I hate email and avoid it as much as possible so that is not a source of distraction for me.
Today I have 2 1080p 22in monitors, 1 1900x1200 27in monitor, and 1 1440x900 19in monitor
the 19in monitor i use to display various monitoring tools and automation outputs.
the 27in is my primary work area one of the 22in I use for Media (spotify) and reference/docs so I can reference and/or update documentation while I work on a project The 2nd 22in is simple overflow, a post can drag things when needed. It is used less often i could probably get by with out it but it is nice to have when i need it
If you're doing development and need to see the output window, some logging, and are watching your performance monitoring application, you'll run out of real estate in a hurry.
A single monitor can also help one be more productive by not having always-on distractions in your periphery. Putting the inbox away is a very effective way to be productive. (There was an article about this on Slate but I can't seem to find it.)