I hate the way to young people marrying out of "it makes sense" while guy goes to strip clubs every weekend and girls dream about some sexy guy taking them for a date. Its sick and sounds like pathology. Its really, really wrong.
Mortgage/Taxes is not the reason to get married. Love is. If you call me romantic, I am sorry, but it seems you didnt really seen true love.
(But no, I don't completely agree. It's just that it's a good question to answer, because it's so obviously partially right.)
Or rather, the relationships do make sense, but they are unaware or unwilling to consciously recognise the reasons why.
On the other hand, feeling when you're happy or not is something anyone can do.
Well we all have to make sacrifices in a partner, but when there is this overarching feeling that you're with the wrong person, then, you're probably with the wrong person.
I think the more conscious decisions you're making about someone, the more likely you are to be wrong, but that's my 2 cents.
Edit: My ex-fiancee was the one who gave up long before I did, when I was still trying to make things work.