News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by wil421 on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @08:34AM (#8009279)
>to see how ineffective AA is.

Please dont speculate on recovery unless you have first hand experience. I know many people who have improved their lives from AA and other meetings of the same type.

There are many people with addiction problems who do not trust doctors or religion and a place of like minded people is the only option for them (AA).

Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by hellodevnull on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @09:08AM (#8009403)
Yes I'm sure you do and I too know many people who improved their lives without going to AA. We're not going to persuade anyone talking about our personal experiences and how this guy Bob we know is doing really well.

Also I'm not speculating and I do have personal experience since you ask, I didn't say you need a psychiatrist and a prescription but from years of talking to addicts and going through recovery myself I've found that setting goals and staying positive and within limits and simple things like looking at changes in a certain way is very effective compared to what seems like a New Years Resolution that you'll likely fail and beat yourself for failing to keep up. Such therapy mentioned in the article can motivate people more than AA-style regimes can and that's more important in the long run.

Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by colanderman on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @08:50AM (#8009339)
Agreed. (I don't know why you're being downvoted.)

I've never been in AA but I am close to someone who has. The primary benefit I see AA provide them is a group of like-minded people who will do fulfilling non-drug-related activities with them.

Addiction is as much social as it is physiological. It's very difficult to quit an addiction if you continue to hang out with the same people in the same environment in which you developed your addiction. Replacing that social environment with a new one composed of people who are sworn to avoid those substances and which is filled with fulfilling activities unrelated to your addiction is a superb way to keep from slipping back into old habits.

Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by DanBC on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @09:01AM (#8009370)
> (I don't know why you're being downvoted.)

I didn't downvote but I have a knee-jerk reaction to want to downvote people using anecdotal evidence to support medical treatments.

[deleted]
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by 67726e on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @11:10AM (#8010025)
You're using your anecdotal experience to say that an entire profession of people who undergo many years of training don't understand the scope of the issue but that you do. That's why I downvoted you.
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by gizmo686 on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @09:04AM (#8009378)
People with first hand experience are not in a good posistion to judge how effective something is.
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by humanrebar on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @10:48AM (#8009873)
When doing scientific research, absolutely. When making a personal decision, it's foolish to ignore first-hand experience just as it's foolish to ignore advice from experts.
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by DanBC on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @11:49AM (#8010272)
> When making a personal decision, it's foolish to ignore first-hand experience

Isn't this exactly the kind of thinking that makes people believe that homeopathy works?

Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by mcelreath on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @01:20PM (#8010878)
Not exactly. You can have the opinion that Homeopathy as a medical treatment is a complete sham and 'does't work' and back up that opinion with research, but while there is debate as to the relative merit of 12-step programs compared to other forms of treatment, it would be strange to assert that they simply don't work for anyone ever.
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by humanrebar on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @02:26PM (#8011391)
Good point. I think homeopath is a load of bunk, but behavior modification deserves to be in another category. Especially considering the independent variables (going to an AA program) and dependent variables (substance abuse) tend to be clear in this case.

For example, saying "I put cumin oil in a vaporizer and now I don't get colds as often" is different than saying "I joined an AA program and now I have been sober for 10 years".

Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by voxic11 on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @03:19PM (#8011693)
How is that different?
Re:A Different Path to Fighting Addiction by humanrebar on Thursday July 10, 2014 @11:21AM (#8015249)
In this case:

* observation is simpler (are you in AA? are you still drinking?)

* so measurement is simpler (how much blortzroot do you add to your lotion to clear up that rash? can you show your rash is 65% better than last week?)

* AA attempts to provide a permanent solution, not a remedy for symptoms, so it's more clear when AA fails.

* Also the things homeopathy "cures" tend to be in a completely different class and severity than chronic substance abuse