It sounds odd, but General Motors is a large and complex entity. Their release system is old and buggy, not to mention never completely overhauled, just constantly having more checks ticked on when ever a recall happens. This is actually true at Ford too, the Big 3 hold on to technology a lot longer then other companies. Ford's time clock system is still ran on emulated System360's using MTS a circa 1967 OS.
Lastly DRE's are more of a projects internal sales arm (they sell the product to management. A DRE's job is to also get the test results from the test engineer, get it to the management, take the managements complaints to the designers/hardware engineers, and relay the tests plans back to the test engineers.
Basically high technical middle management. Their responsibilities at some companies may involve actually writing test plans, sometimes not. I don't believe GM does directly but somebody under the DRE does this.
Ultimately the DRE is just the guy who gets all the forms to all the right people so he can push the plans into the system. And takes all the responsibility when a product fails. On top of that your normally managing 5-6 products concurrently, each taking 18-72 months to clear the system. Your work load is basically endless meetings 500+ email a day, and 100+ phone calls.
1. I use the term 'Chinese' in this phrase to represent any state actor who can rapidly deploy, or incentivise, manufacturing capability at a significant discount to their Western counterparts.
>Enter the likes of Telsa Motors
I don't think we can call Telsa Motors a success yet strictly speaking. When its own CEO states its stock is overvalued we need to reconsider out position on the company. Telsa has only had 1 profitable quarter so far in its entire history.
>I have a hunch there will be others, probably 'cheap Chinese knock-offs
I'm not even gonna talk about problems with Chinese steel, Chinese quality control, Testing, etc. Lets just focus on sourcing. Developing a car's transmission costs roughly 5-10 billion dollars. Its so expensive to do that really no automakers do it themselves, same with engine designs. They share these collectively.
To disrupt the industry you need cash, and a lot of it. Metal dyes are outrageous, 250k to 500k+. The initial investments a company needs to break into the industry is stupid high.
On top of that, as an in-experienced new comer it'll be challenging to gain the public perception of having a higher quality product, as your first attempt may not be.
Products in the Auto-industry typically have decade long life spans, with half a decade spent testing them before release. So your trying get 1 billion in angel funding, for a decade you won't even be profitable?
Fuck! MTS? The Michigan Terminal System? I haven't heard that being mentioned since I was, literally, a kid. Even IBM considers that obsolete, and IIRC even development stopped about 15 years ago!
A lot of the Detroit Metro UUG (Unix Users Group, the LUG is very small) people like to find some of the old tech in the basements of Ford and GM and use it for show and tell :)
But the subtext in the article makes it pretty clear. They are tracking cost of design as accurately as unit costs.
It is largely an "in for a dime in for a dollar" scenario for each internal engineer when they approve a design direction that appears to cut a cost. The larger oversight is unaware of some of the hidden issues and each engineer is motivated to paper over them to some extent to protect their relative standing. The engineers who are completely transparent are completely unemployed.
Its not a culture problem, its a management problem. One person cannot be allowed to essentially design, development, qa, and support. If they are who knows what essential steps are not fully performed if at all? checks and balances fall by the wayside when your both.
One note I remember from some buddies who used to be in similar careers, part costs are calculated not by individual unit prices but the production run. Hence a change you say, that is only a few cents can be hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Resulting in it being possible for the steering wheel to detach! whilst driving.
It's no different than an engineer selection of a single line of code, if it's in the wrong place, crashy crashy.
Here's a much better article: http://www.seattlepi.com/news/us/article/Engineer-s-switch-f...
Perhaps the engineer was distracted by an underground boxing ring.
I don't think that this can be compared directly to the kind of adhoc software development that is routine in many places. Engineering processes have developed over decades to eliminate human error and very, very rarely allow single unjustified decisions made by a single person to propegate through to a finished product.
I'm surprised that in a world where individual car platforms cost billions of dollars to develop there was never a point at which the switch selection was challenged. I haven't read the full report though - perhaps it's not quite as the news article suggests. It would be interesting to hear the point of view of someone in the automotive industry (if any of them are HN readers?)