News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Story Of Mel by jacquesm on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:31PM (#7870316)
I don't think I can enumerate the number of ways in which I disagree with you.

- It's only obfuscation if you have the luxury of solving it in another way.

- the times have changed (1956), but the methods have not

- sure, it may be obscure but it shows perfect control of the machine and the issue at hand

- agreed, it is not maintainable, but back then feature changes usually meant re-writes and people thought longer about what they wanted before they started building. Machine time was more expensive than programmer time.

- being clever is (to me at least) exactly what hacking is all about, finding a solution to a problem where you thought none existed. Ask yourself this: if Mel's code was so useless how come some hotshot didn't re-write it using 'best practices' and zero 'clever tricks'? The answer: likely because it could not be done. Mel delivered.

- the rebel in me likes Mels attitude towards management. Sure, if you're in management you'd hate him twice weekly but I note that Mel did not get fired, instead moved on to greener pastures

- I compare this with the way a jeweler would make his little works of art versus the way a production welder connects pieces of pipe. Mel is the jeweler, you'd rather we all just join pieces of pipe.

- I've gone through some of the assembly code for 80's video games and that stuff was full of tricks like this (and without it would never have gotten of the ground). Making a computer output the right results within the margin of error visible to the user when lacking the 'proper' resources is where creativity comes in. And in that case I'd much rather have a guy like Mel by my side than any number of {insert high level language of choice here} pushers because if it is at all possible guys like Mel will find a way.

Anyway, as you can see, we're likely not going to agree on this one.

Re:The Story Of Mel by JoeAltmaier on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:42PM (#7870379)
My professor said it this way: Engineering begins when the problem constraints admit of no solution.
Re:The Story Of Mel by atmosx on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @02:05AM (#7872029)
Really nice quote, what is the name of your professor? :-)
Re:The Story Of Mel by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday June 10, 2014 @10:14AM (#7872570)
Harry Kane