News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by cm2012 on Friday June 27, 2014 @03:41PM (#7955921)
I guess the idea is - money is not the only resource. Your dad's genetics and nurture combined to make him an ambitious person. Your best friend's genetics and environment led to his decisions.

That's not to say that your dad isn't more valuable to humanity, etc., than your friend - he is. Nor is it to say that your friend shouldn't change - he should. But if you had the exact same genetics, and exact same life, isn't it literally impossible that you would have made different decisions?

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by bane on Friday June 27, 2014 @04:05PM (#7956045)
I don't know to be honest, and I agree I don't want to assume value of people on the whole of humanity based on their socio-economic conditions.

For example, my Grandfather was absolutely dirt poor. But he had my father. My father, when he was in Korea, volunteered time at the orphanages. My father-in-law and his brother were orphaned during the war and fondly remember U.S. soldiers coming to their orphanage with candies and clothes and things. It might even be possible that my father helped my father-in-law at one of those institutions. Regardless, he was helped enough so that he didn't die of starvation or exposure and instead became an architect and helped house thousands of people in post-war South Korea, and had 5 children who've all gone on to be educated, successful, very productive members of society.

In some way, my Grandfather, who was socio-economically at the bottom of the pile, by having my father, may have helped contribute to my wife's family in helping thousands of people put a roof over their heads and for my wife's generation to go on to do other good things. We're all connected in a way and it really is a small world.

But if socio-economic condition is one axis to measure "success", being able to house and feed yourself and your family based on the money you earn from your efforts should be a minimal barrier to being considered "successful". And I wholly understand that there are simply people who don't have opportunities to seize at all, who never get the decent paying job or the cheap reliable car or the grant to go to school. Who make a bad decision once and it impacts them for the rest of their lives no matter how many right decisions they make afterwards.

I think it's a pity that not everybody has opportunities to be upwardly mobile, but I also think it's a problem when opportunities are presented and continuously squandered, and years later, they sit there bankrupt and miserable and wonder why they can't get a leg up in life. As a person who is now (occasionally) in a position of creating opportunities, I'm cautious about who I help because I am afraid that the effort I might go through to create one, for people like my friend, will simply be wasted.

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by Retric on Friday June 27, 2014 @06:02PM (#7956483)
My father grew up poor, but well educated. He literally gained significant weight in basic training because he could eat as much as he wanted, at the same time his mother graduated from Harvard. It's hard being a single mother with kids and no savings.

In the end it was not hard for him to become moderately successful. But, his view on success and money was vary far from what "successful" people think. Heath, Stable job, good clean house, kids, and enough food is success. Just not the kind your going to read about.

IMO, as much as people look down on the middle class lifestyle there is little point to more because money is quickly just a number and unless you think you have enough it's never going to be enough. Which IMO raises an interesting question was my grandmother successful? Sure, she was living on the edge but she was self sufficient and her kids made it.

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by id on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:56PM (#7956467)
Let me rephrase your question: Is there a free will?

To me, determinism [1] is more plausible than free will. Events are always caused by prior events and in the end we have no control over our genetics and the conditions we were born into.

Of course I could be wrong and there is a realistic chance we will never find out.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Determinism

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by logicchains on Friday June 27, 2014 @11:10PM (#7957316)
It depends on how you define free will. If you define it as being 100% the cause of an action, that's impossible. There are two possible causes for an action: either you caused it, or something external caused it. If taking action X at time T is entirely the result of your choice, why did you choose it? Because of whatever influences made you the person you are at time T.

If these influences were external, by the definition in question your action wasn't entirely free will, as its root cause could be traced back to external influences. This means the person you were at time T-1 would have to be 100% responsible for the person you are at time T in order for you to be 100% responsible for taking action X at time T. The same also implies that the person you were at time T-2 would have to have been the cause of who you were at T-1, and so on recursively.

Trace that far backwards enough, and you get to the point where in order for you to be entirely the cause of your actions at time T, the person you were at time Tb would have to have been the cause of who you were at time Tb+1, where Tb is the time you were still a baby and incapable of conscious thought. This is not possible, as a baby doesn't 'make decisions' in the conscious sense, it acts purely from the impulses condition by its genes and whatnot.

Thus if you chase the causal chain far back enough in time, you see there's always an external root cause for an action.

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by bnjms on Saturday June 28, 2014 @03:22AM (#7957687)
This was the conclusion I came to when I first considered the question. I later decided it was a moot point. The question "is there free will" generally assumes or implies to most people, I think, that if there is not free will there is no matter in day to day choices. But that's silly because as far as I can see determinism applies to systems and from within the system our will is indistinguishable from free will. (Not sure how to word the leap here.) And believing in not free will, if it causes paralysis, results in less desirable deterministic outcomes anyway. So it's best for most people to assume free will.
Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by logicchains on Saturday June 28, 2014 @09:04AM (#7958084)
I think often free will is a fuzzy concept people use to represent some kind of feeling/function/mode/whatever that exists in the psyche. As in, there's some kind of positive feeling associated with being in control, and when people speak of free will they don't necessarily have a clearly defined concept in mind, rather are speaking in reference to that feeling.

I'm not sure I expressed myself so clearly there. What I mean is that, the concept of free will disbelief in which is associated with paralysis is distinct from the philosophical/logical concept, but these two are often conflated. The logical understanding of free will not existing can actually be emotionally liberating; it acts as a balm against hatred and whatnot for instance, as it's difficult to hate someone when you see their actions as merely following a mechanistic, predetermined path. This kind of thing was an important concept in Spinoza's Ethics (Spinoza famously denied free will), and I believe also played a role in Buddha's teachings.

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by johnchristopher on Sunday June 29, 2014 @06:25PM (#7962725)
This is existentialism.
Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by id on Saturday June 28, 2014 @11:43AM (#7958454)
Of course there are external causes. Events are caused by your decisions and external causes. Very often external causes have more influence and they can also influence your future behaviour.

When I said there is no free will, I meant that you can't influence your own decisions. In fact, according to this theory, "you" is just a product of your mind. Your brain just follows the law of physics and chemistry. Decisions are made by your synapses and are the result of your past experiences, genetics, hormones, logic, emotions and surroundings. So if there would be an all-knowing being that knows the exact state of the universe and how things interact, it could calculate the future.

I don't define free will as being 100% the cause of an action. I would define it as the "freedom to do otherwise in the same circumstances".

Bear in mind that this is just a theory. But even if it's wrong, the influence we have over our life might be smaller than we tend to think.

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by jqm on Saturday June 28, 2014 @12:46AM (#7957444)
"Thus if you chase the causal chain far back enough in time, you see there's always an external root cause for an action."

I'm not sure I agree 100%, but I agree at least 99%.

I believe humans have the possibility of free will. But it in practice it's very rare and most of the time is exactly what you state.

See G.I. Gurdjieff for more on this. Probable crank, conman, and (I believe) probably correct on at least this point.

He states (rather his pupil Ouspensky states from his teachings), that we have the potential to develop free will, but it is not a native attribute, and most of the time we simply respond to stimuli and conditioning. I tend to agree.

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by logicchains on Saturday June 28, 2014 @09:09AM (#7958098)
Interesting. His theory reminds me of something called the Theory of Positive Disintegration[1], a theory of personality in which only through active reflection and self-confrontation can people develop a conscious personality that's not just the result of biological and social pressures.

1.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_Disintegration

Re:Commencement address by Bill and Melinda Gates by taway98765 on Saturday June 28, 2014 @07:03AM (#7957938)
1) Genes do play a role but it's still an ongoing research on the real impact they have. The current upper estimate for general intelligence is around 7-10%[1] which leaves the median of the population unaffected(meaning, 1 in 10k people born in poverty may be able to escape a slam and be successful(with all the grey area this word entails) because if this random boost - but the median is what we should focus on when designing our social/educational system .. sooo

2) We're all different* in a way but its primarily our environment that stimulates our intellect. From early age - music, lego/toys boosting creativity, conversations promoting curiosity about the world around .. educated parents(with enough free time and financial/social security[2]) and good schools - mozart would not write a single note had he been born in a poor lumberjacks family(he might have been a pina always playing tunes with some wood laying around - but even this is probably not true since he wouldn't have been exposed to music during his early life(~3-5y) meaning his brain wouldn't wire itself sufficiently to enjoy music as much as to become suff. motivated to go through the hassle/it would be difficult to "grow" a reward cycle for this particular activity; and even if - even if he had understanding parents etc - if they couldn't afford to get him a music instrument/send him to music school he'd probably end up as a lumberjack anyway)

It's time to get our heads out of our as*s, throw away the sociopathic narcissism/individualism that is so blatantly being promoted these days and look at the reality: You can't really boost your egos looking from above on all the people living in poverty/homeless/lower class or those who just "didn't make it" - because you haven't had the same starting position( >1) ). It would be OK to feel "superior" - looking at your car-park/property list - and despise people below(well not really but lets forget about the implications for now) - if everyone would have the same opportunities as you had(pre-school - should filter out bad parenting as well - /school/uni/entry capital/enough social and financial security to be able to take the same risks ..). In such a world - with a working education system and social safety net - there would still be "losers", a lazy good-for-nothing percentage/large leisure-crowd but if one of them decided that - after 10y of doing nothing, with friends all making contributions to medicine/science/writing novels/doing art he'd want to do something with his life too(which is the default for most people - till our current education system won't beat this out of your head) - he should have an opportunity to start school/business/project without taking 2 jobs and putting his family on an emergency budget ..

BTW The Original Position by John Rawls is a good thought experiment for this discussion[3]