News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter to the Patent Office From Professor Donald Knuth (... by hbogert on Saturday June 28, 2014 @04:09PM (#7959174)
Excellent example of the lawyer's defense patent. I'm often in discussion with engineers from other fields taking patents as some holy grail. I now have some ammo to show that patents are not a generalized solution.

I do have one remark, Knuth refers to algorithms as fundamental building blocks, but as every programmer knows - we like to abstract upon abstractions making solutions higher level, so when does something stop being a building block and where does something start to be a patentable product.

Re:Letter to the Patent Office From Professor Donald Knuth (... by simonh on Saturday June 28, 2014 @04:29PM (#7959238)
It doesn't. It's building blocks all the way up. That's why I don't think that software should be patentable.
Re:Letter to the Patent Office From Professor Donald Knuth (... by jsmeaton on Saturday June 28, 2014 @11:03PM (#7960237)
I agree with you, but what about copyrightable? I don't think that "swipe gestures with 3 fingers in a diagonal motion" should be patentable. But I don't think blatant ripoffs of entire applications should be protected or encouraged either.
Re:Letter to the Patent Office From Professor Donald Knuth (... by Joeri on Sunday June 29, 2014 @07:59AM (#7960946)
If you copy the code, the specific artwork or the resulting binary, you're copying the expression, which is covered by copyright. If you copy the specific ornamental design, you may violate a design patent, if one was registered. If you copy the name or logo, or create one that is confusing, you may violate trademark law, if one was registered.

Software patents don't protect someone against blatant rip-offs of their product, those other laws do that. They merely prevent good ideas from disseminating quickly. The software patent system acts in exact opposition to its stated aim: encouraging innovation.

Re:Letter to the Patent Office From Professor Donald Knuth (... by m_mueller on Saturday June 28, 2014 @10:45PM (#7960206)
Exactly. That's what Copyright is for, a perfectly fine way of protecting a software developer's work.