News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT and Harvard release de-identified learning data from ... by contingencies on Saturday May 31, 2014 @04:02AM (#7825518)
My problem with MOOCs is immediacy: I'm interested now and I don't want to delay that over x weeks, beginning at y point in the future. Hell, I often don't know what country I'm going to be in, let alone whether I'll have free time and an internet connection. So for my lifestyle, the relatively simple mapping from traditional tertiary course formats across to MOOCs is fundamentally flawed one, though I believe they are improving these days by offering access to all materials immediately. Another thing is downloads ... I just want everything, please. I'm often offline, as I believe many developing country learners may be. I don't want to have to register, log in, then painfully click through everything bit by bit. I want bittorrent with early-to-late material download priority. (Otherwise, maybe someone should start developing a converted and open courseware format to share on PirateBoxes? http://piratebox.cc/)
Re:MIT and Harvard release de-identified learning data from ... by incision on Saturday May 31, 2014 @11:22AM (#7826236)
I'd wager that you're in the small minority here.

I've gone through a number of MOOC courses and structure, schedule, TA interaction and shared experience seem pretty important to most enthusiastic / best performing course takers.

Some courses, like CS50 are already completely self-paced. Others run quite frequently, restart every month.

Being able to have it all in terms of TA/instructor support and an arbitrary schedule seems to be the direction Udacity is going with subscriptions.

I do agree that being to easily grab some/all course materials at once would a nice option. However, I've completed a majority of the work for my courses offline and only one had its coursework structure in a way that necessitated a frequent connection to complete.

Re:MIT and Harvard release de-identified learning data from ... by adricnet on Saturday May 31, 2014 @10:45AM (#7826149)
Well, the problem there is a lack of available $QUALITY courseware content as there are tools to do this sort of thing (Moodle, XO Server) and free content (moodle.net, Khan Academy, scorm modules) available in small quantities for some topics and languages.

I would advance the theory that the art and science of developing useful and effective courseware is new and we (humans) haven't at all figured out how to do it yet.

Various people I know are exploring this from different directions with their projects, EG:

* AST is running with the free BBST courses

* while the original authors of that free content have built a company around expanding and maintaining the curriculum commercially.

* a friend is putting together work for hire 1000x level class material as part of her instructor position

The economics of motivating class creation, much less improving $QUALITY or availability under free culture licences are ... well quick the thorny thicket.

Re:MIT and Harvard release de-identified learning data from ... by ghaff on Saturday May 31, 2014 @10:11AM (#7826052)
I think a lot of people find the structure helpful (and it's the only real way to make things like discussion boards work). That said, it's really a tradeoff. Case in point, there's a sabermetrics course running that I'm sort of interested in and, had it started when scheduled a month ago, the timing would have been pretty good. As it is, I'm about to take off on a lot of travel and it's probably not realistic to do anything other than audit the couse.