I work at Nest and it may be a little unclear at the moment (we're working on it), but The Nest API does not guarantee that if you send an ETA of 15 minutes (docs: https://developer.nest.com/documentation/eta-guide), the home will heat to the appropriate level in 15 minutes. It's actually filtered through our algorithms to determine the best course of action to not waste energy but also provide the appropriate level of comfort.
I have a modulating (i.e. change flame level) condensing boiler (the highest efficiency available). I programmed it to run as close to 24/7 as I could, because that way it uses the lowest flame, which is the most efficient flame.
When I tried a setback thermostat when the boiler attempted to rewarm the house it shifted to a higher and therefor less efficient flame. So I gave up on that and let it run on low all the time. So there would be no peak usage by me.
As people shift to more efficient ways to heating I suspect that this will happen to everyone. Not just modulating boilers, but also multi-stage heating with a heat pump. By trying to rapidly heat the home you can't use the heat pump.
It's also true with an A/C - the faster you are trying to cool the larger temperature gradient you need, and therefor you lose efficiency.
If I'm wrong here I would be happy to be corrected, but the US Government seems to agree with me: https://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?c=archives.thermostats_...
I'm not sure that's always correct. The Coefficient of Performance (heat moved/work done, higher COP is better) of an A/C is:
COP = T_hot / (T_hot - T_cold).
T_cold is the inside temp, T_hot is outside of the heat exchanger. The narrow the temperature range, the better the COP. Thus the A/C will actually be more efficient in terms of heat moved per watt while it's cooling a warm house down than when it's already cool.
There's one other factor that applies. The rate of heat transferring into the house is proportional to the temperature difference. Once the house has warmed up, you reach equilibrium. The net heat flow stops, so the total amount of energy you need to remove later stops rising. If you run the A/C all the time, heat is transferring in all the time. So the total amount of heat you need to move back outside in a day increases significantly if you leave the A/C on.
Without those assumptions your analysis is correct, and a setback thermostat seems to always be a win for A/C.
The energy loss from your home increases as the differential between inside and outside increases, right? So at night or when you're out, if your house were kept colder, then you'd lose less energy to the outside.
So by keeping your heating running 24/7, you're wasting some energy in the extra energy loss when you're out, right?
How does this compare to the efficiency gain by running your more efficient flame? Have you calculated or measured that you actually save energy overall?
Yes, but I can't let it cool very far, so it's only a small energy saving.
> How does this compare to the efficiency gain by running your more efficient flame?
The boiler can be up to 98.6% efficient at low flame, going down to 86% at full flame.
And after experimenting it always ended up at full flame when trying to rewarm a house.
> Have you calculated or measured that you actually save energy overall?
I tried, but I couldn't, winters are just so variable. I even emailed the EPA asking if they had research data, but they didn't.
So you're accepting the ETA request not as a demand to obtain a certain temperature, but as a request, and then still taking utility demand information into account. Excellent.
Thanks for the insight, btw.
This is a nonsensical view of the concepts of value and money.
Secondly, it's silly to object to innovation that allows humanity to be frivolous or wasteful according to their desires. Where do you draw the line? Why have central heating in the first place? Is it that difficult to wear a sweater indoors? If people want to be warm, they will utilize technology to be warm. And if that technology progresses to allow this process to be simple, efficient, and automated, people will use it. And not just those in the luxury market.
This was using dumb thermostat technology. If we were back later than usual, the house still got warm. If we stayed up later than normal, the house started to get chilly. Smart thermostats that know what you're doing can help even more, but the less predictable you are, the more the gains from the thermostat being linked to other systems to monitor what you're doing. If you're home the same time every day and go to bed at the same time, the gains will be less.
BTW, I also discovered that our dishwasher warmed the kitchen by 2C. The obvious conclusion was that it was best to use its timer to start it at 4am, so the waste heat has already warmed the kitchen by the time we're up for breakfast.
Imagine thousands of households doing something smarter.
A couple of hours after 6pm and a couple of hours just before you wake up. All controlled from a simple timer.
Yes, Nest would be a fancier solution, but I don't really see much benefit a part from the 'coolness' factor.
I guess Nest is heading towards this direction, but pre-warming a house very "first-world".
Imagine a neighborhood of 100 homes where you know all 100 people will return approximately at 6pm in the winter, and they all want 72 degrees. Taking into account the insulation of each home, if you could pre-heat the homes on a rolling schedule (say, heat 25 of them to 75 degrees at 3pm, accounting for 1 degree of heat dissipation per hour, heat another 25 to 74 degrees at 4pm, etc.), you will actually in aggregate save a lot of energy and cost because of inefficiencies in the way we deliver and generate energy during peak times.
(@yitchelle - central data center)
Especially given that this works best for second homes like a weekend house in Tahoe where it might take a full day to warm up if you left the heat off all week.
A simple, programmable thermostat will make up for the purchase within the first year of service.
My otherwise boring furnace is variable speed and the longer its on, the faster it runs. It's really roaring after about 30 minutes. Its more than a decade old, this is pretty old COTS tech. My first zillion BTU cost me somewhat less than my last zillion BTU in any heating cycle.
I live in a cold northern climate with great insulation and low heating bills and a variable speed furnace and the house is basically never empty (spouse and I work at home often enough, etc). The whole "nest" idea doesn't work financially for me although it is interesting to watch.
While there is no momentum in heat transfer, the walls of your house store heat. If you're away long enough to allow your house to cool down it will take more fuel than it would to keep it at a reasonable temperature. Also, this is much, much more comfortable than to arrive in a stone cold house, only to open a window 30 minutes later because of the blazing heat.
I'm not saying it's always better to keep a certain temperature, though. It depends on the time that you're away, the insulation of your house, the outside temperature, the efficiency of your boiler, etcetera. But, having lived in houses with ordinary thermostats and non-modulating boilers and houses with programmable thermostats and modulating boilers I can tell you this: I'm not going back to the old stuff. The indoor climate is so much better now!
There was never any question on using this system; everyone I know has this, unless they live in a really old house or an apartment block with common heating. It's a standard for heating systems called OpenTherm.
Is this really that uncommon, or is this a European thing?
I can't believe more people don't know about these things. They predate the Nest by 5-10 years.
You think you can bear it - until you absolutely can't, and immediately turn it to the highest setting you can because damn it you want it warm now.
Then it's warm (or too hot) and you turn it off to cool down faster and...rinse repeat.
For most people it's far more efficient to turn the air conditioner on to a given temperature setting, so when they enter a room they don't have any immediate reaction to "make it warmer or colder". We are exceptionally bad at judging these things in the moment.
In Winter, we use space heaters (new ceramic ones that start outputting heat in 10 seconds that are kid safe to touch) in the bedrooms and a very low central heat.
Of course we have over-standard insulation and trees nearby - anyone in a top floor of an apartment complex will most certainly be using AC almost every summer day (but probably not shivering at all during winters).
A person driving a Mercedes-Benz is probably not one to care about saving the half a dollar in energy consumption to pre-heat the living space. So, it's not difficult, but not not-difficult, either.
OK, there could be a use-case where the elderly is due to arrive home and needs the house to be at the right temperature for health reasons. But this is clearly not the use case being put forward by Nest. It uses s luxury Mercedes Benz and is spinning it for luxury market.