where you can see, quite unambiguously, the direct effect of the monopolistic behavior. Other things like zoning tend to be very complex and ambiguous, but taxi medallions are simple. The effect? NYC taxi medallion prices have grown by 29% annually over 30 years. As someone in the investment world, that might be the single best performing asset class I can think of, all for the privilege of taking someone from point A to point B. I noticed airlines don't need medallions - how has that worked out?

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/10/the-amaz...

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tptacek on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:26PM (#8015910)
Did you just suggest that it's easier to start a commercial airline than it is to get a taxi medallion? Have you ever paid attention to the drama about who gets what gates at which airports? Or watched local political battles over the addition of new runways at an airport?
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by bedhead on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:53PM (#8016066)
No. One's supply limited by the government, the other's is not. At the end of the day they both just transport people from point A to point B. Owners of planes have gone bankrupt 1,000 times since 1980, while owners of taxis have the single best returning asset I can think of. Do you really think government meddling (or medallioning, heh heh) hasn't been about 85% responsible for this otherwise incomprehensible result?
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tptacek on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:12PM (#8016186)
The supply of available airport gates is absolutely limited by governments.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by bedhead on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:59PM (#8016493)
Well this is going nowhere. I don't know why I try sometimes.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by dragonwriter on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:55PM (#8016076)
> Do you really think government meddling (or medallioning, heh heh) hasn't been about 85% responsible for this otherwise incomprehensible result?

Its 100% responsible, from one perspective, because "bankruptcy" is one form of government "meddling" in economic markets.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by pg314 on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:15PM (#8016214)
Where do you get the 29% annual growth from? The article you linked to states 1,900% increase over 30 years. That works out to about 10.5% annual growth. That is still a decent increase, but no longer that extra-ordinary.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by chimeracoder on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:38PM (#8016370)
> NYC taxi medallion prices have grown by 29% annually over 30 years.

I agree that NYC has not increased the number of medallions in a manner commensurate with its growth since 1970. But this is like referring to the sale prices of commercial condos - you don't need to own a storefront in order to have a retail store (most business owners don't). Likewise, you don't need to own a medallion, just have access to one (ie, rent it, which is what most taxi drivers in NYC do).

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:07PM (#8015790)
Yes, yes it does.

If Uber could help usher in the end of some of the other government monopolies, we'd be looking at some huge steps forward.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by rayiner on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:16PM (#8015855)
I think it's time to reconsider a lot of state licensing regimes. But the fact that they're licensing regimes isn't what makes them bad. Licensing regimes are a perfectly reasonable way for the state to control behavior that involves negative externalities. I think almost everyone agrees that governments shouldn't allow factories to be created in residential areas, or allow drivers to drive without liability insurance.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tptacek on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:19PM (#8015860)
Careful: ancaps, hardly an Internet endangered species, definitely don't agree with this.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by zachlipton on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:21PM (#8016255)
And we don't necessarily have to take every single view seriously. The vast majority of people don't want a massive polluting factory built next to their single-family home. The fact that a few people disagree doesn't mean that every project get bogged down in a discussion of the legitimacy of zoning as a concept.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday July 10, 2014 @09:52PM (#8018482)
Ancaps simply have more efficient ways of keeping the polluting factories away from homes than existing zoning processes can achieve.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday July 10, 2014 @09:50PM (#8018480)
>I think almost everyone agrees that governments shouldn't allow factories to be created in residential areas, or allow drivers to drive without liability insurance.

Zoning is not needed for the former.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by simonh on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:16PM (#8015854)
I think it only makes sense to argue on a case by case basis. Saying one unreasonable practice is ok because there are other unreasonable practices is hardly constructive.

For example there is a fixed limit on available land, therefore it makes sense to regulate its use for the common good. The problem with licensing taxis isn't that they are licensed, it's that the number of licenses is fixed arbitrarily without regard to the actual need for taxis.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tptacek on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:20PM (#8015868)
So you're saying there is a valid public policy case for limiting the number of taxis, and you just think San Francisco got the number wrong? (For what it's worth: that's what I think too).
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by NiceOneBrah on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:12PM (#8015829)
>the argument that says medallions are bad public policy because they're monopolistic applies equally to many other forms of licensure, for instance zoning.

True; many of those other forms of licensure are also bad.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by lisper on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:21PM (#8015881)
Zoning is not a fair comparison. Land use has very different kinds of externalities than for-hire transportation. If I build a munitions plant next to your house that impacts you in ways that my getting paid to drive someone from A to B does not.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tptacek on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:31PM (#8015939)
Two responses.

First, land use has different externalities, but for-hire cars still have obvious externalities. And because of the civic role that taxis have assumed over the last 50 years, decisions about the management of the taxi market have still more externalities.

Second, my point wasn't that land use and taxis have the same issues, but rather that the logic that taxi medallions were bad public policy because "monopoly" was flimsy. Which, it is.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by lisper on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:26PM (#8016295)
> for-hire cars still have obvious externalities

Like what? Note that, for example, "They take up space on the road and pollute the air" doesn't count because not-for-hire cars do the exact same thing. It has to be an externality that is caused by the fact that the ride is for-hire. There may be such externalities, but I think they are far from obvious.

> the logic that taxi medallions were bad public policy because "monopoly" was flimsy

It's not the medallions per se that are the bad public policy, it's artificially limiting the supply (and then compounding the problem by making them transferrable). That's what the OP (almost surely) meant by "monopoly". Zoning also artificially constrains the supply of land available for certain uses, but that is clearly justifiable because of the (actually obvious) externalities of land use. The externalities of paying someone for a ride are far less clear.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by SilasX on Thursday July 10, 2014 @03:21PM (#8016641)
>Like what? Note that, for example, "They take up space on the road and pollute the air" doesn't count because not-for-hire cars do the exact same thing. It has to be an externality that is caused by the fact that the ride is for-hire. There may be such externalities, but I think they are far from obvious.

More specifically, the externality argument about taxis is that they take up space while hunting for fares, while private cars only drive when actually being used to get somewhere.

I agree though, that the point is irrelevant to Uber, since it's strictly a by-request car service that is not hailed from the street, and so doesn't cause the congestion that typical fare hunters would.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by sliverstorm on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:19PM (#8015863)
Not necessarily a failure. One of the purposes of medallions is to control the number of taxis on the road. It's a conscious choice, and the fallout is accepted in exchange for less taxi congestion.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tfinniga on Thursday July 10, 2014 @01:10PM (#8015809)
On the other hand, the limit on taxi medallions protects a common resource, room on the streets. Maybe the balance isn't right, but you're going to need some artificial limitation or else you're going to have a classic tragedy of the commons.
Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by nickff on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:12PM (#8016190)
There does not need to be an "artificial limitation" to protect every 'commons'.[1] Many have made the case that services like Uber and Lyft actually free up street space, and allow more people to get to work faster, because less parking spaces are required, and these services usually allow ride-sharing, which is banned (or effectively prevented) by many cities which license taxis and taxi companies.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elinor_Ostrom

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tfinniga on Friday July 11, 2014 @05:22AM (#8019377)
Thanks for the link to Elinor Ostrom.

It seems like what she was saying is that if the people who own and use the common resource have the ability to create rules and enforce them, then they can avoid a tragedy of the commons. I'd totally agree with that, you need some way to govern the resource.

About freeing up street space, I'd be curious to see some kind of statistics about how many lyft drivers were headed that way anyway and just pick up passengers vs. how many are providing a taxi-like service. Is there a way in the lyft or uber software as a driver to say that you're only looking for passengers going from one location to another location?

It seems like slugging is more likely to provide those benefits.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by nickff on Friday July 11, 2014 @06:46PM (#8022949)
Using ownership of a resource to give an incentive for preservation and long-term thinking has its roots at least as far back as Armen A. Alchian.[1] Ostrom's achievement was finding that many cultures had alternative solutions, and that these solutions were very effective.

I am sorry to say that I do not have the statistics that you are looking for.

[1] http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PropertyRights.html

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by mudetroit on Thursday July 10, 2014 @02:14PM (#8016202)
This isn't necessarily the case though. I am in no way going to argue that the "tragedy of the commons" is a real phenomenon. But their is a natural counterbalance to the streets filling up with taxis.

People operate taxis to make money. If the number of taxis becomes such that the roads fill with taxis, then the number or taxis should lower itself for two reasons. A.) If the taxis can't get anywhere either then people won't pay for them. B.) The ability of any single taxi to turn a positive profit will approach 0.

Re:Uber Makes Economists Sad by tfinniga on Friday July 11, 2014 @04:56AM (#8019323)
So I'm a bit confused by your phrasing. Are you saying that the tragedy of the commons isn't something that actually happens?

I agree with your point that there are natural pressures that would keep the number of taxis down if the artificial limitation was removed. It's just that I don't think that the natural equilibrium point financially is going to be the optimal level in terms of getting people where they want to go efficiently. In my mind, the entire transportation system is useful to provide a service to individuals and other sectors of the economy, and if it's not doing that well it doesn't matter much if the people working in transportation are at a natural equilibrium.

I'm also not saying that the medallion system is the right way to handle the situation. A taxi or car on the road uses up some common, limited resource (space on the road). Maybe you'd have more luck charging for that resource more directly, like a congestion charge?