Reminds me of the late 90's when my ISP told me I couldn't get cable Internet because I didn't have a 486. I lied and told them I did to have the modem sent to me to hook up myself. It's a computer network, once it's in my house I can expose it as I like.
Tech: "Could you please unplug your computer for 20 seconds and restart it?"
Me: "Okay. <does nothing for 60 seconds>. Okay, it's back"
Or this gem? Tech: "What browser are you using?"
Me: "<Looks at Ubuntu desktop> Internet Explorer 6". Tech: "Looks like we're about done. Now I just need to
use your computer to activate the connection."
Me: <looks at my Debian laptop> "I don't have a computer,
I only use my internet for tablets and my roku"
Tech: <looks at my laptop> "I need to use your computer to
activate your connection..."
Me: "I don't have a computer, and of course you do not."
Tech: "Okay, just a second, I have to make a call..."
[one minute later]
Tech: "Okay, your connection is activated, you should be
good to go."
Me: "Thanks!"
If there was really a hard and fast requirement that they use a computer to activate the connection, they would bring a computer with them. They just want to install their shitware on your computer.I feel comfortable lying to their techs about a computer that is in plain sight because they feel comfortable lying to my face that they must use my computer to complete the installation.
I now refuse to subscribe to any ISP who does not offer Linux support, and will in fact check to make sure that Teksavvy (or an equivalent as described above) is available in an area before moving to it.
Full Disclosure, I am a Teksavvy customer but not a Teksavvy employee.
However, over 90% of American homes have at most 2 ISP choices. At most! So we are in a small but happy minority.
I lay most of the blame here on the FCC and the FTC, who have totally failed to regulate in a way that maintains a healthy market.
But I also have some blame left over for all the people who signed up with major ISPs while the small ones went out of business. It has always cost me more money to go with a local ISP rather than whatever the megacorp's latest intro rate would be. Now everybody is shocked that Comcast, Verizon, et al are giving shitty service and being total dicks about it. But it turns out I can't go down to the corner and shout, "WELL DUH! WHAT DID YOU EXPECT?!? TO THEM YOU ARE THE VEAL!" because nobody likes hearing I told you so. That or they don't like crazy people shouting on the corner.
They probably mean the WiFi built into the cable modem.
My general sense is that these types of conversations happen daily at Comcast and such...I've heard too many similar stories over the years.
People just don't know that you can have wifi for free, especially when you've got adverts from O2 and such that 2gb 3G and " unlimited wifi".
I dunno if it's the same in the US but apparently it's some typically restricted resource that many providers in the UK are lifting the limits off.
No, this isn't too typical. Most people have their own router offering WiFi in front of the cable modem. It wasn't until recently that cable companies started bundling wi-fi and NAT into the modem.
I just felt a disturbance in the force. Damn, that sentence triggers a whole range of evil ideas I hadn't yet thought of.
Hmm, hold on while I check with my ISP whether I can downgrade my WiFi data limit for cheaper service... or would that just be giving them ideas? :p
No, but all of their features can be enabled/disabled by the ISP remotely.
Similarly to how you only get the ability to tether your data with more expensive plans. It's a completely artificial client-side restriction that can be circumvented by rooting, etc. Not unlike DRM.
I just played it dumb and said it was just me. We had about 10+ wireless devices connected.
A few years ago I was setting up a new internet provider for my mother, so I called to get the info to get email: Support: "You're using Outlook, right?" Me: "No, Thunderbird." Support: "We only support Outlook, so I can't help you." Me: "It's email, it won't matter if I use Thunderbird." Support: "Our email does not work with anything other than Outlook." Me: "Okay, I'll get rid of Thunderbird and use Outlook." I entered the information into Thunderbird as he gave it to me and then hung up the phone.
But, of course, it only run on Windows, and I was lying telling that I had Windows, as every ISP would refuse to serve somebody that uses Linux...
I had one of their built in modem/router combos that provides internet and wifi, me and a room mate had a minecraft server set up on a box wired into the router, and we played locally, but for some reason every 20 minutes, our connections to the server, the internet, and eachother would just die.
leaving an active traceroute on a spare computer suggested that the router just stopped routing for a period of 20-30 seconds, every 20-30 minutes.
Angry and annoyed, I called in a tech from Shaw to look at and replace the hardware. Standard operating procedure here: "We will show up some time between 8am-1pm". Of course he showed up at 3pm, with no call that he was going to be late. I had to call them.
Unbelievably, he logged into the router (with no permissions given, so those routers are backdoored... goody) and actually identified that the router WAS resetting every 20 minutes or so. Yes, the problem was identified! The problem was that my internet plan was not sufficient enough to support online games, and that if I didn't get another better one, the problem couldn't be fixed. (For the record, I had a 30 mbps down, 3 mbps up, cable connection.)
Jaw agape, I tried to explain to him that A. The game server he was referring to was literally right next to his feet, and B. that even if it wasn't, game data is minuscule compared to video data, something I am a prolific consumer of with no obvious problem there. All that combined with the subtle hint that the router literally just told him it was resetting, the conclusion clearly was that the router is broken, and my internet is fine.
His response to that was:
...
that's a direct quote. I'm not paraphrasing.He didn't want to say anything because I had the audacity to say something that went contrary to the marketing line, and the only option he had was to either say I was wrong, or accept it.
He wouldn't replace the router regardless.
So I told him to take his modem/router, put in my old modem, get it registered, and buzz off (though maybe not so colourfully).
When I talked to a Shaw customer representative about having a Tech show up late, lie to me, and not fix the problem without an upgrade, I got this response:
uh, ok?
That's a direct quote. I'm not paraphrasing.Fun part though: that transgression was actually considered a transgression by Shaw's regulatory agency, So I reported it to them after I got piddly squat from customer service.
Yet when another entity does something as simple as showing an error message that casts them in a negative light, they are willing and able to threaten legal action.
They stretch the truth as far as they can, yet give not an inch when confronted with truths they don't like.
Remove government so we can add customers! But we need government so we can slap Nextflix when they say something we don't like!
I don't have a good answer how to fix it, it's just very plain to see, and frustrating.