Re:Show HN: Proof of Position
by swang on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @03:01PM
(#7978929)
I kinda like the concept, except there is no way to prove you were there in the first place. It just proves you inputted a set of GPS coordinates at a specific time and can prove that.
Re:Show HN: Proof of Position
by danbruc on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @02:36PM
(#7978751)
Why? And even if there is a good reason this does not work because you can not prove that you actually were at the location you encoded into the block chain.
Re:Show HN: Proof of Position
by charleyhine on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @02:47PM
(#7978839)
Why? Wanted a decentralized database of memorable places I've visited.
Proof? The key pair signing the transaction proves it originated from this service. HTML5 geolocation data could be incorrect in the same way a Foursquare check-in doesn't prove one is actually at a given venue.
Re:Show HN: Proof of Position
by tg3 on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @03:17PM
(#7979025)
My guess would be the decentralized nature of it. Even if this service goes away (like Foursquare could), your check-ins with service won't (at least until the blockchain dies, which is presumably longer than an individual company).
Re:Show HN: Proof of Position
by danbruc on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @03:59PM
(#7979312)
I thought of that, too, but then - with bitcoin still in its infancy and far from sure to survive the next five years - I think that a cloud service is a far safer bet than the block chain. Or just have your own database on the site hosting the website.
Re:Show HN: Proof of Position
by Coffeewine on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @02:58PM
(#7978910)
It's quite unclear to me - how much does it cost to store this data in the blockchain? I'm imagining the quantity must not be nil as otherwise it'd be possible to DOS the blockchain by supplying a large quantity of useless data.
Proof? The key pair signing the transaction proves it originated from this service. HTML5 geolocation data could be incorrect in the same way a Foursquare check-in doesn't prove one is actually at a given venue.
Long story - It depends on the inputs to the transaction you want to make.