News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non Compete Clauses Reduce Innovation by SilasX on Thursday June 12, 2014 @10:40PM (#7887208)
Me: A right you can't waive is burdensome.

You: Well, Black's law disagrees. Under current precedent some rights can't be waived.

Me: But my point is just that such laws are stupid. To the extent that waiving a right can lead to bad situations, the problem is the lack of true, informed consent and so should be addressed at that level.

You: Current legal precent refutes that.

Me: ???

Re:Non Compete Clauses Reduce Innovation by dredmorbius on Friday June 13, 2014 @12:35AM (#7887453)
I don't care to get into this debate now because reasons.

But you might want to look up why certain rights are generally considered or legislated to be non-waivable.

Guiding hint: it sets up perverse incentives, creates tremendous power imbalances (and exacerbates existing ones), and, net net, is seen as a negative for society.

You haven't made any points, you've asserted them, backing up along an increasingly narrow and slippery, and steep platform as you're cornered with a set of inconvenient facts regarding your case. Among the reasons I find any discussion with you to be, in all likelihood, to be tremendously unproductive.

So I'm out, but you're welcome to research further on your own.

Re:Non Compete Clauses Reduce Innovation by SilasX on Friday June 13, 2014 @01:05AM (#7887512)
>But you might want to look up why certain rights are generally considered or legislated to be non-waivable.

I'm intimately familiar with them! It's why I've come to my conclusion: all of the reasons are either confused, would invalidate the right to sell one's apples, or are an issue of informed consent that only justify greater scrutiny, waiting periods, etc rather than a blanket "lol you can't trade that right".

Had you read my responses, you could have articulated -- perhaps even substantiated -- those reasons in your own words the first (not fourth) time around, rather than dwell on the orthogonal issue of how many jurists agree with you. Then we could have had a productive discussion and probed each other regarding the basis for our beliefs, and perhaps learn something from each other.

But as it stands, you chose to condescendingly lecture me about issues that don't speak to those I raised, as per my previous reply.

Next time, would you mind focusing on the substance, rather than on citing Black's Law to refute that "a right ... is not a right" and such?

For example, you could have said something like, "well, inalienable rights can definitely feel like obligations, but capping what people can waive has the following benefit ..." And then gone on about the stuff you're only now saying. See how much more productive that is?