c. Appear to volunteer the details, but obfuscate them so deeply in patentese that nobody can ever tease them out, but I still get to sue my competitors.
How is that a strawman? He said that patents were introduced to allow ideas to be disseminated. That's a faulty premise.
However, to handle your own strawman, the answer is b. I'd keep the details secret. Which is not a problem, because there have been many, many occassions when someone reverse engineers the work or comes up with the idea completely independently.
Let me ask you, as a rational, profit-seeking individual or organization looking to secure revenue from your new invention in a patent-free society. Do you:
a. Volunteer the details of your invention to your competitors?
b. Keep these details secret?
Moreover, what would it take to get you to choose option a?