News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by zachlipton on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @12:43PM (#7878935)
Elevators. I mean obviously there are significant structural concerns as well, but elevators are a big part of what makes building super-tall buildings uneconomic and impractical. The Elevator Conundrum, as Wikipedia dubs it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyscraper_design_and_construc...), means that as you build a taller building, you need more elevators to service the floors. More elevators take up more space, meaning less rentable space for occupants. While skylobbies, double-deck elevators, and other tricks can help, they don't eliminate the problem, especially since no one is willing to transfer elevators four times to get up/down. We also run into the issue of how to build a 10,000 foot elevator, which is so far outside the competence of manufacturers that it would represent a huge risk to the completion of the entire building project.

I am, of course, assuming you plan to build a useful tall building instead of an empty 10,000 foot tall shell for no particular reason.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by Pyrodogg on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:27PM (#7880234)
The elevator problem is partially solved by never leaving your section of the mega tower!

Work on level 120 Sleep on 73 Recreation on 145 Skyway connections to neighboring mega towers every 50-75 levels.

Actually travelling to the surface world would be akin to driving for hours across the state. It's a trip and would be planned for accordingly, and happen rarely.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by 27182818284 on Thursday June 12, 2014 @12:43AM (#7881844)
>Actually travelling to the surface world would be akin to driving for hours across the state. It's a trip and would be planned for accordingly, and happen rarely.

I must be missing something. 10,000ft is 1.8ish miles. That's like an 8 minute bike ride not a cross-state drive. Even if it took 30 minutes by elevator, that's a reasonable commute in cities like Chicago.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by Pyrodogg on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:51PM (#7886905)
Yea, I went funny with the scale. Jumped straight from skycraper to something the size of a GSV from the Culture series.
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by jvvlimme on Friday June 13, 2014 @09:42AM (#7888758)
The main problem with elevators today is that you can only have on cage per shaft. You could solve this if you could have multiple cages per shaft. A bit like how trains operate with switches and passing points. I imagine that would take some serious technical development but doesn't seem entirely out of this world. It would be easier if you have cableless lifts like the maglev lift Toshiba developed (http://www.toshiba-elevator.co.jp/elv/infoeng/technology/tec...).
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by JoeAltmaier on Friday June 13, 2014 @09:45AM (#7888784)
Maybe you don't have to pass - just like beads on an abacus string they could oscillate up and down with some overlap. Sometimes your cage might have to pause to let another leave the zone but mostly it could work.
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by brudgers on Thursday June 12, 2014 @09:19AM (#7883160)
Ok, let's give your skyscraper a nice 80' x 200' floor plate. A 100 stories up, and you've probably spent a billion dollars on construction and land and entitlement...at least in the US. Less some other parts of the world, more in others.

You're only half way to matching the tallest building, have just put an additional million and a half feet of expensive space into the local real-estate market, and your costs are only going up.

But that doesn't really paint the right picture about how expensive it is to build upward beyond a half dozen stories or so rather than building outward or just cramming more into less space.

No to put the cost of building upward in perspective: the great pyramid was the tallest building for nearly 4000 years. Lincoln Cathedral was then the tallest ever built for more than 500 [250 years if you want to say it lost the title when the spire collapsed, which brings up the point that the great pyramid would have been, but for erosion the tallest structure from 1647 to 1874, but was still the second tallest in the age of steam and iron].

So yeah, it's expensive and hard and unless you're the Pharaoh doesn't serve much purpose.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by mikeevans on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @02:14PM (#7879498)
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by gus_massa on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @01:12PM (#7879132)
Some of the thecnical problems are discussed in "Billion-Story Building" https://what-if.xkcd.com/94/

Another problem is the cost. Who is going to pay it? Do you want to pay it???

Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by VLM on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @11:47AM (#7878606)
Assuming you want a serious answer, a very HN one is to discuss scalability, and unlike rope or cables or fiber, towers most certainly do NOT scale merely linearly with length. Its way, way worse. Or if you prefer to think of it this way, we don't have enough income inequality and/or world wide wealth for one plot of land to "deserve" a 10 kilofoot tower.

Another fun term to google for is Euler and column buckling. That's why we don't have 75000 foot tall radio towers, which at least superficially would seem to be a great idea that could get past the scaling costs because potential revenue would scale even better with surface area within line of sight. Or even more interesting a 75 kilofoot rocket launching tower so you could use higher Isp vacuum rated nozzles at launch (if you tried that at ground level they'd buckle from the outside in)

Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by gdewilde on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:23PM (#7886828)
I suggest a giant snow man
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by dekhn on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @11:33AM (#7878524)
ask yourself, why do you need a taller building, and if so, are you sure you want to spend the money to engineer it?
Re:Ask HN: Why is the tallest manmade structure only 2,722 f... by joeclark77 on Thursday June 12, 2014 @08:10PM (#7886771)
They say that the tall skyscrapers sway a lot with the wind. It's perfectly safe, but it freaks people out. I've never been to the top of one to see for myself.