Thank Nick! I did keep him company though.
I hope you guys did not lose too much sweat. Messing with a live site like this always makes me lose weight.
I'd argue that HN already has this kind of functionality with the noprocrast setting [1].
[1] Last question at http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
It took years (weeks) to fix. I disabled noprocrast in the mean time. (I guess I should turn it back on now)
If you use this feature and you noticed the bug, thank @kogir I guess!
If it keeps their servers up and the downtime low, and it gives them time to develop new things (such as a proper mobile version, or a non-table-based design), or time to fix the "Unknown or expired link" bug... then why not? Is there any reason to run this site like it's 1999?
1. HackerNews would have more resources to do maintenance and development on the site. Both of which are relatively necessary: There's a lot of low-hanging fruit.
2. It would create an incentive to improve the service and prevent downtime. Would they really put the site down for multiple hours during (European) office hours if they had quite a few paying customers?
Primarily, though, I think it boils down to the fact that Hacker News was originally run as a service towards the YC alumni, and that it serves that purpose very well as it is - and as a result, product development has stalled. The original author (PG, the product owner) is busy doing other things, and has employed other people to run the show.
Truth is, Hacker News has outgrown its original audience (YC alumni) and would be ready for some changes or improvements. Nothing major, because it's great as it is, but it could use some bug fixing, or maybe getting the HTML and CSS up to date, or a mobile version, finally fixing that stupid 'up' arrow... I could go on. I care about Hacker News, and I want it to improve and to be available permanently, and most certainly not be offline when I wake up and am ready for my 21st century equivalent of the morning newspaper. That's why I wrote that angry message, and that's why I'm offering to pay to help achieve that.
Think about it this way: you need your fix so badly that within minutes you're back here to vent your frustration.
And yet you have nowhere else to go. So HN can afford the downtime easily, and with what I know of the way it is put together the reliability is astounding.
Now imagine it shuttin HN down for a month! (I sensed a disturbance in the force there when you read that.) Within an hour of switching it back on the traffic would be right back where it was before.
Hm, maybe there is an idea in there somewhere. A website for hackers with 'opening hours' that simply refuses connections from your locality when you're supposed to be at work.
It would probably be sponsored by some VPN supplier ;)