Having worked in government for well over a decade now, I can tell you that this is undoubtedly the case. That is not to say all departments have poor practices, but on the whole there is no standardization and each organization does things differently.
I have worked in offices that have NO server archive and everyone relies on PST's, and others where there are server archives but they are limited to 500MB or something small and they just start deleting items by date.
It's common for the contractor to own all the IT equipment and just lease it to the government. What happens when it's time to change contracts and every single computer, phone, printer has to be replaced. There is no possibility for competitive bidding in the wake of that.
It's an awful system, but a lot of it has to do how government awards IT contracts and how quickly they are out of date.
It's a fine coverup since what is the recourse? It's worked before, so why not now?
Yes, Friday news dumps are shitty. They're also standard practice in politics. The fact that it wasn't mentioned in the original document requests, though, might just be an extension of the aforementioned incompetence.
> It's a fine coverup since what is the recourse? It's worked before, so why not now?
What's worked before? Failing to keep the purported coverup secret and also turning over a large number of the purportedly destroyed documents because they were recoverable from other sources?
If you're looking to see intentional bad behavior, fine. But this kind of digital stupidity happens all over. I've no doubt that corporate America is full of Exchange implementations with small mailbox limits and a reliance on PST files that are stored locally.
Losing documents in all the other Congressional requests the last couple of years. Hell, a unrelated FOIA request produced documents for a news org that weren't given to the committee. There are no real consequences so why worry. If there was a problem and they didn't mention it in the original request then it is very close to criminal. I do believe the Official Records Act has been grossly violated at this point.
The point being the IRS is supposed to be apolitical.
Lois Lerner pleaded the fifth couple of months back. She is accused of harassing tea party donors.
Lois Lerner in 2011: Receiving a Thick Questionnaire from the IRS Is a "Behavior Changer"
http://patterico.com/2013/07/10/lois-lerner-in-2011-receivin...
> The IRS said technicians went to great lengths trying to recover data from Lerner's computer in 2011. In emails provided by the IRS, technicians said they sent the computer to a forensic lab run by the agency's criminal investigations unit. But to no avail.
> The IRS was able to generate 24,000 Lerner emails from the 2009 to 2011 because Lerner had copied in other IRS employees. The agency said it pieced together the emails from the computers of 82 other IRS employees.
So, reading between the lines here, it looks like the IRS doesn't archive email at the server level, and any copies of mail were retrieved from individual workstations.
I don't see conspiracy here. I see incompetent IT processes and a lack of mandated data retention policies. Maybe I'm predisposed to employ Hanlon's razor, but that's only because I've found it to be the best explanation for most situations like this. If it was a coverup, it's a terrible one.