News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by arrrg on Friday May 30, 2014 @03:04AM (#7820616)
I don't know why, but this creeps me out. This seems like such a hard balance to get right and also too much of a burden for search engines. Also, there is potential for abuse.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by danieldk on Friday May 30, 2014 @04:38AM (#7820817)
Sure, it is a hard balance to get right. But privacy is an important right and we should not throw it away because it creates some extra effort for a multi-billion dollar company.

I also find it weak that Page plays the 'think of the startups' card. In fact, I think that since the Snowden leaks, there are far more opportunities to create privacy-aware or privacy-protecting services. E.g., I am pretty sure that Duckduckgo, a startup in search, benefitted tremendously from the recent attention to privacy issues.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by cbr on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:42AM (#7821082)
DuckDuckGo certainly has benefited from privacy becoming more salient, but this ruling is probably negative for them. Each of these removal requests needs manual review to keep people from requesting takedowns of other people's stuff. There are ~500M people eligible to request takedowns under the ruling, and if 1% of them ask for one link removed per year that's 14k requests per day. If each request takes 5min then you need 143 people working full time. Which high but doable for Google, but at ~20 employees this would be an enormous burden for DDG.

These numbers could be higher if someone puts out a campaign that goes viral and gets lots of people submitting requests, and there's nothing that stops people outside the EU from submitting (invalid) requests.

One thing in DDG's favor, however, is that that at first people are probably only going to send these requests to Google.

Disclaimer: I work for Google, on open source software.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by danieldk on Friday May 30, 2014 @09:37AM (#7821654)
There are ~500M people eligible to request takedowns under the ruling, and if 1% of them ask for one link removed per year that's 14k requests per day. If each request takes 5min then you need 143 people working full time. Which high but doable for Google, but at ~20 employees this would be an enormous burden for DDG.

You are making a mistake in your math here, since a sizeable portion of that 500M people use Google, but probably only a fraction of a percent uses DDG.

In other words, if DDG's usage is currently 1% that of Google (which would surprise me), that's 1.43 people. If you are a search company of 20 people, it seems reasonable to me to have at least a few people working on keeping your index clean.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by cbr on Friday May 30, 2014 @12:55PM (#7822799)
For my privacy to be protected in this way it doesn't matter what search engine I use, it matters what search engine the people who are trying to look me up use. If I want a fact about me to not come up when people search for my name I would need to remove it from any search engine others might look in. This is a lower barrier than usage, but you're right that at least for now people probably won't bother submitting these to DDG.

Unless someone makes a single form for submitting a removal request to all/most search engines? Though I guess then the search engines could pool together and do some kind of centralized processing of these requests?

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by mike_hearn on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:25AM (#7821345)
DuckDuckGo is primarily a Bing frontend, no? I seem to recall that they claim to be a real search engine and have their own crawler, but any time someone analyses their results deeply they're almost always identical to Bing.

Given that Microsoft has a large EU presence and is presumably also affected by this law, perhaps they will have to start doing the same thing as Google. Which would then automatically feed through to DuckDuckGo.

I don't believe there are any competitive startup search engines at the moment. However, this doesn't mean there would never be. Plus this ruling is so vague it's likely to impact all kinds of companies that are not startups: think specialised social networks, etc.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by Vik1ng on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:17AM (#7820909)
Also open data like OpenStreetMap will really help DuckDuckGo and other services to contest google in that market. Especiylly when that data is connected to Wikipedia & Wikidata then they can show similar snippets as google.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by marincounty on Friday May 30, 2014 @04:52AM (#7820857)
Duckduckgo is getting better each quarter. Whenever I type anything into a search engine; I now pause for a micro second, 1/8 of the time I access DDG.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by yuhong on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:26AM (#7820928)
It doesn't create extra effort just for the companies involved.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by arrrg on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:30AM (#7820942)
I don’t really see what privacy has to do with it. Really. Privacy, to me, isn’t something that is timed. Either it’s ok to state something publicly or not, time shouldn’t matter in my opinion.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by seren on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:16AM (#7821032)
Privacy is only very tangentially linked to what you say, this is also related to what you did, or even what happened to you in a passive way.

Let's say that 20 years ago your family was murdered under your eyes by an axe-wielding maniac when you were 4 years old. Now as a potential employer, I type your name on Google and the first result is an article from 20 years ago. Maybe I am prejudiced but I wonder if you would be a pretty stable employee, and as a result, I bin your CV.

This has nothing to do with being able to "state" something but this is really a privacy issue.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by throwwit on Friday May 30, 2014 @04:01AM (#7820724)
It's already happening in one form or another with 'reputation management' and the DMCA... http://arstechnica.com/science/2013/02/site-plagiarizes-blog...
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by Fuxy on Friday May 30, 2014 @04:45AM (#7820837)
It's also useless the content isn't removed it is just impossible to find in search engines.

If You can make a decentralized search engine that indexes everything no exceptions you would still find it.

Or you could make your own. It doesn't make it impossible to find just impossible for the average person.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by blazespin on Friday May 30, 2014 @04:55AM (#7820866)
Which is really the idea. The law isn't about squelching free speech, it's just trying to keep this information from being so easily available. It's the right balance.

I find it so incredibly hard to believe that so many people are falling for this "poor-us" google routine. I just shake my head in bewilderment every time I hear it.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by ewillbefull on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:44AM (#7820977)
> The law isn't about squelching free speech, it's just trying to keep this information from being so easily available.

You're just mincing words here. There are profound speech arguments to be made when someone is coerced or threatened for publishing _facts_. It is the same nanny-state crap that Europe invokes when it criminalizes offending people, and they have an army of people like you to jump on their bandwagon.

The ruling is technologically illiterate. It fails to appreciate the growing ability for anyone to access and index public information as time goes on. It fails to appreciate its jurisdiction and effectiveness. It fails to make sound rational justification that separates the role of a newspaper from a news aggregator.

Most important of all, it gives the government an enormously broad -- and practically limitless -- ability to remove the expression and dissemination of information based on purely subjective and even temporal characteristics. Europe's freedom of expression laws are a joke with endless carve-outs for "public stability" and "offense" which will only become increasingly useful tools to regulate and censor legitimate public discourse.

Too bad for you, these laws won't work and when they fail it will be embarrassing. In the short term, enjoy the further rot of economic growth in the region due to compliance costs of this and other ridiculous judgments.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by krbbltr on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:58AM (#7821264)
You sound bitter. Why do you get so worked up over 'nanny-state crap' that's going on on the other side of the world? Business interests in the EU and don't like to put in the extra effort? Or do you just enjoy that mode of righteous indignation?

I find it amusing that – even taking the Google shills out of the picture –, most of the 'debate' around this topic is along the lines of Americans preaching to Europeans about how they're 'doing it wrong', often with emotionally charged language, just like your comment here. Ever thought that Europeans just might have some slightly different values than you do?

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by mike_hearn on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:27AM (#7821358)
I live in Europe, was born in Britain, and I think this is a bad ruling that makes the EU look like a bad joke.

Laws that can only be enforced by building a massive system of internet censorship akin to China's are indeed "doing it wrong".

Happy now?

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by krbbltr on Friday May 30, 2014 @08:58AM (#7821476)
You're entitled to your opinion, but a single comment on a US-centric discussion forum does not convince me that it's a majority opinion as far as Europeans go. My observations so far indicate the opposite.
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by Fuxy on Friday May 30, 2014 @09:54AM (#7821772)
As a European myself the request of the citizen for the removal of the content was legitimate you can't have past problems looming over you your entire life and certain things are just too personal and shouldn't be so easy to find to begin with.

I don't want a potential google search to reveal I got my home repossessed for instance.

The employer could take advantage of this by offering you a lower wage since you're desperate it's more likely you will take it or not hire you at all.

However the way the court choose to handle this was completely wrong. This shouldn't be handled at search engine level but at the publishing website level.

The ability of anybody requesting content to be removed from the internet should be very limited in the types of things they can have removed and rigorously monitored by a court of law.

Plus there should be a private database containing the Names of the people who had content removed and what was removed.

That would discourage political reasons since the log of their activity exists even if the content doesn't.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by mike_hearn on Friday May 30, 2014 @10:48AM (#7822067)
What about the right of the employer to know who they're about to employ?

If someone claims to be an expert in a certain area which you need but are not yourself an expert in, it would be very useful to be able to search their name and discover that things they wrote about the topic have been discredited. It'd be even more useful if you could find unflattering opinions about them written by their peers: perhaps it avoids a very long and messy employment of someone who will then be difficult to fire, but who doesn't know what they're doing, potentially crippling your business.

The guy you're looking at would probably love to make the criticism of his work unfindable whilst simultaneously leaving behind the bits that make him look good. But why should he have that right? Employers have needs too.

For what it's worth I quite agree that the existing framework for getting things removed from the internet (by going to the source) works well enough, but that's not what the court has now created.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by mike_hearn on Friday May 30, 2014 @10:41AM (#7822016)
But haven't you just been assuming that anyone who is against this ruling is American?
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by krbbltr on Friday May 30, 2014 @10:18PM (#7825030)
Generally, no, I have not. That preachy, self-righteous subset of Americans I was referring to is usually very easy to tell apart from concerned Europeans. Which to be sure I've seen as well, but in much lower quantities.

And to be clear, I don't actually have much of an opinion on whether the immediate consequences of the ECJ ruling will be positive or negative ones for EU citizens. My issue is mainly with the way this topic was and is reported on in some of the US media – lots of fear mongering and misrepresentation of facts by mainstream press and high-profile bloggers alike. It smells like a PR campaign. (The completely unreflected freedom-of-speech-as-a-religion type forum commenter is really just a consequence and an extension of that.)

Larry Page happily confirms that suspicion. From the article:

“I wish we’d been more involved in a real debate . . . in Europe. That’s one of the things we’ve taken from this, that we’re starting the process of really going and talking to people” - Larry Page

Translation: "This whole ordeal made us realize we need to do a lot more lobbying in Europe and pay off more media outlets in non-english language markets, since our propaganda there didn't work nearly as well as we had hoped. Don't worry, we're working on it."

At the core of the ECJ decision – whether you consider it good or bad, or hilarious, or plain stupid – lie important questions about what privacy and human dignity mean in this age and how much of them we're willing to give up. These questions deserve more than being drowned in the overwhelming noise of corporate shills.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by ewillbefull on Friday May 30, 2014 @12:57PM (#7822807)
You going to have to come up with a better defense; the "it's just a different culture" and "you wouldn't understand" and "our values are different" does NOT insulate you from criticism. Your 'balance' is poorly reasoned, and should be openly mocked and despised by anyone in western society.

This ruling affects everybody because of its balkanization effect on the Internet. Other than that, I just feel bad for Europeans who throw fundamental human rights away in favor of populism.

Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by yuhong on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:29AM (#7820934)
Yea, are things like removing results from search engines really the right solution to the problem?
Re:Google bows to EU privacy ruling by rmc on Friday May 30, 2014 @07:22AM (#7821163)
There is a potential for abuse with everything.