News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So you didn't get into Y Combinator, now what? by Jemaclus on Thursday June 12, 2014 @01:07PM (#7884587)
Are there any meta-analyses of YC "I didn't get into YC" / "I got into YC" posts that can give a more objective conclusion to this kind of thing? We almost always see these posts from individual founders who did [not] make it into YC and what they think the reasons are. It's all anecdotal.

I realize the plural of anecdote is not data, but it would be nice to see some real scholarly analysis of what happens to YC applicants, as opposed to a series of anecdotal and speculative blog posts. Denis is both a founder and a YC advisor, so maybe his anecdotes are a little higher quality than others, but even so, they're still anecdotes.

Which brings me to my other point: every couple of months we get flooded with "I didn't get into YC" and they all basically say the same thing (or at least variations on the same thing). It seems to me that anyone who is applying to YC would already read up as much as they can about YC applicants, which includes reading every "I didn't get into YC" post they can find. After reading 5 or 10 of them, they'll quickly realize there are the same 5 lessons from each one. Why read any more? (Which translates to: why post another "I didn't get into YC" post?)

Anyway, just kinda thinking out loud here. I would love to see a more comprehensive, multi-applicant analysis instead of yet-another-anecdotal-blog-post.

[Edit: Next up on a Jemaclus post, how many times can I use the word "anecdote" in one comment? Stay tuned...]

Re:So you didn't get into Y Combinator, now what? by denismars on Thursday June 12, 2014 @01:29PM (#7884755)
Agreed, although, the aim here is not to focus on the 'why' part? It's to focus on the 'where to go from here' part. The 'why' will always be anecdotal as it's one perspective vs another. The key to this post is really honing in on the fact that the best entrepreneurs can take setbacks yet still move on to succeed in their endeavors to build amazing companies with our without YC. Which 'anecdotally or otherwise' makes for the best YC applicants.
Re:So you didn't get into Y Combinator, now what? by free2rhyme214 on Thursday June 12, 2014 @01:12PM (#7884625)
I agree but you don't really need an in depth reason why because at the end of the day you gotta make it happen or don't.

I think it's just annoying to see posts about the same topic someone already mentioned several times again.

It's like yup I've heard that before and then my response is, "Okay so what are you doing about it?"