News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by crahrah on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:29AM (#7867033)
Seems the fact that the company was Chinese is pretty irrelevant - and yet it's repeated over an over.

China is the new bogeyman.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by vwinsyee on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:24AM (#7867176)
In many cases, I'd agree with you. But in context of what happened here, the fact that the company was Chinese (or simply just foreign, for that matter) is absolutely relevant. A few outstanding points:

1. The company was "unaccustomed to the rigor of American construction rules" and "lacked basic quality control", leading Caltran to "relax U.S. standards when the firm couldn’t finish fast enough."

2. "ZPMC violated the job contract by delivering key documents in Chinese instead of English. ABF lacked sufficient quality-assurance staff to speak directly to its own subcontractor – also a contract violation."

3. "Counting the money spent on travel and living costs for Caltrans and its contractors, the suspension span consumed much more than the $250 million in ZPMC’s assumed efficiencies that made the Chinese steel so cost-effective." On living costs alone, Caltran "paid about $50,000 annually per person to rent more than a dozen well-appointed rooms."

Asked for justification, "Caltrans described the accommodations as "reasonable and appropriate" in a written statement. 'The hotel provided a government rate that was comparable to rates at other western hotels,' and followed bargaining agreements, based in part on providing adequate 'safety and support for employees far from home.'"

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by FatalLogic on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:34AM (#7867197)
Parts of the story will feel terribly familiar to anyone who has had much manufacturing done in China. Sometimes, things go smoothly, but in the worst cases, like this one, there's a huge mismatch between 'Western' quality demands and the output of their Chinese partners.

The typical pattern will be for the manufacturer to start sending back work which is totally unacceptable. When their partner protests, the manufacturer will grudgingly raise the standard to 'barely tolerable'. Time runs out, exhaustion sets in, decision makers don't want to draw attention to the fact that they chose the wrong manufacturer - so the client has to lower their standards.

Caltrans officials were amazingly naive and blinkered if they weren't aware of the long history of stories just like this one. Perhaps they did know the history, and they thought they would be protected by quality checks embedded in the contract, but that's just more naivety. Contracts don't have much power in that environment, particularly when your project is already falling way behind schedule.

Blaming 'The Chinese' though, is stupid. Caltrans was in charge of this deal. If they chose the wrong partner and didn't stay in control of things, they are responsible.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by literalusername on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:57AM (#7867096)
Not at all. You apparently didn't read the article.

"Caltrans employees and U.S. contractors who supervised the job lived fulltime in Shanghai, and top officials flew there often. Tony Anziano, toll bridge program manager, alone spent more than $300,000 on travel.

"Part of that cost was for Anziano’s room at the five-star JW Marriott Shanghai Tomorrow Square for up to $470 per night, according to his expense reports."

The travel costs are an obscene waste of American tax dollars. Moreover, the fact that so many tax dollars were paid to a foreign company is offensive. Even if that company was at all competent, it shows a disregard for the American economy. For a project that puts American lives at risk, a demonstrated concern for the wellbeing of Americans is rather important.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by Mvandenbergh on Monday June 09, 2014 @09:01AM (#7868218)
>Moreover, the fact that so many tax dollars were paid to a foreign company is offensive. Even if that company was at all competent, it shows a disregard for the American economy.

The reason that the US doesn't restrict foreign engineering companies from getting government contracts is that it wants US companies to be able to bid on government projects in other countries.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by swampthing on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:01AM (#7867108)
I don't actually find the hotel price to be necessarily offensive in the absence of any other information... in foreign countries, you often have to pay a premium to get American-standard lodging (if it's even available).
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by slashedzero on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:14AM (#7867154)
The idea of requiring (and then paying for) "American-standard" lodging seems ridiculous when we outsource it for developing country prices.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by swampthing on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:27AM (#7867188)
I don't think people outsource to developing countries because they think they'll get cheaper hotels there... it's more about the cost of the services / goods being delivered.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by mikeash on Monday June 09, 2014 @10:16AM (#7868543)
Shanghai is more or less a first-world city these days. American-style hotels will not be hard to find. Your "if it's even available" parenthetical may be true in general but is rather absurd in this particular context.
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by austinz on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:13AM (#7867152)
Do you think the citizens of countries such as Japan, Canada, and Turkey should be offended that their governments are paying hundreds of millions of dollars to 'foreign' companies in the U.S. for (e.g.) the F-35 fighter?
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by adventured on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:23AM (#7867175)
Lots of companies from around the world can build bridges at a very competent level while remaining near budget.

Quick, name the current generation alternatives to the F35 and the country behind said alternative.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by austinz on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:32AM (#7867193)
Responding to this from the parent comment (highlight is mine):

> Moreover, the fact that so many tax dollars were paid to a foreign company is offensive. Even if that company was at all competent, it shows a disregard for the American economy.

Competence is explicitly not the OP's point.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by dba7dba on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:10AM (#7867446)
Let's stay on topic, shall we?
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by Noted on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:21PM (#7870275)
Check the comment he responded to, it was definitely on topic
Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by tolmasky on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:05AM (#7867122)
> Caltrans diaries also indicated that ZPMC violated the job contract by delivering key documents in Chinese instead of English. ABF lacked sufficient quality-assurance staff to speak directly to its own subcontractor – also a contract violation. “Although I can jump in when misunderstanding between ABF and ZPMC developed,” Caltrans engineer Stanley Ku wrote in a report, “I do think ABF should have a (quality expert) who can speak Mandarin to reduce the ‘misunderstanding’ situation.”

Seems pretty important.

Re:Troubled welds on the Bay Bridge by Natsu on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:30AM (#7867190)
I'm not concerned because the firm was Chinese. I'm concerned because they tried to override the engineers and hired a company with zero experience who massively underbid the project. That screams "bad management" to me, personally.