News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MayDay PAC by nickff on Friday July 04, 2014 @04:02PM (#7990066)
One of the strongest arguments against FEC limits on speech is that many (very long-term) incumbent politicians support it. If these people support limits, it is most likely that they believe unlimited spending by outside groups will influence the populace in ways that are politically inconvenient (for the elected officials). Almost every American voter is (rightfully) skeptical of the honesty and integrity of their elected officials, and wants to allow for more political dynamism. It seems plain that unlimited campaign spending by outside groups will allow for new ideas, and real change.
Re:MayDay PAC by pron on Friday July 04, 2014 @05:52PM (#7990327)
> It seems plain that unlimited campaign spending by outside groups will allow for new ideas, and real change.

Absolutely not! Money is one of the most obvious forms of power in society, and therefore any group that has a lot of money to spend, is, by definition, already a significant part of the power structure. "Outside groups" with money are never true outside groups.

Re:MayDay PAC by baddox on Friday July 04, 2014 @06:41PM (#7990443)
Maybe that's true on a sufficiently large scale, but for local/state politics I don't think it applies. For example, I would imagine that several policies in San Francisco and the Bay Area would be very different if political influence was perfectly correlated with wealth/capital.
Re:MayDay PAC by warfangle on Saturday July 05, 2014 @12:34AM (#7991041)
On the other hand, policies of e.g., local government in North Carolina reflect the influence of the pork industry really clearly.
Re:MayDay PAC by nickff on Friday July 04, 2014 @06:37PM (#7990432)
If unlimited campaign spending is so advantageous to the political insiders, and entrenched interests, then why are they (McCain, Feingold, and other long-term career politicians) so opposed to it? How often do you see a politician advocate for something that puts them at a significant disadvantage, and helps their critics?
Re:MayDay PAC by cpeterso on Friday July 04, 2014 @07:12PM (#7990517)
Long time incumbents can assume their position is safe unless there is a well funded challenger. Incumbents have plenty of air time and name recognition.
Re:MayDay PAC by nickff on Friday July 04, 2014 @08:22PM (#7990649)
>"Long time incumbents can assume their position is safe unless there is a well funded challenger."

You have restated my position quite succinctly; FEC campaign regulations are a way of preventing "well funded challenger[s]".

Re:MayDay PAC by pron on Friday July 04, 2014 @07:33PM (#7990559)
Right. Money is not the only source of power.
Re:MayDay PAC by Avshalom on Friday July 04, 2014 @07:12PM (#7990516)
The media spent decades basically felating McCain for championing cfr.
Re:MayDay PAC by michaelt on Friday July 04, 2014 @07:46PM (#7990587)

  One of the strongest arguments against FEC limits on
  speech is that many (very long-term) incumbent politicians
  support it.
If I was a politician, I would attempt to capture both the benefits of big-money politics and the benefits of public opposition to big-money politics.

So, in my public speeches to voters I would claim I was 100% in favour of campaign finance reform - I'm concerned, just like you! I don't like these million-dollar donors, I got into politics to represent normal Americans like yourself! Unfortunately until the system changes I have to go along with it, obviously, so I will be taking some million-dollar donations. Once elected I'll get on that reform as soon as I can, honest! First I have to fix the economy/ensure national security/balance the budget/ban guns/fight terrorism/take on the banks/fix the college tuition bubble/deal with income inequality/reform patents/fix contraception access/educate more scientists/fix agricultural subsidies/reduce our dependence on foreign energy/reform immigration/fix the DHS/stand up to Putin/bring peace to the middle east/kiss this baby. As soon as those are done, campaign finance reform will be my top priority.

Hence, I'd get the money of the big donors without alienating regular voters by publicly supporting the current (messed up) state of campaign finance.

Re:MayDay PAC by cheese1756 on Saturday July 05, 2014 @02:41AM (#7991221)
How do we know that incumbents are afraid of super PAC spending because it will create change and influence the population? Couldn't it just be that they are afraid of a super PAC dumping money into attack ads and an opponent's campaign if they go against the wishes of a special interest group?
Re:MayDay PAC by georgemcbay on Friday July 04, 2014 @06:45PM (#7990452)
"It seems plain that unlimited campaign spending by outside groups will allow for new ideas, and real change."

New ideas, and real change... like the death of net neutrality. Great!

I really don't see how anyone could consider what you just said there logical considering that the people with (virtually) unlimited money (to donate to campaigns) historically always represent a very close overlap of the people who want to maintain the status quo that continues to earn them unlimited money.

Re:MayDay PAC by Qworg on Friday July 04, 2014 @05:40PM (#7990293)
How is unlimited spending by entrenched powers who have already "won" in the current system going to encourage political dynamism?

Most American voters aren't PAC contributors, at least in any meaningful way. Is their speech less important due to less cash in their pocket?