News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tor Challenge by chatmasta on Thursday June 05, 2014 @02:18AM (#7850481)
I'm working on research for monetizing Tor relays, providing an incentive to relay operators. It's called TorCoin. We introduce an alternative cryptocurrency, like Bitcoin, to reward relay operators for transferring bandwidth. Rather than being CPU intensive, it's bandwidth intensive -- so one TorCoin represents a certain amount of bandwidth transferred.

We will be presenting our research at the HotPETS privacy workshop in Amsterdam in July [1]. Here's a link to the paper if you're interested (I'm Miles). [2] Keep in mind it's an early draft.

[1] http://petsymposium.org/2014/hotpets.php

[2] https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7r4osQgWVqKTHdxTlowUVpsVmJR...

My email is in the paper, but it's [email protected]

Re:Tor Challenge by jlgaddis on Thursday June 05, 2014 @04:53AM (#7850935)
Quite interesting but I immediately wondered about something. I intend to fully read it later today but so far I have only skimmed over paper so I apologize if my question is answered there. I imagine others here will wonder the same thing, though.

With Bitcoin and others, we've seen malware created that turns compromised PCs and devices (routers, DVRs, etc.) into "zombie miners". If this becomes popular, I can certainly envision malware that instead turns these compromised devices into "zombie relays" in an attempt to benefit $hacker. Have you considered this (I'm sure you probably thought about it at some point) and/or do you have any ideas of ways to discourage (or punish) that behavior?

I am all about having more Tor relays out there but, well, legitimate ones.

Re:Tor Challenge by belorn on Thursday June 05, 2014 @08:52AM (#7851657)
Vulnerable computer that can be turned in cash is always going to get broken into. Once broken into, the device becomes a zombie miner, zombie spammer, zombie advertiser, zombie scammer, zombie overseer, or some unique form of zombieism.

How important is it to discourage a specific kind of zombie, rather than the infection itself?

Re:Tor Challenge by tribaal on Thursday June 05, 2014 @02:30AM (#7850508)
That is not a bad idea either... but:

This will be a challenge: the number of people willing and able to run TOR relays is quite small, and the subcategory of those interested in a (new) cryptocurrency is even smaller.

Reaching critical mass for the currency to be interesting is going to be hard.

Re:Tor Challenge by kylebrown on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:33AM (#7850677)
I think you are underestimating the size of the market. Seems like there's demand for every flavor of alt-coin: gimmickyCoin, mediocreCoin, memeCoin, yetAnotherCoin, every single one gets 15 minutes or more.

Try looking at it from the miners' perspective. The pitch isn't "buy our coin, and use this guide to help yourself install the dependencies needed to run our beta software." Instead, its "get paid coins, all you have to do is leave the relayCoin bandwidth-miner running while you sleep."

In the future, proof-of-bandwidth / proof-of-relay "coin" incentives on next-gen layer 3 protocols will bootstrap the transition to a global, p2p wireless mesh network (wireless at the edges and sparse areas, the big pipes and backhauls will still be fiber). It will look something like "leave this wifiMeshCoin nodeBox attached to your cable modem. It will open an unlocked wifi hotspot for anyone nearby. some people will get free access through a metered guest connection, and you might earn a little coin. But if you get lucky and your nodeBox can form a bridge connection to somebody else's nodeBox at a different ISP, that bridge relay will earn a lot of coin. Another option is to invest $2k to get a 4G/5G cellular micro-tower from NextGen Labs, one of those could earn you $500/mo in relayPower if there are enough unlocked CDMA phones in your area. You can resell the unlocked phones as well."

Re:Tor Challenge by tribaal on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:41AM (#7850703)
Ah, thanks for explaining this to me this way.

It's still going to be a challenge, but that makes a more manageable one :)

Re:Tor Challenge by jayshahtx on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:00AM (#7851689)
Interesting idea, but wasn't able to find much literature on this on the internet. Are all the proper nouns used in your post hypothetical? Apologize if I missed a clear hypothetical...
Re:Tor Challenge by kylebrown on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:48AM (#7852215)
Yes, its a hypothetical future. Yourkarma.com is a real-world company (centralized, not p2p) of today that is sort of on the same path.
Re:Tor Challenge by atmosx on Thursday June 05, 2014 @06:51AM (#7851229)
WOW. I would like to see an extensive post describing in detail the ways bitcoin protocol can evolve. Sounds a very promising future.
Re:Tor Challenge by chatmasta on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:49AM (#7850728)
We have the same vision for the future of ISP's. If you're interested in chatting about this definitely get in touch.
Re:Tor Challenge by wyager on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:15AM (#7852330)
How do you protect against people setting up fake nodes that just relay useless data among each other, or claim to do so?
Re:Tor Challenge by VikingCoder on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:53AM (#7852526)
I believe the point is when you want to transfer data, you pay for it.

So, transferring data among each other wouldn't get them any coin from outside their own circle...

Re:Tor Challenge by wyager on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:16PM (#7856043)
So more of these coins can't be minted? Who controls/creates the initial money supply? What happens when bandwidth exceeds what the money supply can usefully measure?
Re:Tor Challenge by hackety on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:21AM (#7850644)
That's such a good idea.

Tor really needs some more relays. With this it could be more interesting to companies as a business model.

One thing I could be worried about is abuse - could a scriptkiddie deploy a botnet and earn TorCoins with this, like it's done with bitcoin miners (although not that effective any more).