News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by caycep on Friday June 27, 2014 @03:36PM (#7955887)
The one worry, and this is more of an ancillary one, is that now without the Aperture competition, Adobe will let lightroom development slack off. Lightroom is (was) one of the adobe apps that don't totally suck, and I always credited this w/ them getting taken off guard by Aperture (competitions is a great thing, etc etc). That being said, I suppose the writing is on the wall and whatever changes in direction were in store for lightroom is probably already in motion.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by mortenjorck on Friday June 27, 2014 @04:22PM (#7956109)
I'm not even so worried about Adobe letting Lightroom languish as I am about them using their newfound monopoly position to at last move Lightroom into the mandatory Creative Cloud subscription model that ate the Creative Suite last year. As an enthusiast photographer and avid Lightroom user, there's no way I'm paying a recurring subscription for the same app when I'm not using it to make an income.

That said, there's a potential twist here. Apple's upcoming Photos app can go one of two directions: Apple could, as everyone seems to be assuming, go the consumer-focused route and stay out of Lightroom's market. On the other hand, Photos could pack all of Aperture's pro features and more behind an "advanced mode" UI. Suddenly, Lightroom isn't just competing with an Apple product, they're competing with free.

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by coldtea on Friday June 27, 2014 @09:14PM (#7957095)
>I'm not even so worried about Adobe letting Lightroom languish as I am about them using their newfound monopoly position to at last move Lightroom into the mandatory Creative Cloud subscription model that ate the Creative Suite last year.

I think they've already done that, a few months ago.

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by uptown on Friday June 27, 2014 @10:37PM (#7957251)
You can still buy stand-alone Lightroom, though they also offer it as part of the $10/month Photography subscription where you get both Photoshop and Lightroom.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by coldtea on Saturday June 28, 2014 @06:10AM (#7957895)
I see. I had the impression the standalone version was off-ed by now.

I myself have forked for the PS + Lightroom subscription -- and I hate subscriptions --, and the reason was, that, if I am not mistaken, you can't use the Lightroom app for iPad without the subscription.

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by dublinben on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:01PM (#7956286)
The copy of Lightroom you have right now isn't going to suddenly stop working, even if the next version becomes part of CC. If somehow it does fail to do the job for you in the future, you can switch to DarkTable, RawTherapee, CaptureOne, or any number of other programs.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by jonknee on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:42PM (#7956417)
It will stop working if you ever get a new camera. RAW formats are all different and Lightroom needs constant updates to support new camera models. It's a huge mess, the camera companies don't make the specs public and the formats change subtly with camera releases. Adobe obviously gets access to the formats, but open source tools are left to guess and it shows.

I just had this burn me when I got a new camera (Panasonic GH4) and I couldn't import a thing. Even worse is that I was on a road trip and didn't have a way to install the software that came with the camera (also terrible, but I took photos at Yellowstone and badly wanted to see them). As of the last week an update came out and now I'm good to go, but if you want to remain on an old version of Lightroom it can indeed be tricky.

None of the other programs you mentioned are anywhere close to Lightroom. For example, while RawTherapee can technically open images from my new camera, it displays them incorrectly. They're not even the right size and I don't want to talk about color.

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by SourPatch on Friday June 27, 2014 @06:23PM (#7956551)
You might want to play around with Darktable (http://www.darktable.org). I have no affiliation other than using it a bit. I use an Olympus EM-5 and it handles the raw files just fine.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by jonknee on Friday June 27, 2014 @08:01PM (#7956866)
I have an E-M5 too (great camera!), but it has been out quite a while which helps out. It's still not perfect though, the color is off a bit for the E-M5's RAW images (.ORF). The GH4 images are unusable in Darktable, they look they have been through an Instagram filter. This is straight off the camera in both Darktable and Lightroom:

http://i.imgur.com/6v0mbUb.jpg

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by lukasb on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:51PM (#7956450)
good lord, why don't the camera companies publish specs?
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by jonknee on Friday June 27, 2014 @08:08PM (#7956885)
It's rage inducing, but I think they are of the opinion that it's part of their secret sauce. I get the idea that they're all similar enough so that open source apps can get most of the way there, but Adobe has the full specs and is able to get them perfectly.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by secabeen on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:34PM (#7956399)
True, but it won't handle or process RAW files from your new camera. Yes, you can use the free Adobe tool to convert RAW to DNG, but that adds another step, and reduces some of the current simplicity of Lightroom.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by dublinben on Friday June 27, 2014 @09:45PM (#7957154)
You can't expect software written before your camera was even released to support it. It will never stop working for existing cameras. What more can you expect?
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by iSnow on Friday June 27, 2014 @04:35PM (#7956178)
Apple never does simple/advanced mode UIs
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by Bud on Friday June 27, 2014 @06:41PM (#7956599)
Also, compare clicking on various Menu Bar items (or other UI features) with option-clicking on the same item. Apple has advanced little mini UIs all over the place.

Similarly, look at many current System Preferences panels in Mac OS X. The basic stuff most users need is up front, and the rest is hidden behind an "Advanced..." button.

I conclude that having an advanced mode, or various enhanced features accessed in different ways from the standard UI, is not inimical to Apple's approach or UI philosophy.

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by andymcsherry on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:00PM (#7956280)
Not the best example, but the OSX calculator app seems to have this.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by rikf on Friday June 27, 2014 @09:21PM (#7957107)
Aqua (GUI) and Terminal (CLI)
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by sbuk on Friday June 27, 2014 @05:03PM (#7956293)
Lightroom isn't the only game in town. Both CaptureOne from PhaseOne and DxO's Optics Pro handle raw files better than ACR. Bibble also still exists in the guise of Corel After Shot. There are a few decent OSS options too. it looks like Apple are incorporating the Aperture toolset into the new photo app, so it's not necessarily the end of the world.
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by stan_rogers on Friday June 27, 2014 @08:05PM (#7956877)
With Apple supplying the RAW codecs with the OS, Hasselblad's Phocus [1] is a viable (and gratis) alternative on the Mac. For Windows types, it's only good for Hassy's own cameras, but if OS X understands hte RAW format, Phocus can work with it.

[1] http://www.hasselbladusa.com/products/phocus-.aspx

Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by nicholassmith on Friday June 27, 2014 @04:02PM (#7956027)
I don't think Adobe will slack off too much, they know it's a massively popular product but that most photographers are geeks and won't put up with them taking their foot off the gas, they'll look elsewhere (although elsewhere is mostly nothing at the moment).
Re:Apple to Cease Development of Aperture and Transition Use... by binaryorganic on Friday June 27, 2014 @04:10PM (#7956061)
This seems like all the more reason for Adobe to double down on Lightroom if you ask me. They stand to gain a lot of displaced users from this. I'm certainly going to have to make a choice now.