Re:Did the Supreme Court Recognize an Innocent Person's Righ...
by khafra on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @12:03PM
(#787409)
Eliezer Yudkowsky's dissolving of the consequentialist/deontologist divide can be applied here, I think: Nothing is more precious than a human life. But people die, so we have to make compromises to minimize the rate of unnecessary death; there's no use spending all your time and resources to build a completely death-proof car if you then die of untreated appendicitis you were too busy to have fixed.
In addition to that opportunity cost concern, there's knock-on effects, like you touched on, mustpax. Letting a killer live saves one human life now, but a policy of letting killers live may end far more human lives in the future. Personally, I don't think the data supports that, but if it did that's a choice we'd have to make.
Re:Did the Supreme Court Recognize an Innocent Person's Righ...
by edw519 on Wednesday August 26, 2009 @11:56AM
(#787389)
Undermining them for the sake of accommodating a single outlier would result in much more harm overall.
The magnitude of "overall harm" is not an issue.
I simply adopted the axiom of "nothing is more important than a single human life" and came up with one approach to make sure that axiom is never violated. There may be better approaches.
Agreement on this axiom is a necessary first step. I'm not sure we have it. What a shame.
I don't necessarily agree with this line of argument. But people will keep making it, so it's worth formulating a response to it if you want to win the debate. (Not that rational discourse wins any debates these days.)