Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by Fuzzwah on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @12:09PM
(#7846395)
Is this the blog post you've mentioned?
http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2011/06/reality-...
It is titled "Three arguments against the singularity" from June 22, 2011
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @12:18PM
(#7846451)
Yeah, that one. And I didn't bother addressing the "Simulation Argument", since it's unfalsifiable nonsense.
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by halfcat on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @09:03PM
(#7849562)
Unfalsifiable, okay. But why nonsense? (I haven't read it, yet, genuinely interested in your non-hand-waving thoughts).
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by eli_gottlieb on Thursday June 05, 2014 @02:30AM
(#7850511)
"Nonsense" in that there's literally no way to ever tell the difference between a "simulation" being run on a computer in some exterior universe and a very real universe whose laws of physics are fundamentally discrete. "Real" is what you can causally interact with, which means that until that exterior universe decides to deliberately talk to us, they are not actually real with respect to us.
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by halfcat on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:25AM
(#7851317)
Maybe "pointless" is more correct then. "Nonsense" suggests you have a strong opinion on whether we live in a simulation, which as you said, we can't know.
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by ableal on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @03:07PM
(#7847476)
This bit:
"What we're going to see is increasingly solicitous machines defining our environment"
reminded me of Jack Williamson's With Folded Hands scenario (from 1947, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/With_Folded_Hands )
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by DanBC on Wednesday June 04, 2014 @12:25PM
(#7846491)
> Meh, I always thought your "Why There Will Be No Singularity" blog post was a pretty accurate prediction. AI will work, but be so piecemeal that the chances of total domination by a superintelligent singleton get quite low.
Oh god - domination by the mediocre AI bureaucrat sounds worse than the AI overlord.
Re:"We need a pony. And the moon on a stick. By next Thursday."
by davidgerard on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:26AM
(#7851322)
In the future, cyborg personality emulations embodying immortal human minds will still behave like arseholes towards each other.
Which has the major upside of meaning we'll never have to deal with the Vile Offspring.
By the way, the final component to Rapture of the Nerds didn't seem to have a very good "exam", as I can't imagine the Galactic Authority would never have come up with any way to analyze minds, for instance a sample of human minds, and thus infer the chance that we can coexist as a species without having to run trillions of parallel copies performing very expensive simulations. Hilarious book, other than that, though; it really reminded me how much of a total nerd I am that I understood every single damn word without having to google.