News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by declan on Monday June 09, 2014 @07:36PM (#7871130)
Folks here should check out http://patrick.net/, run by a SF bay area programmer, for an opposing view on the necessity and desirability of Realtors(tm).

In terms of the MLS, at least in California, which has the largest one, it's run by Realtors(tm) for Realtors(tm). The board members are Realtors(tm); so are the "34 REALTOR® Associations" that are the MLS's customers. You can see crmls.org for more details.

In terms of attorneys, at least you can pay them by the hour. In the SF bay area, where house prices can be 10x-15x the national average, why should a Realtor(tm) be paid 10x-15x as much for doing approximately the same amount of work? Haircuts, which require approximately as much skill on the part of the service provider, don't cost 15x as much here. Also the more you spend, the more the Realtor(tm) gets paid; this precisely misaligns incentives.

Attorneys also have a far higher degree of legal obligation to you than a Realtor(tm) does. Check out the standard real estate contract, which is designed primarily to eliminate any legal responsibility on the part of the Realtor(tm), and only secondarily to conduct the actual house transaction.

Also it's rather silly to compare the amount of knowledge required to represent someone in court vs. show a house. To be a real estate agent in California, you have to spend 18 days taking three simultaneous correspondence courses. One of which can be "Computer Applications in Real Estate," which will teach you such difficult-to-master skills as "setting up e-mails," "using digital cameras," and "designing a power point presentation." Tests are T/F and multiple choice. I am not making this up: http://www.accreditedcareers.com/ca_info.pdf

Here's part of Assignment #1 (representing almost 10% of your final grade!): 1. Search Online for 5 Internet Service Providers and make a list with the URL next to the ISP name and list the price of each. 2. Search Online and find 5 different Online Vendors of computer hardware and make a list with the URL next to the Vendors name. 3. Search Online and find 5 Computer Software Vendors and make a list with the URL next to the Vendors name. 4. Using your URL go to http://www.dre.ca.gov find the latest Real Estate bulletin and just send the URL address to the bulletin on the list. 5. Download Yahoo Messenger and Install program. Using Yahoo Messenger Application set up a username and messenger account and send a request to [email protected] to join your buddies. (this will also allow chat to the instructor)

It's true that Realtors(tm) can provide some value, for instance when they have deep knowledge of the local area. But whenever I've spoken at Realtor(tm) conferences -- a few times at Inman Connect in SF -- I've outraged the audience by telling them they'll be disintermediated as surely as their travel agent brethren, and describing how it will happen. My only regret is that it's taking so long.

If anyone is working on a startup to dislodge the Realtor(tm) effective monopoly[1], let me know.

[1] The DOJ sued the National Association of Realtors(tm) in 2005 for antitrust violations during the antitrust-averse Bush administration. Unfortunately the case was settled in 2008: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/28/business/28realty.html?_r=...

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by burntsushi on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:17PM (#7871425)
I really liked your comment. It's insightful and provided a perspective I hadn't really heard before. This is important, because I'm gearing up to buy my first house in about 2 years or so. The thought of working with a realtor has been somewhat terrifying, if only because I believe competence is rare generally. And the incentive inverse has always been a bit of a put off too.

I've certainly considered the possibility of going without a realtor when the time comes, but multiple people whose opinion I respect have claimed that a realtor was worth it. So your comment piqued my interest. In search of more information, I decided to check out patrick.net.

Umm. What? Here's what I see:

* Money is a form of social control and most Americans are debt slaves

* Midieval spikes thwart London homeless from sleeping in apartment doorways

* Michael Moore in cat fight with wife over divorce settlement

* Photo of US at Night

* "Go and rape women" Why do we just stand by?

* God bless the free market!

* ...

I mean, really? I understand that this is probably some dynamically generated list of hot threads from a message board, but if your goal is to convince someone that maybe realtors aren't necessary (a pretty mind-bending claim for most people, I imagine), then you have provided a source that inspires exactly zero credibility. I'd suggest you stop linking people to it.

I had expected to see some material on how one would achieve tasks that a realtor would normally perform for you. I can at least understand how this open data stuff would help replace the realtor's job of finding houses for you, but what about all the legal mumbo jumbo? I know almost nothing about it, but I know it exists. So how would I tackle it? Is there anything else that a realtor generally does that I'll have to do myself?

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by declan on Monday June 09, 2014 @11:16PM (#7871679)
These are fair points. I've met Patrick in person and used to follow patrick.net a while ago (>4 years ago), but the discussion threads appear to have gone downhill a bit. But as someone else pointed out, there are some FAQs there that provide a useful counter to the conventional wisdom. Also it looks like Patrick now has a book out you can buy on Amazon.com: http://www.amazon.com/Housing-Trap-Buyers-Captured-Yourself/...

Put another way, even if there's an 0.9 probability that the advice there is wrong, buying a house is nevertheless the most significant purchase of your life for most people. It's also a very illiquid purchase, meaning it's difficult to sell and you need it to appreciate ~7% just to make back what you paid (that's because of Realtor(tm) commissions). You owe it to yourself to seek out a different opinion even if there's only a 0.1 probability it's accurate.

Edit with an addendum: My goal is not necessarily to get people to avoid Realtors(tm). This is not yet possible given the state of the market; I made some effort in that direction and was unsuccessful when I bought a single-family home on the SF peninsula. Instead, it's to get folks to realize that especially in coastal markets, they are likely not worth it, have minimal mandated training, and do not necessarily have your best interests in mind. In the long run, what I'd like to do is encourage HN readers to come up with ways to make real estate transactions more efficient. Some Realtors(tm) with deep knowledge will probably stay in the industry; most others will end up doing something more productive with their lives.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by burntsushi on Monday June 09, 2014 @11:28PM (#7871708)
You make a good point. The site is off putting, but it's worth it to spend a little time investigating. I'll check out the link that huherto gave me and maybe take a look at the book.

> It's also a very illiquid purchase, meaning it's difficult to sell and you need it to appreciate ~7% just to make back what you paid (that's because of Realtor(tm) commissions).

Indeed. Realtor commissions are a huge drag. I do somewhat skip over the part about the importance of a house appreciating in value because I'm not purchasing a house as an investment in which the primary goal is to make money. It's a purchase of a good whose main value to me is its utility as a domicile. A secondary goal is for it to benefit me financially. I acknowledge that this may be an uneducated opinion, but I definitely know what a house means to me, and its financial value isn't terribly high on that list. Perhaps that will change as I learn more over the coming years. (I'm considering building a house too. I get the feeling it would be financially better to start smaller, and then incrementally add to the house as we accrue the necessary capital to do it. I very much intend for my first house to be my primary residence for at least a couple decades.)

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by declan on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @12:16AM (#7871806)
>I'm considering building a house too. I get the feeling it would be financially better to start smaller, and then incrementally add to the house as we accrue the necessary capital to do it.

I don't know anything about your personal financial situation, so this advice may be completely off-base. But perhaps buy a house that's unrenovated but structurally sound and then hire a contractor to renovate it to your specifications? At least if my experience a few years ago was any indication, you'll learn a tremendous amount about permits, appliances, electrical upgrades, fixtures, moulding, doors and windows, insulation, decks, landscaping, and how to manage a complex undertaking that's likely (depending on the size of the house and the geographic area) to run into the six figures and last at least half a year.

Then, a few years later, you can hire an architect and do everything right the second time around. :)

Also if you live in the SF bay area (and I know your profile says you're in Massachusetts), be warned that all the good land is already built on or unavailable for building or vacant and extremely expensive -- as in millions of dollars for just a lot in Portola Valley, Los Altos Hills, or Woodside. There was a discounted property for sale two blocks down from me a few years ago for only $800,000 (!). But there was an active landslide on the property and the town expressed some doubt about whether the owner actually had the legal authority under the deed to subdivide in the first place...

So if you have a liquidity event, you can buy that 800 ft^2 shack in a great location in Palo Alto for $2M, tear it down, and spend another two years and $2M building a nice modern 3,500 ft^2 house (1,000 of that may have to be underground because, well, it's Palo Alto). Otherwise, well, New Hampshire is a nice place to live! :)

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by ars on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @02:31AM (#7872077)
> I get the feeling it would be financially better to start smaller, and then incrementally add to the house as we accrue the necessary capital to do it.

From my experience with other people who have thought like this, this is a mistake. One person wanted a 2 story addition, but couldn't afford it - so they put in a 1 story addition, but built the foundation so it could handle 2.

Needless to say they never added that second level even though they had funds - once you've paid for the roof, and the equipment and everything else (i.e. startup costs) adding that second level would have been just a small addition, but doing it now means starting over and the expense is no longer worth it.

Others have done that, but found the interface where the two connect to shift, which is unpleasant. Or the styles don't match.

Instead, build all the rooms you want, with exterior walls and roof, but don't finish the inside - no wires, no drywall, no doors, nothing except insulation, not even windows (when it's time for windows you just cut the exterior and add blocking on the inside). Close that section off from the rest of the house, and then when you have funds, and need, build it out.

The interior costs a significant amount, but the startup costs are much smaller than for exterior.

Note a possible problem: The inspector may object, I don't know.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by DougWebb on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @12:43AM (#7871878)
If you're purchasing a house that you intend to stay in for a long time, reducing the cost of your mortgage as much as possible will save you far more money than the Realtor commissions will cost. The interest on a mortgage can easily double the cost of a home, and for the first ~third of the lifetime of the mortgage your monthly payments will be more interest than principal.

You reduce the cost of a mortgage by making a larger down payment, especially if you pay more than 20% in cash. You also want to avoid 'points' (which are just more interest) and to get the lowest interest rate you can. (A very good credit score helps a lot.) If you go for a variable-rate mortgage, read the fine-print very carefully; you want to make sure that the rate can't go up more than a reasonably small amount or more often than a reasonably long period.

You should also consider a lot of the non-purchase costs involved in home ownership. I wish the commissions had been the most significant expense I faced. Remodeling, repairs, improvements, decorating, re-decorating, and general maintenance added up to a large multiple of the commission I paid over ten years. And living in NJ, my property taxes have rising to nearly as much as my mortgage payments after a decade! I had never planned for any of that when considering what I could afford to buy.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by dnr on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @12:19AM (#7871809)
I bought a TIC in SF using Redfin as my agent. They rebate around half of their commission back to you (with a minimum for the amount they keep). It's not quite disrupting the industry, but maybe it's a start.

Part of the way they keep their costs down is letting you do all the searching and scheduling of visits on their web site, so all the agent has to do is manage the process once you're ready to make an offer. Not that that's so easy: I had a few complications with mine, and I've heard much worse stories.

My agent had just moved from the east coast, and I've lived in SF for several years, so I was more familiar with local market conditions than he was and I didn't get any value from that. But it was my first real estate purchase and I didn't know much about how the general process worked, so that was very useful to me.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by huherto on Monday June 09, 2014 @10:50PM (#7871645)
I also got lost on the site.

But this article is really good. http://patrick.net/housing/crash1.html

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by redfalcon6 on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @11:17AM (#7872982)
I recently sold my house on my own. We live in a hot metro area. I initially listed it just on Zillow and did an aggressive social media campaign. Within a week I had several offers.

My mistake initially was to try to attack both sides of the realtor(tm) mix: seller and buyer brokers. I was clearly taking the seller side out. But I was willing to work with buyers' brokers if they found me. But I wanted to twist the commission scheme, as a flat rate doesn't make much sense. (e.g., an incremental $100K is huge for me but very little for them.) So I tried to create a stairstep where if they came in below ask, the broker would get paid .5%, and if they were 100K above ask they would get 3.5%. Needless to say, this failed. I had many brokers tell me they would refuse to bring clients to see my place, DESPITE their fiduciary duty to do so.

In the end, I offered 2.5% commission to buyers brokers (the standard in my area). I also listed it on the MLS using a shady site where you can pay to $150 bucks to a broker to list it on the MLS. Finally, I scraped the websites of 3 major brokerages in my area and did a mailing list to 100 brokers with the subject line of ADDDRESS X, 2.5% Buyer Commission. (100 brokers in 4 square miles. Should tell you something.) Had a 60% open rate and a 50% clickthrough rate. Lots of appointments right away.

I endeded up getting 9 offers and having a 2 step auction. I of course netted out what I would have to pay to brokers, so folks without brokers had an automatic 2.5% advantage. I ended up selling without a broker on either side. 3 weeks from first listing on Zillow to contract signed.

So yes - it's definitely possible to work without brokers if you're willing to do a little work, you're confident in your pricing skills, and you're in a hot area. As I said to my wife, each individual showing we did saved us about $2K!

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by mrfusion on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @09:34AM (#7872342)
If the real estate test/license is so easy, I've always wondered if savy buyers could "become real estate agents" and then show themselves properties?

As far as I'm concerned the only value agents provide is unlocking doors at houses you want to view. (Source: I've bought 3 houses with three different agents.)

Feel free to email me if you want to chat, I'm sure there are some great start up ideas in the space.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by DougWebb on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @10:06AM (#7872507)
Getting a license is just the first step; you have to associate yourself with a brokerage to do the things agents do, and there's a cost to that.

If your agents haven't done anything for you but unlock doors, then you haven't had good agents. Like any other profession, there's a huge range in quality and competence, and finding a good agent requires some research and probably recommendations from past clients.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by mrfusion on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @10:14AM (#7872567)
No, they were highly recommended, and generally knew a lot about the areas.

But for a buyer wanting to do his own research, and having lived in the area for a long time, they simply couldn't add any value besides unlocking doors, and filling out a stock form to make offers.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by DougWebb on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @10:56AM (#7872853)
Didn't they do anything for you after the offers were made? Did you not hear from them again until the closing a few months later?

For what it's worth, I agree 100% with you when it comes to rental agents. They do almost nothing besides provide a listing in MLS. But buyer and seller agents should be doing a lot more.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by declan on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @12:08PM (#7873375)
Like <mrfusion>, I did my own research, had my own spreadsheet of comps for the area, wrote my own personal offer letter to the seller, hired my own inspectors, and so on. The buyer's agent incorrectly said I didn't need to check the box saying as a condition of sale that the house have a working plumbing and sewage system; I did anyway and wrote it in, which saved me approximately $23,000 (the seller fixed it). Because I knew the market, we only looked at one house with this agent so his work was minimal.

About the only thing the buyer's agent did that was useful was cart away some household debris away in his truck after closing. It had been left behind in the garage. It probably would have cost me $40 to have someone do the same.

Re:Finding the perfect house using open data by mrfusion on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @11:37AM (#7873138)
I found my own home inspector. They unlocked the door for him too :-)

They came to the closing and told jokes :-)

What else should they have done after the offer was accepted?