News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by potatolicious on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @07:06PM (#7849037)
I really hope this doesn't go through. T-Mobile has been great for me, and shed a lot of the anti-consumer policies of the other carriers. I'd hate to regress.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by brownbat on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:29PM (#7849651)
I feel like it could have benefits, but like you I lean pessimistic.

I had a deeply discounted unlimited plan with Sprint (a couple family members worked there).

I left when T-Mobile offered a lower price for unlimited web + text. The only people I know who use voice use OTT services for it anyway. On top of that, T-Mob offered BYOD, letting me run pure Android, without all of Sprint's then unremovable NFL, NASCAR, and Facebook apps. It beat Sprint's employee discount plan for me, and easily.

My family members who work there were frustrated by the news. They mostly rationalized by bashing T-Mobile, claiming their prices were unsustainable, arguing it must be a risky, poorly run business.

I think those prices are only unsustainable when you have a major carrier's assumptions. Assumptions about acceptable levels of overhead and expected levels of profit.

I think Sprint did some really bold things in its history. It fought the good fight as MCI against an entrenched telecom monopoly, back when sentiment was against them, when legislators were literally talking up how wonderfully efficient the telecom monopoly was.* Today I feel like T-Mobile is more like the scrappy startup that benefits consumers primarily by running aggressively trim.

Unlike others posting here, I've never had any network issues with T-Mobile, and had routine congestion based or coverage based issues with Sprint. But that doesn't really matter. A larger network could offer more redundancy, and faster speeds on both sides of the network.

Historically though, conglomeration of telecom companies has reduced competition, and essentially led to monopoly rents for a service that is especially susceptible to price competition. (There's a reason they try to lock you in with contracts. Competition is the enemy.) Here, I worry that Sprint's management has noticed that T-Mobile is unlike other competitors, AT&T, and is competing on price, setting a dangerous precedent. I worry they're trying to squash this unruly behavior through the purchase.

Potential benefits might be nice, I just worry the downside risk is very large.

* Check out "The Master Switch" by Tim Wu, or at least this review: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/12/books/review/Leonhardt-t.h...

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by apendleton on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:06PM (#7849798)
"I think those prices are only unsustainable when you have a major carrier's assumptions. Assumptions about acceptable levels of overhead and expected levels of profit."

And assumptions about acceptable levels of service and coverage. I'm saying that as a loyal T-Mobile customer, but it's readily apparent that when I visit my parents in my small home town, or drive a few hours east to the beach towns near me, or really go anywhere much outside a major city, my service is poor or non-existent, and my Verizon-customer friends' service is fine. I'm okay with that because I live in a big city, don't go to small towns often, and think the mediocre coverage is worth it for the lower price, but there's definitely a "you get what you pay for" aspect to all of this, at least in my experience.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by brownbat on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:42PM (#7849909)
> I'm saying that as a loyal T-Mobile customer, but it's readily apparent that when I visit my parents in my small home town, or drive a few hours east to the beach towns near me, or really go anywhere much outside a major city, my service is poor or non-existent, and my Verizon-customer friends' service is fine.

Yeah, I think more testimonials are on your side here, so I don't doubt that T-Mobile subscribers face this issue, but it's strange to me, because I had exactly the opposite experience in reliability. Moving from Sprint to T-Mobile improved my reliability considerably.

Sprint would claim I had full bars, but downloads would stall out, webpages would just die half loaded. This was near their headquarters in Kansas City. T-Mobile's network has never crowded me off line, and has worked for me fairly consistently on the east coast.

Neither seemed to work very reliably in the long rural gaps between Kansas City and other metropolitan areas at the time. (Though I hear Sprint has I-70 covered fairly well now.)

I think part of my experience is driven by the fact on the spectrum of "voice user" to "web user," I'm really far to the right, probably outside of the mainstream. Could be T-Mobile's investments in data have come at the expense of their voice reliability? I'm not sure...

I guess if the main issue is T-Mobile's lack of coverage, then on net, things will improve after a merger. If the main concern is Sprint over-selling their network so that it becomes congested and unusable around 6 PM, then a merger is mostly just going to make things worse. It will be better in the short term, but as Sprint takes on subscribers, unless they change their strategy, they'll still overbook the lines.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by commandar on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:50AM (#7851931)
T-mobile's strategy has generally been a higher quality network over a limited footprint. If your within their limited coverage area, coverage tends to be quite good. Wander outside it and it degrades rapidly.

Sprint coverage tends to be better, but their network has generally lagged behind in terms of technology.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by phil21 on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:16PM (#7852939)
I don't think you can really compare the best network in the US (Verizon) to Sprint in any meaningful way. I would put (based on ancedote of course) Sprint's network on par with T-mobile in terms of coverage. I'd rank it far below T-Mobile in terms of speed.

If you need good coverage "everywhere" VZW is unfortunately your only real option. AT&T I guess is a close second.

Or to put it another way. I have lent my VZW phone out to dozens of people to make phone calls when they lacked coverage. I have never once had to borrow a Sprint or AT&T phone to make mine.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by rayiner on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:19AM (#7851298)
Meh. I have T-Mobile, but AT&T's service is faster and has better coverage. I get barely any coverage in my parents house less than 15 miles from DC. Not a big deal for me, because I'm mostly in the city, but its a lower quality product being sold for a lower price. Nothing atypical about that.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by opendais on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:03PM (#7849786)
Ya, that what scares me too.

I run stock android BYOD style with Tmobile. I don't want them to switch to the Sprint model of terrible apps and higher prices. :/

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by taylorwc on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:11AM (#7852034)
+1 on the Tim Wu book. Being a young[ish] person, Wu's perspective on the history of innovation and competition in media and connectivity-provider industries was eye-opening. I think about that book often in regards to the pending mergers right now (Tmo/Sprint, Comcast/TWC, DirectTV/ATT.)
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by ToastyMallows on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:18AM (#7852071)
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by joshdance on Thursday June 05, 2014 @11:58AM (#7852558)
+1 for smile link
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by ToastyMallows on Friday June 06, 2014 @09:59AM (#7857876)
Check out this add-on for chrome, this way you never forget!

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smile-always/jgpmh...

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by donflamenco on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @07:24PM (#7849128)
From what I understand, if this goes through, T-mobile will be the surviving brand. The current CEO of T-Mobile will run the new company.

I am a current T-mobile customer and anti-Sprint. I think this is a good move.

This is more of a merger than a buyout.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by abrowne on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @07:27PM (#7849143)
As long as they stay pro-GSM and unlocked phones. And no matter what, it's way better than a purchase by Comcast!
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by aidenn0 on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @07:55PM (#7849242)
I strongly suspect they will move to CDMA, as IIRC Sprint owns far more towers than t-mobile. On the other hand for LTE they should be compatible.

[edit] As I said in another thread, my information for that is a few years old, so this may not be true anymore.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by dsl on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:00PM (#7849774)
Sprint has more towers, but they effectively run three different networks on top of them, making it a terrible fragmented mess.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by greg5green on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:40PM (#7849903)
More likely that they slowly decommission the CDMA network as both networks move towards being 100% LTE.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by zanny on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:34PM (#7849666)
I miss Wimax.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by ulfw on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:57PM (#7849525)
With DT owning only 20% I doubt the brand would be T-Mobile. Most likely it would be Sprint branding and look n feel with largely T-Mo management. Will be interesting to see what happens to Bellevue as I suppose the combined co might be run from Overland Park.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by jusben1369 on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:24PM (#7849638)
Agreed. Sprint is by far the bigger brand in the US. Although if this was even 1 year later it might be more of a toss up as T-Mobile has done great things to enhance the markets perception of them.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by ulfw on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:30PM (#7849873)
Well I'd argue that T-Mobile is clearly the 'preferred' brand in the market. Just kind of doubt it would make sense to brand it that way when T-Mo Intl only owns 15 or 20% of it. Who knows - maybe they come up with a new brand even (like EE for T-Mobile/Orange in the UK)
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by YokoZar on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @11:00PM (#7849970)
One of the nice assets you acquire when you merge is the option to use whichever brand will work best in front of consumers, no matter how small a player it actually is.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by jusben1369 on Thursday June 05, 2014 @03:55PM (#7853961)
I don't know why T-Mo Int % of ownership matters one way or the other. The BOD of the new combined company would say "Ok, which brand is better to go with?" The only way I can imagine T-Mo Intl having an impact is if they specifically wanted to forbid it being called that for their own brand reasons. That might include fear that the US will screw up and drag down their brand overall. Or they may want to try again here in 5 or 10 years and use T-Mobile then etc.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by ulfw on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:08PM (#7855206)
It matters when you see how long DT wanted to get out of the US market. With a small ownership it's just a question of time when they get rid of that too, because frankly you have no control with that percentage. So if you don't control the entity and have no interest in it in the first place (thus the multiple tries to sell it), why tarnish your brand with something that is out of your hand and control?
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by protomyth on Thursday June 05, 2014 @09:42AM (#7851880)
"Well I'd argue that T-Mobile is clearly the 'preferred' brand in the market."

Given the sponsorships and the lack of coverage in certain markets, Sprint is the higher profile brand.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by donflamenco on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:53AM (#7851394)
Here's the article talking about it.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/05/29/us-softbank-tmobil...

"Deutsche Telekom may also be more accommodating with Softbank regarding a break-up fee than it was with AT&T, the sources said. That is because T-Mobile is likely to be the surviving brand and its CEO, John Legere, is likely to lead the new combined company, thus avoiding a loss of subscribers and momentum it had to contend with during the drawn out regulatory process with AT&T, two of the sources said."

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by JoshTriplett on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:01PM (#7849276)
If T-Mobile and Sprint can leverage this to create one more comprehensive LTE network (ignoring the CDMA bits from Sprint), that would greatly benefit T-Mobile customers. T-Mobile's biggest problem is coverage.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by myared on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:59PM (#7849545)
I hope this is true as a T-mobile subscriber. T-mobile is great in cities, but it's terrible when you leave. You can make a phone call, but there will no Internet. I just finished a cross country road trip, and if I were ever to do one again, I would get a Verizon phone for a month.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by mrinterweb on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:28PM (#7849650)
I was a Sprint customer for years. From my experience, their coverage was not a whole lot better than T-Mobile's. I'd also hate to see them switch their networks to be more CDMA centric. CDMA should go away IMO.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by burnte on Thursday June 05, 2014 @01:21AM (#7850355)
With LTE, CDMA is going away. Both Verizon and Sprint have committed to going with world-common standards rather than staying with CDMA, which is dead anyway.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by taylorwc on Thursday June 05, 2014 @10:12AM (#7852039)
Agreed, but the time horizon on that is likely a decade at the least.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by jonknee on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:07PM (#7849580)
I also just finished a cross country trip and Verizon would not be a bad way to go. I purposely got a Verizon flavored iPad so that I would have multiple networks (AT&T mobile phone) and between the two I usually had coverage. AT&T slipped back to 4G/3G/EDGE and even GPRS (!) much more than Verizon did. But having both was great.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by pkulak on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:48PM (#7849480)
This. I loved T-Mobile but decided to bail since it didn't work between cities for me. T-Mobile's service with better coverage? Sign me up.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by wise_young_man on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:37PM (#7849433)
As a Sprint customer, I hope it does go through. My internet speeds are pretty bad even after them upgrading the infrastructure here to LTE. I don't know how it will play out, but I think Sprint users could stand to benefit from T-Mobile. As a T-Mobile user though, I could see why you could be nervous if it went the opposite direction and both services went downhill. I think Sprint wants the band that T-Mobile has that they received in the AT&T fallout so my hopes are positive.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by maxsilver on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @10:53PM (#7849942)
This won't help your Sprint service get faster.

Sprint is already sitting on tons of unused spectrum, and a larger subscriber base than T-Mobile. Nothing stops Sprint from fixing their own service. They just choose not to. And they choose to not fix their network, all across the nation in lots of areas.

My fear is that Sprint's lack of care and lack of effort, will bleed into T-Mobile's network, and we'll be down to just two functional service providers in the US.

Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by jusben1369 on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:26PM (#7849642)
You really want it to happen. T-Mobile's CEO will lead the combined company. So more of what you love but now with the resources to fix the bad parts.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by untog on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @08:48PM (#7849478)
T-Mobile has been great for me too, but I'm not totally soured on this idea. Their coverage is bad, and this could help them in the future. They also never get good handset exclusives - if they were a larger company perhaps they might be able to compete better.
Re:Sprint and T-Mobile Agree on Terms of $32B Deal by esbonsa on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:15PM (#7849609)
I've had both carriers on different devices on a recent car trip across eastern USA and Sprint had much better coverage. Hopefully this would help T-Mobile.