Anyway, getting the answer right and seeing which different angles I could take to get to those results were entirely part of the reason why I loved math. The answer wasn't per se the number at the end. The answer was, for each method I employed, the right sequence of logical and mathematically sound steps to that final value.
I would have never really been so fascinated by mathematics and related disciplines if it weren't for that sense of absolute, meritocratic, objective wrong or right.
In high school, however, my school implemented a 'pass the test first' policy. We learned what the Regents (spelling on this) exam would have and learned only that. Still, most of my teachers always graded the procedure and not the answers (in fact, my teachers suggested we look at the answers afterwards to compare if our answer is right).
One of the worst examples of that mentality I saw in a first year university course was a multi-part question where one part had the student calculate something and the next part had the student do something to sanity check the answer. One student got the first part wrong and then fudged the working in the second part to get it to say that the first answer was correct. Of course, this completely misses the point of checking the answer. Worse, they came up to me after class and argued that they deserved full points because the second error was "a consequence of" the first one. They seemed totally perplexed that I didn't agree.
There is a problem where children just learn algorithms. But they don't really understand numbers or how this algorithm works. And the bang numbers in and hope for the best.
Show them "speed = distance / time", and give them distances and times and they're fine. Now given them some speeds and times and ask them to find distance and they're stumped.
Math should be teaching children how to think, not just how to put numbers into a calculator.
That's the part that counts, and is largely missing today.
For example, when solving quadratic equations, I often used trial substitutions and the fact quadratic equations have at most two solutions to justify answers, instead of using quadratic formula. Why wouldn't this get the full mark? (I would actually argue this is a better procedure if you are looking for integer-only solutions, for example.)
I've read the Common Core (and the Australian equivalent) and they certainly require proving how answers were obtained.
Naturally, there's a side of math involving getting an approximate answer that's good enough to be useful. One thing I've noticed as my kids progress through school is that most science being taught is qualitative or descriptive.
Adding some quantitative science to the K-12 curriculum would be a way to teach a more fuzzy approach to math. Naturally, science has its own notion of "right" that could be learned through the formation and testing of quantitative hypotheses.
There were many courses where I could get an "A" by writing a mountain of drivel that anticipated the teacher's social biases. I was thankful for the boost to my GPA, but the "no right answer" aspects of those subjects frustrated me. Oh well, different strokes.
One thing the standardized tests might be doing is to focus too much on memorized algorithms. And it may not be necessary. My son had a teacher in grade school who didn't even teach the standard algorithms for things like two column addition. Instead, the kids spend time trying to come up with their own methods. Yet his students get excellent scores on the state tests.
Try spending some time digging into the foundations of set theory. A good starting point is looking into the Axiom of Choice and the Continuum Hypothesis: are they true or false? Is there a "right" answer to those questions?
"Combine the equation 8x+y/2 = 1/24 with a second equation so that the resulting system of linear equations has (a) exactly one (b) zero solutions. Justify your answer."
That's leaving aside the fact that there are multiple ways to solve a system of linear equations with two variables to begin with (since you don't even need to solve such a system to answer the question).
This even applies to simple problems. See the comment by Aur Saraf responding to the original article: http://powersfulmath.wordpress.com/2014/04/30/who-or-what-br...
Also, algorithmic thinking is one of the more powerful ideas we have right now. You can trust that a Turing machine has certain properties without being a genius yourself, for example.
At the basic level that has 4 choices, you can substitute X or Y in the top or bottom equation.
Take the Euclidian proof (#7). The order of the reasoning is important, because each step builds upon what was proved in the previous step.
(A+B) -> X, (A+C)-> Y
(X+Y) -> Z
Now you need to prove both X and Y before Z. But, you could prove Y before X so It's not a strict question of order but one of dependence.Going back to the proof 7 the line For the same reason also means the order is not strict and you could swap those lines without changing the logic.
That's also a big part of why I got into Computer Science. Computer Science[1] courses are basically a flavor of the interesting kind of math. I really enjoyed working through algorithmic and computability problems because it wasn't always obvious how I should approach them or if I'd even be able to figure them out.
I think it's sad the vast majority of students will never even reach a math course where they aren't performing calculations that could trivially programmed into a computer. It seems like there should be a way to give students a taste of that earlier on, but I'm not sure what the best approach would be.
0: This kinda started with integrals in Calc II, but didn't get really interesting till the my first 3000-level University course on proof by induction and the like. 1: Not programming or engineering, although those can be fun in their own ways.
Also, I should note that at METU no mathematician major student was able to graduate from statistics department as minor. They all gave up. That's what our professors told us. That is why math and statistics are very different subjects. It is like math and chemistry or math and computer engineering. Statistics do not deals with math, it has its own separate topic.
Mathematics is indeed all about rigor, proof, and finding "correct answers". Philosophy, on the other hand, takes a more lenient approach, with emphasis on the process of thinking, rather than the final result.
Perhaps the children in this class merely thought that a more mathematics-oriented approach was what the teacher desired. That's reasonable, if that's how their previous classes had been done.
Apparently the students themselves adjusted quickly enough, once the teacher made her expectations clear. As the article states, "Things went so much better the second time around with not one student asking me if their answer was “right”".
So this could very well come down to a simple misunderstanding between the teacher and her students, in this rather isolated case.
The "right answer" consisting of a valid proof is very different from the "right answer" to a numerical computation. The thinking and communication process is surely more relevant to the former than the latter. And if anything, as you say, the former is what math is really about.
When it comes to mathematics, the exact form of the outcome isn't very important. Maybe it's a valid proof in one case, maybe it's a specific number in another case.
It's the degree of rigor that's important. Rigor is what separates mathematics from other fields of study.
Thinking and reasoning about abstract concepts aren't without value, of course. But if this is done without an extreme degree of rigor, it probably should not be considered to be mathematics.
A: Because they can't tell their coffee cup and donut apart.
When it comes to mathematics, the exact form of the outcome is extremely important. Proofs that are aesthetically pleasing are better than proofs that are not. Proofs that glean insight are better than proofs that do not. In fact, most people don't care about whether a theorem is true unless the proof provides sufficient insights.
"If we are to truly make progress in getting our students to understand the concepts presented in the Common Core to the depth intended we must help them learn to stop looking for a right answer and start looking for a right reason."
Talking to a lot of teachers it is often not the provided Core material that is the issue, but not having enough time to actually provide the structure and context to help the kids internalize why any of it is important. It's also not a surprise that is the case, given that at least where I live (California) the school year is measurably shorter and class sizes are measurably bigger than they were when I was in the same grades.
So, if math isn't about getting the right answer, it's been broken a long time.
Even today, math as I've explored it (which admittedly hasn't been much) has right and wrong answers. Sure, there's a bit of fuzz in the answers now, but a probabilistic model which can't determine ham from spam some majority of the time isn't kinda right, or even on the spectrum of right. It's just wrong, and needs to be fixed.