What it sounds like to me is that the court is leaving open the possibility of software patents that are more like the former case, although the vast majority are more like the latter.
Abstract idea: something to clean your windshields in case of rain/snow
Non-abstract (concrete) idea: a device composed by a wipe, mechanically connected to a motor that cleans the windshield with an oscillating motion
It almost seems then that written into the definition of non-abstractness is that the idea could be implemented multiple ways. In other words, If there was no possible other way to make a windscreen wiper then the abstract idea itself would be sufficient to specify the actual implementation (or the implementation can be derived as an inevitable logical consequence of the abstract idea). But if we can postulate a different way (perhaps less optimal) then we can say there is an abstractness about the original idea.
I still have trouble with this though because the point where you define the abstractness seems a bit arbitrary. There are many ways to make a wiper blade, a rotating mechanism, a motor, etc. So aren't those abstract too? If the patent specifies it exactly then it is truly concrete, but then it's too specific - competitor can just use a slightly different material.
And then at some point we invent a generically programmable army of nanobots that swarm to accomplish any physical task using a goal oriented AI type language ... and now merely specifying the idea IS the implementation for ANY task.
Were it not for patents, inventors would resort to the only tool at their disposal to limit free implementation of their ideas: the trade secret.
On the other hand, imagine someone found out a way to cure cancer. If he just releases his formula, then there's a very good chance that he will not make any money off of it at all. Without patent protection, he will probably hoard the discovery for years while building a company of his own to sell the drug. Finally, the drugs will be available, and yet the public will still have no knowledge of how to develop the drug, improve it even further, or apply it to other diseases.
I'm not personally a big fan of patents. I'm merely addressing your comments, which I see to be somewhat irrelevant.
Let me ask you, as a rational, profit-seeking individual or organization looking to secure revenue from your new invention in a patent-free society. Do you:
a. Volunteer the details of your invention to your competitors?
b. Keep these details secret?
Moreover, what would it take to get you to choose option a?
However, to handle your own strawman, the answer is b. I'd keep the details secret. Which is not a problem, because there have been many, many occassions when someone reverse engineers the work or comes up with the idea completely independently.
The point of Alice Corp. would then be to remove the loophole of merely writing up an abstract process as a computer program running on a generic computer; the process would have to be linked to specific hardware characteristics to pass the test (obvious examples would be an MRI scanner, anti-lock brakes, or device drivers).
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine-or-transformation_test
Abstract: A way of making video files smaller by compressing it using various mathematical procedures. Patentable: A way of making a video file smaller by braking it down to keyframes and than ......... {detailed description of one specific way of doing it}....
I think that's the line the supreme court is drawing.
The court decision this week seems to entangle two things; the fact that the abstract idea was not novel, and the fact that it was abstract. It is not clear to me: had the abstract idea itself been truly novel - would that have changed the outcome? A lot of people are saying this ruling is against patenting abstract ideas but it seems to me that it is mostly about the fact that directly transcribing an idea to a computer doesn't ADD concreteness (or novelty?), NOT a judgement about the veracity of the original idea. Would love to hear any insight about this.