News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by atmosx on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:08AM (#7852300)
I get and send ~ 10 to 15 emails per week. Not even 1 of my regular 'correspondence' uses GnuPG. It's too complicated to setup and even harder to use for avg Joe, like bitcoin, he has to spent time understanding totally new concepts. And no one is willing to do that, unfortunately :-(
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by tptacek on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:38PM (#7853089)
I have walked non-technical people through the process of setting up GPGMail on Macs without much problem. I buy that GPGMail is hard to use reliably, and that its user interface is cryptic in ways that make it likely that users will slip up. I do not buy that GPG is particularly hard to get started with.

Unfortunately, all the glamour and the money and the code seems to track vanity crypto projects, and not so much of it goes to projects that make GPG more usable for normal people. Kudos to Google for taking a stab at correcting this.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by sp332 on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:19PM (#7852966)
It's true, Glenn Greenwald said that he almost gave up on Snowden's information because it was too hard to set up GPG correctly!
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by tptacek on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:37PM (#7853078)
He did give up on GPG, and instead used Cryptocat, at a time during which it appears to have been possible to decrypt Cryptocat conversations from network traces due to key generation bugs.
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by Create on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:18PM (#7854116)
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by hershel on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:05PM (#7854025)
Currently , the most practical way for secure communications looks like textSecure, which is a mobile IM app that is easy to use and install , and relatively easy to convince others to communicate in.
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by belorn on Thursday June 05, 2014 @05:28PM (#7854664)
A possible solution to this is private mail servers that encrypt and decrypt automatically for you.

The idea that you go to the store, pick up a small box, and it will do all the security for you is the stated goal of freedom box (https://freedomboxfoundation.org/). Once transparent end-to-end encryption that avg joe can use get traction, mail encryption will hopefully become default.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by vog on Friday June 06, 2014 @06:48AM (#7857099)
I configured my parents' email program (Thunderbird/Enigmail) to automatically encrypt emails they send to me. Also, I encrypt all emails to them.

They still don't really care, but at least my communication with them is encrypted.

Also, they see that using encryption is not hard (once set up), except that they have to type in a password from time to time.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by warcode on Friday June 06, 2014 @04:25AM (#7856776)
Keybase.io is doing good work in making public key encryption more easily available.

Except for the part where they want you to upload your private key to them. But that is optional.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by sssbc on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:21AM (#7852362)
ok, get info-raped by any and all then.
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by pyre on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:33AM (#7852424)
Consider this:

1. It's probably better to remain civil in your discourse if you want people to take you seriously, and not just dismiss you as a troll. If you really do feel so strongly about your position, then you're probably doing more harm than good to your cause by firing off such remarks.

2. I doubt that you personally communicate with everyone using encrypted email. If you do, your world is probably fairly insular (and you should probably consider expanding your experience to include communicating with people outside of your comfort-zone).

3. The most constructive response to the parent post would probably be a suggested plan of action. I'm sure that many here would be all-ears to even a decent framework for convincing the average person to use encrypted email.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by dllthomas on Thursday June 05, 2014 @12:36PM (#7852731)
It seems like teaching people to use GPG for the authentication is probably the first step. Sending to someone who doesn't use GPG then is still readable, and if you want to push the point with a particular person then every time they email you call them and say "I got an email, I wanted to be sure it was from you, since there was no signature..."

Once you can count on contacts using GPG, the path to encrypting is much easier.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by atmosx on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:25PM (#7853006)
IMHO the problem is the NOT infrastructure per se, it's the theoretical part that is cumbersome. If you now why you are doing something, it's easy to understand why you should not save the 'key' in the "Keychain" or sign random emails.

To use GnuPG correctly you need explain to average Joe concepts like:

    * PKI
    * Key signing
    * Web of trust
    * Revocation key
The problem is that, as Einstein said: Everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simple.

Same problem I can't talk bitcoin with most of my real-life friends. They are incredibly smart people, but they are not familiar with key concepts about BTC and don't wanna wrap their minds around it when we're hanging out having fun.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by borplk on Friday June 06, 2014 @02:04PM (#7859427)
I see what you're saying I think the same argument is being overly used to justify a lack of basic effort to learn anything about computing beyond 'click this shiny red button'.

People just cry out to the programmers to "just make it easier".

Well there's only so far you can go on the easy scale until you start sacrificing security and integrity.

People need to learn some of the fundamentals and basics you can't run away from it forever.

It's like someone saying "Mehh I don't like calculus ... why don't these mathematicians make it just easier? Why do I have to learn about differentiation? Make it so easy my grandma could differentiate this equation"

Instead we force every kid to take the pain a bit and learn some damn basics.

Same should go for computing. Schools could teach the kids the basics of protecting their communications on the internet. Give that 10 years and Public/Private key encryption is a piece of cake for every reasonably educated adult in the society and they are no longer buzzwords because everyone grew up with it and remembers their 8th grade when they learned all about it.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by Tomte on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @06:09AM (#7877171)
> It's like someone saying "Mehh I don't like calculus ... why don't these mathematicians make it just easier?

Actually, modern textbooks do exactly that: they try to find pedagogically better ways to teach this stuff.

And sometimes newer developments really simplify things.

All that apart from the simple fact that mathematics and the user interface and user interaction are not even in the same ballpark.

Your comment seems a bit lazy to me. Just not in a way you expected to.

Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by amirmc on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:31PM (#7853046)
I'd argue that getting address books to understand what keys are and how to use them would be more impactful. If I put public keys in my address book, which is nicely integrated with my mail client anyway, then sending encrypted mail should be far more straightforward. The problem then is getting people to use new address books.
Re:Email Self-Defense – a guide to fighting surveillance wit... by XorNot on Thursday June 05, 2014 @08:18PM (#7855486)
Making the Thunderbird address book not suck would be a good firsr step in this regard.