It depends on how the FCC classifies the ISPs. If the FCC classifies the ISPs as a common carrier, then yes that will basically force them to honor net neutrality. Due to <politics>, the FCC has been reticent to classify the ISPs as common carriers (instead classifying them as infomation services), but it has tried to regulate them as a common carrier in some ways (but not in all ways), ie net neutrality.
Recently verizon took the fcc to court over this and the gist of the court's ruling was 'The FCC has the power to enforce net neutrality on the ISPs iff it designates the ISPs as common carriers.'
> An effective net neutrality policy could even harm our economy, if its a rule that nobody else needs to play by.
An effective net neutrality rule could just as easily bolster our economy if no one else decides to play by that rule. What makes you think that net neutrality isn't a competitive advantage?
> If we want access to a free internet, we need to figure out how to democratize the infrastructure.
It's hard to democratize the infrastructure because it is so expensive to keep and maintain, short of nationalizing it like the interstate system, though based on the previous paragraph I don't think that's what you meant.
Can you expand on this? I don't see it. What does it matter to America, if Brazil allows telcos to meter speed to subscribers based on bribes paid by third parties?
For instance, let's say Brazil's telcos started throttling their citizens' access to Netflix, but not to Braziliflix, a hypothetical Brazilian version of Netflix. That could prevent Netflix from gaining traction in Brazil. Meanwhile, Braziliflix would be free to compete on an even playing field for customers in the US.
Meanwhile, consumers in Brazil enjoy shitty services and exorbitant prices...
Why do you think that?
To some extent. This was discussed extensively in the recent Verizon-FCC lawsuit.
On US soil with US citizens and US companies, it should be simple. But it is a complicated world in which we live, so it sounds like the FCC could only really protect equality in the best of circumstances.
For the sake of conversation, lets say the FCC isn't powerful enough. Lets say the internet is just too powerful, and there is no hope of the FCC or any other organization to regulate it. Would net neutrality be lost forever? Is it lost already?
Even if the US government did somehow manage to regulate the US-based telcos, the FCC would have no legal way of regulating net neutrality outside of the US. An effective net neutrality policy could even harm our economy, if its a rule that nobody else needs to play by.
If we want access to a free internet, we need to figure out how to democratize the infrastructure. As long as we depend on fiber and copper controlled by big companies, net neutrality will continue to slip through our fingers like water.