News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by brotoss on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @04:37PM (#8006611)
Pretty slick way to earn 20 grand...nice work
Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by stevenh on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @08:15PM (#8007452)
Taking the following into consideration:

- The severity of the exploit, which may be nearly the maximum theoretical possibility on a site like Facebook, aside from SQL injection or remote code execution

- The multiple months worth of unpaid sleepless nights Stephen Sclafani likely spent exploring countless dead-ends before finding this

- The fact that he beat black hats to the punch by discovering it first and thus saved Facebook and its users from millions, perhaps billions, of dollars worth of damages stemming from vague and mysterious causes over an indefinite period of time

- The billions of dollars Facebook regularly uninhibitedly spends to acquire a given startup

I feel that $20,000 is a bit low.

Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by lstyls on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @12:21AM (#8008045)
"Insultingly low."

Really? 20K is about two months of salary for a Facebook engineer. So even if he did spend months on this like you speculate (he didn't) it's still an industry-leading salary.

Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by voltagex_ on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @06:51AM (#8008969)
Holy crap, I'm working for the wrong company.
Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by StevenRayOrr on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @08:45PM (#8007552)
> Insultingly low.

Oy.

Not that I am going to pretend that I know what the dollar value of Sclafani's time/effort should be, but I have a hard time believing that $20,000 is an insult. Just because he could get more money by exploiting the bug -- or showing others how to exploit it -- doesn't necessarily suggest to me that he should get paid more than he did.

Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by argonaut on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @12:43AM (#8008101)
The price you can get for something == its value.
Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by nbm on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @01:16AM (#8008184)
That's not totally accurate - sometimes you're exchanging more than just the item in question, for example, putting yourself in danger.

In other words, if you can sell an item for $100k if you follow a set of laws (a government's, an organisation's, a community's, or your own), but you could sell the item without doing so for $500k, the item is still really only worth $100k (to you), but the (physical/societal/moral) danger involved in selling the item illegally that goes with it is not worth $400k to you.

Or, put another way, the item may be valued at $500k (to some potential buyer), but the legal buyer of the item is offering not to put you in danger in exchange for $400k.

Re:Hacking Facebook’s Legacy API, Part 1: Making Calls on Be... by ohitsdom on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @09:15AM (#8009436)
I thought $20k was really low. GREAT value for Facebook. In the hands of black hats, trust in Facebook could have been destroyed before they had time to patch the vulnerability.