News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by Retric on Saturday May 31, 2014 @10:28AM (#7826093)
Proofs don't have a single correct answer they have a range of acceptable solutions. Any time your told to show your work there tends to be a multitude of acceptable answers.
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by Double_Cast on Saturday May 31, 2014 @04:53PM (#7827237)
I think he likes math because it's consistent. E.g. if I prove that some natural number "x" is prime in decimal, then "x" is also prime in binary, ternary, octal, etc. Counting "x" in a different base doesn't change the symmetry. Likewise, arriving at a theorem via different proofs just describe the same mathematical object in different ways.
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by nl on Saturday May 31, 2014 @10:32AM (#7826111)
That's not the point: they have a correct sequence of steps.
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by sp332 on Saturday May 31, 2014 @11:06AM (#7826205)
Hardly any math has a correct sequence of steps. (Unless you meant a sequence of correct steps?)
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by hamburglar on Saturday May 31, 2014 @01:13PM (#7826535)
But you are aware that tests on math, particularly for school kids, generally do have a correct sequence of steps, right? The point isn't the answer, but rather to demonstrate mastery of a particular technique. In this case, the test should present problems where one particular set of steps is arguably the best or most obvious one. If the student uses a different set of steps but gets the correct answer, then perhaps the question needs to be asked in a different way (e.g. "Use Euler's Method to determine...").
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by rbehrends on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:31PM (#7826795)
Not really. Consider the following question, for example (taking from an actual eighth grade math test):

"Combine the equation 8x+y/2 = 1/24 with a second equation so that the resulting system of linear equations has (a) exactly one (b) zero solutions. Justify your answer."

That's leaving aside the fact that there are multiple ways to solve a system of linear equations with two variables to begin with (since you don't even need to solve such a system to answer the question).

Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by sp332 on Saturday May 31, 2014 @03:37PM (#7827017)
But if you're teaching a particular technique, then the test would not be whether you can answer the problem but whether you understand how to use the technique.
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by rbehrends on Saturday May 31, 2014 @04:33PM (#7827164)
And that, in a nutshell, is what's wrong with American math education. Too much focus on rote learning rather than actual understanding. What you're describing is an accounting course, not mathematics. Mathematics is about problem solving, not plugging numbers into a black box and blindly following a prescribed sequence of algorithmic steps. You do not want to just test whether students can follow a procedure; you want to test whether they actually know what they're doing when they're using it (even if you specify the procedure, e.g. Gaussian elimination).

This even applies to simple problems. See the comment by Aur Saraf responding to the original article: http://powersfulmath.wordpress.com/2014/04/30/who-or-what-br...

Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by sp332 on Sunday June 01, 2014 @08:00AM (#7828877)
How is a student going to do any math if you never teach techniques? And how are you going to know if the student actually learned it if you don't test them? I never said they should be the focus, but you need to test them sometimes.

Also, algorithmic thinking is one of the more powerful ideas we have right now. You can trust that a Turing machine has certain properties without being a genius yourself, for example.

Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by Retric on Saturday May 31, 2014 @03:56PM (#7827068)
Take something real simple "Solve X + Y = 2; X + 2Y = 4 using substitution."

At the basic level that has 4 choices, you can substitute X or Y in the top or bottom equation.

Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by nl on Saturday May 31, 2014 @07:26PM (#7827623)
WTF? A proof certainly does have a correct sequence of steps. You can't just reorder the steps in a derivation for example.
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by sp332 on Sunday June 01, 2014 @09:12AM (#7829030)
What kind of proof? Here are 102 proofs of the Pythagorean Theorem. http://www.cut-the-knot.org/pythagoras/index.shtml
Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by nl on Sunday June 01, 2014 @08:04PM (#7831216)
Pretty much all of them?

Take the Euclidian proof (#7). The order of the reasoning is important, because each step builds upon what was proved in the previous step.

Re:Who or What Broke My Kids? by Retric on Monday June 02, 2014 @12:30PM (#7834321)
You can think of proofs as chains of logic. Assuming A, B, and C.

  (A+B) -> X, (A+C)-> Y
  (X+Y) -> Z
Now you need to prove both X and Y before Z. But, you could prove Y before X so It's not a strict question of order but one of dependence.

Going back to the proof 7 the line For the same reason also means the order is not strict and you could swap those lines without changing the logic.