News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by ChuckMcM on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @03:14PM (#7879861)
It is a bit more nuanced than that, ARPANet was a lot of DEC machines, USC and USC-ISI had a number of DEC-10's on the network. Usenet was however primarily a bunch of UNIX (or UNIX like) machines. They traded in their modems for nifty connections to the Internet and carried a lot of the same protocols with them. Much of the Internet protocols were developed in college labs with the ability to 'plug in' different UNIX configurations (the BSD sockets stuff) and since the code was tested well on UNIX was often the operating system on the machine that connected someone to the emerging Internet at the time. Lisp systems were popular for research, but were not used extensively for networking research. I expect it was in part a compatibility issue with BSD's socket stuff (where a lot of research was happening).

A more interesting alternate history for me would be if the folks doing system research had settled on a functional language like Haskell rather than a procedural one like C, what would our APIs look like today. I say that because I suspect that using C as a the language of choice was more influential than the OS of choice.

Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by lispm on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @03:27PM (#7879948)
Lisp Machines were usually networked machines. Their were two branches:

* Interlisp-D from Xerox were smaller machines, networkd with a server + printer. PARC developed networked collaborative software for them, the first remote GUI was written for Interlisp, the first IMAP client was written for Interlisp-D, ...

* the MIT Lisp Machines were developed with CHAOS, an Ethernet-based protocol. TCP/IP was available early. Many of the TCP/IP protocols were implemented for them (often client and server): chat, terminal, mail, RPC, NFS, X11, DNS, HTTP, remote printing, remote booting, ... They also ran DECNET and some IBM network protocol. Actually the networking code from Symbolics was quite sophisticated in some respects...

BBN (the Internet company at that time) also used a lot of Lisp Machines. They had some distributed remote object networking substrate, which also ran on Lisp Machines.

Lucent had developed an ATM network switch, which first versions were based on multiple embedded Lisp Machine boards for the switching code and another Lisp Machine for the control and administration. They ran all kind of fancy networking code on them in a zero downtime fashion with live software upgrades. They were for example thought as large network and telephony switches.

Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by gumby on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:44PM (#7880326)
One small correction: the D machines weren't all smaller; there was the Dandelion (later sold as the Star), the Dolphin and the Dorado (which was a full rack, the size of a 32-bit CADR machine, and built of ECL logic). There were at least three different standard microcoded environments you could boot with, Interlisp-D, Smalltalk and Mesa. When I was at PARC if I worked late I could connect to a Dorado, but most of the time I used a Dolphin (plus my group had some Dandelions which ran some custom microcode). They could also run Alto microcode by the way.

I preferred the MIT lispm environment better because I grew up with it. For a while I had a job where I had both a dandelion and a 3600 in my office; later I had two 36xx machines, one with a color display.

They were pretty fast for their time. The late, hyper-dynamic window system was probably too heavyweight for its time, especially when later translated over X, but I generally used the simpler base window system because it was faster.

It was the most productive (in terms of amount of useful code generated per unit time) system I have ever used and I still miss it. The Interlisp D, though quite different to use (and in some ways better), is a close second.

Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by lispm on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:54PM (#7880387)
Right, but the large one weren't sold, IIRC. Xerox sold the smaller ones, not the Dorado. That was also why some users upgraded to the Lisp Machines from LMI, Symbolics and TI: they had larger address spaces and could run larger software.
Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by ScottBurson on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @03:36PM (#7879988)
> Lisp systems were popular for research, but were not used extensively for networking research. I expect it was in part a compatibility issue with BSD's socket stuff

They were not used for networking research, AFAIK, but Lisp Machines were definitely very well networked, speaking many protocols which soon came to include IP and TCP (though they started out with MIT's CHAOSnet). I was using Lisp Machines (both Symbolics and TI) networked with Sun 3s in the mid-to-late 1980s, and they definitely interoperated.

But I think that was a few years later than the networking research you're referring to, that created the Internet protocols.

Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by ChuckMcM on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:03PM (#7880693)
That is correct, they were ubiquitous in various research organizations but fairly rare with people who were doing research on network protocols.
Re:Ergonomics of the Symbolics Lisp Machine by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @08:38PM (#7881230)
The folks doing systems research weren't about to settle for something like Haskell, precisely because it's way too hard to do systems work in it. C is the way it is for a reason.